US Congress: The scalp-hunters of Capitol Hill

A handful of US congressmen have the IMF and World Bank at their mercy. When it comes to fresh capital or even the subject of US withdrawal, these are the guys who have the casting vote, with a mind to their own re-election. Some, like congressman Sonny Callahan, chairman of the House foreign operations committee, are more supportive than others, who'd prefer the IMF to be shut down and the third world left to market forces. The US Treasury and others with a less parochial view have to tread tortuous paths through Senate and House committees to push through the administration's foreign policy. The multilateral institutions have hung back from lobbying on Capitol Hill, but one day it could be a matter of survival. Brian Caplen reports.

Sonny Callahan, a small businessman from Mobile in Alabama, is not a name that means much to the coterie of finance ministers, bankers and bureaucrats converging on Washington for this year’s annual meetings of the IMF and World Bank. But the omission of Callahan’s name from the “must-see” lists of highly influential people could be a costly mistake.

Callahan, a Republican congressman, has more power over US policy towards the multilaterals and US foreign aid than either president Bill Clinton or secretary of state Madelaine Albright. It may be Clinton and Albright who travel the world, meet government leaders, exchange views about big intellectual ideas and promise billions of dollars in assistance. But it is 67-year-old Callahan, a down-to-earth southerner and a self-confessed “first grader” in the realm of international finance, who signs the cheque.

 
  Gramm:
unconvinced by
IMF’s spotty record

Callahan is chairman of the US House of Representatives’ subcommittee on foreign operations, export financing and related programmes, one of 13 sub-committees making up the all-powerful House appropriations committee. Under “foreign ops”, as it is known on Capitol Hill, falls jurisdiction for funding IMF quota increases, the World Bank’s soft loan window the International Development Association (IDA), other multilateral funding and foreign aid. Foreign ops holds huge sway not only over how much the US administration can spend overseas, but how and where it can use the resources. Put bluntly, a Clinton promise is not worth the breath it is made with if Callahan’s committee cannot be convinced of the project’s merits.

The committee’s role is becoming ever more crucial with growing scepticism in Congress over the usefulness of the IMF and World Bank. The debate has gone far beyond arguments about how much money the multilaterals should receive. It now centres on whether they should exist at all. With the development of an anti-multilateral caucus on the right of the Republican party – in earlier times considered reliable supporters in foreign aid votes – a major defeat on a funding issue is looking ever more likely.

 
Paul:
leave IMF’s job
to the marketplace

The World Bank and the IMF will need to improve their image vastly on Capitol Hill if this is to be avoided. The US Treasury, which has the main administrative responsibility for the multilaterals, is under attack for lacking vision and for failing to sell the multilaterals’ case to Congress. Callahan, who is regarded as a conservative moderate and has rallied support for the multilaterals, feels that the administration takes Congress for granted.

“There is a misconception by many in the administrative branch of government that anytime anybody sits in a room and agrees to something, regardless of their position, that that becomes an obligation of the United States. I have argued with the administration it is not an obligation,” he says. “An agreement with four people sitting in a room to increase contributions [to the multilaterals] is not an obligation.

 
Saxton:
the IMF keeps its doors closed if it can

“Sort of like the Wye agreement,” says Callahan in his southern drawl. He is a man whose unpretentious plain speaking makes no concessions to Washington-style prevarication. “There is a perception now that we have an obligation to Jordan, the PLO and Israel because president Clinton went out to the Wye Plantation and volunteered that he would put up a couple of billion dollars if they would sign a peace agreement. Then they come to me and say this is an obligation of the United States of America.

Aggravation

“Same thing in the international financial community. They sit down and they say ‘we’ll pledge $10 billion of American taxpayer money’ and then they say we’re behind in our dues. We’re not behind. The Congress has never given the authority for that. Sometimes it’s aggravating and I don’t think it’s limited to the Clinton administration but I think they have been a little bit more guilty than other administrations.”

