Eiichi Tanabe, acting general manager of Mitsubishi Corporation’s finance department, declares that the trading company has not accessed the Eurobond markets since 1989 when it issued $1.5 billion of bonds with warrants. It is something of a trick answer – technically correct because the corporation itself has stayed away, but its London financial offshoot and other subsidiaries have remained active, with Mitsubishi Corporation Finance in London having a $12 billion programme of medium-term notes and Eurocommercial paper.
Tanabe describes the last three years as “hectic” with an accompanying sigh that suggests it has been a particularly tough time. But he brightens, declaring: “It has become much easier since March last year. Financial markets have become stabilized, mostly by the government’s decision to provide a capital infusion to aid banks. Japanese investors, and those from overseas, were reassured by the government money. This changed the mood drastically.”
But he concedes that Japan is not yet out of the woods: “The real problem is that the Japanese economy is still sluggish. Although we see good signs of recovery, it is still limited to certain sectors, such as semi-conductors and mobile phones, so it is not really straight up. There is a lot of money here in Japan. We have about ¥1,300 trillion yen in financial assets owned by individuals, but there are few good investments in Japan. The catch phrase for corporate treasurers is cashflow management. We should have free cashflow. That makes them compare with capital investment. Consumption is still low, so there is not such a good prospect for capital investment growth. People are still buying government bonds, even with historically low interest rates”Tanabe and his deputy, Izumi Nemoto, have to live with the fact that Mitsubishi suffered double downgrades in its credit rating in July 1998 and February 1999 from AA- to A- by Standard&Poor’s and to A2 by Moody’s. (Mitsubishi’s short-term paper is still graded P1 and A1.) Nemoto points out that the downgrades came not only at a time of recession but other turmoil, such as the collapse of Long-Term Credit Bank at home and the Russian crisis, all of which highlighted the particular problems of the Japanese trading companies. Tanabe adds: “The rating agencies took a very cautious view of the soga shosha [trading companies] and what they are going to do in the new era of the internet and inevitable disintermediation. At a time of a sluggish Japanese economy, the trading companies are always a kind of index of the economy.”This meant that “spreads on our long-term bonds were hiked to 50 to 60 basis points above Libor. We did not issue. That is too much to pay since we have been issuing under Libor for years. So we went to other institutions, like life insurance companies and regional banks, which had money to invest and knew better that Mitsubishi Corporation was a stable, creditworthy company.” Nemoto chips in that “there is a difference between heaven and hell [between the old and the new rating]”.Tanabe says that although spreads in the Japanese market are almost zero, things are still tougher in the global markets. Nevertheless, Mitsubishi is looking again at the Eurobond markets, but is very aware of the millstone of the low rating, and may hold back and rely on domestic money at Libor. “We wonder if European investors have some appetite for just straight corporate bonds. We know that convertible bonds are a very popular product, but that involves us in questions about issuing equity,” says Tanabe “A few years ago, even with a double-A, it would have been difficult [for us] because of the attitudes of European investors towards Japan and soga shosha, But now I think it is getting better.” Mitsubishi is watching to see the success of the upcoming global IPO by Lawson, the convenience store chain in which the trading company has bought a 20% stake.