 
Callahan:
Camdessus, make my day

Callahan adds: “I have jokingly told the president and I’ve told the secretary of state, when she’s with the president in a foreign country: ‘please limit the amount of toasts he can make’, because every time he raises his glass then I become obligated for billions of dollars to give to banks, or to give to other countries. If we could just limit the president’s ability to make toasts it would make my job in the Congress easier. These toasts, somehow or other, become, in the eyes of the administration, an obligation. Then, they call me a deadbeat because I’m not paying my bills. I didn’t authorize the bills. The president just promised it.”

Callahan delivered through the House in August, foreign operations bill HR2606 for the financial year 2000 by 385 votes to 35, one of the highest majorities ever recorded for a foreign aid bill. The background against which the bill had to pass was a tough one, with Congress perturbed about a proposed $40 million World Bank loan to China to relocate 58,000 poor Chinese farmers to Qinghai province, an area Tibetans claim as part of their original territory.

The bill, which needed to pass further stages in America’s complicated legislative process in September before becoming law, cut the World Bank’s IDA funding by $232 million, to almost 30% less than the previous year. Callahan insists this was done for purely budgetary reasons. However, this latest multilateral blunder in China cannot have made any easier his job to persuade a recalcitrant House to fall into line.

The result vindicates the Republicans’ decision to pluck Callahan from obscurity and make him chairman of the least attractive appropriations sub-committee. Foreign ops is a real turn-off to an ambitious American politician because of the low priority given to world affairs by the voters. As former House speaker Tip O’Neill famously said: “All politics is local.”

When the Republicans gained control of the House in 1995 after 40 years of Democrat dominance, the party leadership wanted as chairman of foreign ops someone reliable who wouldn’t use it as a soap box for independent ideas and who could deliver the backbench vote. Callahan who has represented Alabama’s first congressional district since 1985 – an area whose conservative traditions are immortalized in such works as Harper Lee’s To Kill A Mockingbird and Alfred Uhry’s Driving Miss Daisy – perfectly fitted the order. Callahan had rarely voted in favour of a foreign aid measure during his time in Congress and was an instinctive sceptic. But he was prepared to listen to professional arguments in favour of continued US support.

“Callahan came in opposed to all foreign aid and got a heavy pitch from the Treasury,” says one Washington-based researcher. “Callahan listened and is now a cautious supporter of the multilaterals.”

In fact, fours years after his appointment, senior Republicans may be wishing he was somewhat less successful. While Callahan has become convinced of the long-term benefits of US involvement in the multilaterals, Republican doubts have spread right to the top of the party. There is concern that international financial institutions (IFIs), particularly the IMF, interfere with the free market, make bad economic situations worse and cost billions of dollars of taxpayers’ money in the process. These right-wing Republicans are joined in their opposition by the strangest of bedfellows – left-wing Democrats who think multilateral action is hurting poor people, trampling on workers’ rights and ruining the environment.

Republican scepticism, however, is the more serious threat to the multilaterals at present. Previously the US administration counted on Republicans to support the establishment in international affairs. If it could get Republican backing for mainstream ventures, there would be insufficient dissenting Democrats to defeat major initiatives. This was the strategy employed to get the North American Trade Agreement (Nafta) in place. But it broke down when the Clinton administration asked for fast-track authority to negotiate overseas trade deals. Now, with presidential authority further weakened by sex scandals and the impeachment saga, this policy is in ruins.

Last year, the administration had to ask Congress to vote on an IMF quota increase at the worse possible time. Relations between the Democratic presidency and the Republican Congress had reached a nadir, while anti-IMF sentiments were strong because of the fund’s perceived role in failing to spot and resolve the emerging market crises developing in Asia and Russia. The quota increase took the longest route possible through Congress, only finally being wrapped up in an omnibus bill. An omnibus bill is often used at the end of the fiscal year (September 30) to push through a variety of legislation that Congress hasn’t managed to approve. With time slipping away major budget items must be approved and unimportant ones, such as IMF quotas, can slip through unopposed – arguing about them at this stage would delay the whole bill and the entire budget. Even so, the IMF quota increase came through littered with amendments from both political wings on such things as the conditions imposed on borrowers and the fund’s transparency.

Change of strategy

“To get NAFTA approved the administration relied on the Republicans and 20% of the Democrats,” says Jerome Levinson, a lawyer who has worked on multilateral legislation for leading House Democrats. “But since the Republicans got control of the Congress the administration has had to change its strategy. A group of about 40 formed on the populist right with no links to multinational corporations [an interest group that tends to lobby in favour of the multilaterals] but allied to small companies and labour. They weren’t willing to go along [with the status quo] and were immune from pressures from the administration and the business roundtable.”

Levinson believes that attitudes are hardening on the left as well, with US policy under attack for being too close to what has been called the Treasury-Wall Street consensus. He says that American labour unions are concerned about manufacturing plant moving to emerging markets where investment restrictions have been removed but labour policies are hardly developed. American labour unions could prove considerably more hostile to the multilaterals in future, he says.

American NGOs have also put sophisticated arguments against the multilaterals concerning such areas as the environment, poverty and human rights. They have successfully lobbied members of Congress to press for changes in the way the multilaterals operate.

In most IFI shareholding countries, the views of legislators are relatively unimportant. Funding decisions are taken by the executive and are never debated by legislators. They don’t have to worry whether Sonny Callahan from Mobile approves or not. But the US Congress, made up of the lower chamber, the House of Representatives, and the upper chamber, the Senate, is different. MJC Vile describes it in his book Politics in the USAas “without doubt, the most powerful representative assembly in the world today”. Vile adds: “This is not merely to reiterate the fact of power and wealth of the United States: it is also a recognition of the fact that, as a legislature, Congress continues to exercise a degree of independent decision-making power far greater than that retained by the other legislatures of western democracies.”

“There is no whip system in US politics, just self-flagellation,” says one congressional observer, referring to members’ independence from party dictates and their eagerness to push individual causes regardless of their relevance to the legislation in hand. Anti-abortion amendments, prohibiting funding for family planning initiatives that promote abortion, are a frequent rider to foreign aid bills and this year’s is no exception.

This means that the US which often has the largest shareholding in the IFIs – 17.78% in the IMF, 16.68% in the IBRD – and frequently pushes for its own policies to be adopted is always the laggard in signing up to agreements made in international forums such as G7 meetings. As Callahan says, just because the G7 leaders think something is a good idea doesn’t mean it’s acceptable to his voters. All the same, this causes enormous bad feeling among other IFI shareholders.

“Country representatives complain about the Treasury and the US government. Oftentimes the US has not met its commitment to the institution but is insistent on getting its policies pushed in the institution,” says Matthew McHugh, counsellor to the president of the World Bank and a former Democratic congressman. “If I were Germany or France I would be annoyed because I am paying my contribution and yet not trying to micromanage the World Bank.”

For multilateral personnel burdened with these problems the outlook is bleak. Congress is set to get more feisty in future as old alliances break down. Forthcoming elections can hardly improve things since anti-multilateral feelings cross party lines. The only positive change would be if the Congress and the presidency were not politically divided, enabling better coordination between the two branches.

But that would not put an end to multilateral misgivings on the populist right of the Republican party. One of its most colourful characters is Ron Paul, a Texan gynaecologist and presidential candidate for the Libertarian party in 1988, who is fervently anti-establishment. During the 1998 struggle over IMF funding Paul introduced a bill calling for the US to withdraw from the institution.

It would be easy, as some political commentators do, to dismiss Paul as unrealistic in his simple view that markets should be left completely to their own devices and that all forms of government interference, including the setting of interest rates by the Federal Reserve, are to be deplored. He is as hostile to corporate welfare as he is to social welfare and he see the IFIs as part of corporate welfare. He is also against IMF bail-outs of foreign economies because he believes the US should not interfere in other countries’ affairs. Similarly he was against NATO’s bombing of Kosovo.

Label Paul as you please – eccentric, isolationist, maverick – yet the voters in 14th congressional district of Texas are convinced his message is the right one. He has been representing them in the House for 10 of the past 25 years, last returning in 1996. Says Paul who unusually for a Congressman gives interviews without back-up from his aides: “I don’t think we should be in it [the IMF]. I don’t think we should be pretending that we know what’s best for other peoples’ economies because it invites the day when somebody else is going to tell us what we ought to do.

“I think they [the multilaterals] are incapable of conducting their affairs properly, fairly and correctly because I don’t think they have the faintest idea of what is good policy… Bureaucrats and politicians don’t know what good policy is and even central bankers, even Alan Greenspan, doesn’t have the vaguest idea what the proper interest rate is or the proper money supply is. Only the market can determine this. I don’t believe in the socialization of money and credit and finance. This should be left to the marketplace.”

Illusion of strength and wealth

Paul believes the emerging market crises of the past two years are symptomatic of central bankers pumping up credit using what he calls fiat currencies. He thinks this is just the beginning of problems that will show up the weaknesses in the current system, which he claims benefits the rich and hurts the poor. “As long as we have this monetary system and we participate in this international system, as long as we have an illusion of strength in our dollar and an illusion of great wealth, we will be tempted to bail out Russia and all these countries. These aren’t bail-outs. These are just pumping up business interests that get benefits.

“Banks benefit from all this stuff. The little people never benefit from World Bank and IMF mischief. It’s always the politicians and our bankers and our business people who benefit. The notion that World Bank investments in third world countries help poor people is pretty remote.”

If Paul were a lone figure on America’s political fringe, then the IMF needn’t have bothered commissioning major reports looking at its external relations operation and how it deals with Congress – reports which have recently been sent to the fund’s board. The IMF is right to be worried because scepticism about its role extends to the upper echelons of the Republican party. The leadership is at best opposed and relatively inert, an example being Senator Jesse Helms, chairman of the foreign relations committee; at worst it is convinced that the IMF’s case is a marginal one that they might not support in future.

This is the position of veteran senator Phil Gramm who says: “I think it is clear that in the Asian financial crisis the IMF has done very marginal work. It’s not clear that their prescriptions have been correct.”

Then there are those who have actively investigated the IMF, have been unimpressed by what they found and have campaigned for reform. Jim Saxton, vice chairman of the Joint Economic Committee, and a close ally of House majority leader Richard Armey, is in this camp. His continuing crusade for greater IMF openness has provoked considerable consternation at the fund. Saxton is seen by many as a stalking horse for Armey and, indeed, a request for an interview with Armey about the IMF was referred to Saxton’s office.

Armey, who represents the 26th district of Texas, is a Republican populist. But, unlike Paul, he is centre stage and is credited, along with Newt Gingrich, with engineering the Republican win in 1994. Armey came to Washington in 1984, declaring that he hated government. Since then he has fearlessly attacked farm subsidies, and supported immigration and flat taxes. By contrast, attacking multilaterals is a soft option.

Saxton is a former school teacher and small businessman who has represented the third congressional district of New Jersey since 1984. The joint economic committee (JEC) is a strange animal even by the standards of the US Congress. It straddles both chambers yet has no legislative ability. The JEC can investigate issues and hold hearings and its perceived importance depends on the chair’s ability to make noise. Saxton has been effective at making a great deal of noise and the IMF must rue the day in 1997 when he got on its case. He still refuses to give it up.

The thrust of Saxton’s complaints is that the IMF lacks transparency, doesn’t lend at market rates of interest and that the US’s true equity position in the fund is understated. Lately he has come out against proposals to sell gold to provide relief for highly indebted countries as agreed at the G7 meeting in Cologne in June. Reflecting the angry mood of Congress, together with the lobbying efforts of the World Gold Council and gold producers such as South Africa, this initiative is now almost certain not to pass – again showing the increased willingness of Congress to flex its muscles. The IMF has already started looking at other ways to finance debt relief.

A press release issued by the JEC in July states: “Transparency in the IMF finances is needed simply because the IMF is a publicly funded institution in which the US assumes a major financing and policy role. However, IMF financial activities are cloaked in an obscure accounting system designed in an era when the nature of IMF activities was very different from what it is today. Even the public financial statements of the IMF are confusing, as reflected in the inaccurate statements of a member of the IMF executive board before Congress last summer. While confusion about the IMF’s public financial statements is quite understandable given their format, another problem is that the operational budget of the IMF is treated as a classified document.”

The board member referred to in that press release is US executive director of the fund Karin Lissakers. She came off rather badly in a grilling by Saxton at a congressional hearing. Says a former congressional staffer who now works in a multilateral: “These hearings are great occasions for theatre. Lissakers probably made the mistake of treating it as a serious intellectual exercise rather than as a witch hunt.”

Even the act of persuading someone from the IMF to testify on Capitol Hill was a political event. Congress first asked for a staff member knowing, say close followers of congressional politics, that the IMF would refuse and would look as if it wasn’t co-operating. Multilateral policy is not to allow its staff to testify in the US Congress. “If we sent someone up to Capitol Hill to testify then we would also have to send someone to every other parliament around the world,” says an IMF executive. Managing director Michel Camdessus and other professional staff did hold informal meetings with Congress members last year to explain the IMF’s position, but the fund held firm on the no testifying policy.

The US executive director, however, takes instructions from the administration, chiefly the Treasury. At first the US Treasury also refused to allow Lissakers to testify but repented after two Congress members sent a complaining letter to then Treasury secretary Robert Rubin. Spencer Bachus, chairman of the House banking oversight subcommittee, said at the time: “I think it is indefensible for the department to withhold the US executive director from the Congress and the American people. Previous administrations have permitted the executive director to testify before Congress and it is even more critical in this instance. The IMF operates like an elite private club but spends public money. You can’t ask the American people to give billions in US taxpayer money to this institution without a closer look at how it works.”

Questioned

When Lissakers eventually showed up at the IMF hearing of the banking oversight subcommittee (not the JEC hearing) in April last year, she was questioned by Saxton on the IMF shareholding countries holding their quotas in the form of non-negotiable or non-interest bearing securities rather than cash and whether these were held on the asset or liability side of the balance sheet.

After first answering that the fund doesn’t have securities or promissory notes, Lissakers then agreed that it did hold some. She then said that these were held on the liability side of the balance sheet, but later agreed that they were under assets. At one stage Saxton asked her: “…is this accounting system a transparent system, do you believe?” She replied: “I confess it is not fully transparent to me as a layman in this area…”

Saxton said in an interview with Euromoney in August: “[The accounting system of the IMF] is obscure to be sure. When I started to examine the IMF a couple of years ago and thought I was going to examine it in some depth, the first thing I learned was that I couldn’t examine it in depth because the doors were closed. To the extent that they can continue to keep the doors closed, they do. I must say that we know more now than we did several years ago because we have continually tried to prise the doors open. But they certainly do operate under a veil of secrecy. We had Karin Lissakers at a hearing and we asked her questions that she really couldn’t answer.” Lissakers did not want to comment on the congressional hearing but did say: “Congress plays a positive role in requiring the IMF and World Bank to be accountable.”

Backward PR

For sure, hearings on Capitol Hill are politically inspired, but Saxton’s campaign on transparency in the fund has produced a lot of genuine material. Even fund supporters in Washington complain about a lack of disclosure and give some credit to Saxton for improving things.

Says James Orr, executive director of the Bretton Woods Committee, which backs the World Bank and IMF: “The IMF thinks like a central bank – even the phone book is classified. You can’t get an IMF phone book. They are backward in the PR area and are trying to revamp it after the problems on the Hill last year.”

Saxton has put considerable resources into his investigation, with research staff digging into the fund’s activities. His committee asked the US General Accounting Office (GAO) to look into the fund’s finances. A GAO report released in July came up with the finding that only $92 billion of a total $287 billion in resources is unusable.

Says the report: “For the financial year ended April 30, 1999, the IMF had about $287 billion in resources in its General Resources Account (GRA) obtained primarily from members’ quotas. However, from the GRA the IMF could use only about $195 billion, that is, the amount from members that are sufficiently strong economically to permit their currencies to be used for IMF operations. The remaining $92 billion was unusable for lending as it consisted of member currencies in weak positions and gold, which the IMF does not consider to be a liquid resource. Of the usable amount, about $118 billion had been lent, committed, or reserved, leaving about $77 billion available for additional credit to IMF members and to meet members drawing on their reserves held by the IMF.”

Says Saxton: “As I said over and over during the last debate that we had here when the IMF ultimately received, much to my chagrin, another $18 billion of American taxpayers money