After almost 20 years of discussions, the UAE looks set to have a properly regulated stock exchange by the end of the year. For bankers such as Khalid Kalban, general manager of Dubai Investments, who have campaigned for this since the early 1980s, there is still a whiff of unreality about it all. In the past, says Kalban: “Every time it looked like becoming a reality, something happened that stopped it.”
However, it looks increasingly likely that an official exchange will finally be created and replace the volatile and unregulated over-the-counter market. Although no clear-cut schedule has yet been announced, legislation and a structure have been agreed, encouraging bankers such as Kalban to believe that the new structure may be fully in place by the end of the year.
This will not be a moment too soon. The UAE needs a well-managed, stable capital market if it is to make the most of the dramatic shift in policy whereby the private sector is now to take a dominant role in the UAE’s economic development.
This in part reflects the mood swing across the Gulf that the state should act more as a regulator and less as an owner in the region’s evolution. It is also driven by necessity. To limit the impact of the fall in oil prices, governments have to find ways to cut spending.
According to Sultan bin Nasser al-Suwaidi, the UAE central bank governor, the shifting of projects from the public to the private sector is needed for economic reasons. “Some government services are subsidized,” he says. “While there was a reason for that two or three decades ago, the present living standards in the Gulf today are among the highest in the world. Shifting these services and projects to the private sector can save governments large sums of badly needed money.”
He continues: “The government should not be involved in agriculture, mining, housing, communications, manufacturing, health and even higher education. The private sector is capable of undertaking and financing all kinds of projects in these areas and should use its potential to rise to the challenge”.
Abu Dhabi, the largest and wealthiest of the seven emirates that make up the UAE, is using private capital to build water and electricity projects that previously had been the preserve of the state, and, in the longer term, will want to issue shares to nationals through the stock exchange.
Dubai has taken the lead in setting up companies to develop residential and industrial projects – these companies are both quoted on the exchange and keen to make strategic investments in quoted companies.
The persistent delays in establishing a regulated stock market have been caused by disagreements between Abu Dhabi and Dubai and also the fear, exacerbated by the Asian crash, that the UAE would become more vulnerable to international speculation. Although there is no agreement to allow foreign investors to own shares directly in the UAE exchange, it is accepted that this would follow sooner rather than later once a properly regulated exchange was established.
The increasing role of the private sector means that the UAE, like other Gulf states, has in the last five years become hungry for capital. Much of the region’s wealth is still exported and invested in stable, better regulated markets in Europe and the US. Attempts to create regional equity funds, such as the Emirates Equity Fund, were initially successful but were then hit by the extreme volatility of Gulf stock exchanges.
According to one study by the Abu Dhabi Chamber of Commerce, the creation of a trading floor would “attract the savings of UAE nationals from abroad to be reinvested in the national economy. It would also contribute to the widening of the asset and ownership base”.
The UAE has one of the largest and most dynamic equity markets in the Gulf but it is conducted over the counter among brokers located mainly in Dubai and Abu Dhabi. There are fears that, unless it is properly constituted, the market will develop, as it has in Saudi Arabia, as a country-wide electronic trading system without a much-needed regulatory framework.
The credibility of the UAE’s over-the-counter market has suffered from the lack of a settlement, clearing and custody system. This, say bankers, has left it highly unregulated, devoid of transparency and subject to extensive manipulation.
The move to resolve this follows 18 months of erratic stock-market performance and growing concerns that additional damage could be done to local banks, investors and businesses. The UAE market has fallen more than 10% this year. This followed a year in which prices rose 51% in the first eight months – some stocks more than doubled in price – and then plunged 20% in two weeks.
Between the beginning of September 1998 and the end of the year, market capitalization fell from Dh181.9 billion ($49.6 billion) to Dh117 billion. Earlier that year the central bank warned that “the share prices of some companies are inflated and could not be justified by future expectations”.
As the market fell, investor confidence disintegrated. Local banks were left with an estimated $820 million in bad debts, which, according to the Beirut-based Middle East Capital Group, prompted fears that the UAE could be heading for a crash similar to the 1982 Soukh al-Manakh crisis in Kuwait. Up to a third of all recent share offerings were paid for by investors taking out bank loans.
Towards an official bourse
Evidence of the government’s determination to ensure that this could not happen again came this July with the announcement that the official stock exchange would be based in Abu Dhabi and be linked electronically with floors in other emirates.
Formal legislation is awaiting final approval following the agreement on a draft law by the cabinet in November last year. Bankers say that the main benefit of the legislation, which will establish the exchange as a federal entity, is that it will make abuses of the system much more difficult.
The exchange’s monitoring authority will be financially and administratively independent and separated from the market operators. Trading will be limited to licensed brokers, dealing from trading floors linked by computer systems.
Dubai and Abu Dhabi are making preparations to set up trading floors. Bankers say Dubai is likely to anticipate the UAE-wide exchange by opening its floor by October with a local regulatory authority. Abu Dhabi has established a committee to study the setting up of a trading floor equipped with state-of-the-art technology.
“There will be major gains from the increase in transparency. This will restore a lot of confidence and trust in the market by restricting the possibility that there will be any manipulation of prices,” says Mashreq Bank’s chief executive Abdul-Aziz al-Ghurair.
Bankers in Dubai and Abu Dhabi are confident that that there will be plenty of investors. An initial public offering for the Abu Dhabi Islamic Bank attracted 220,000 subscribers. A stable and well-managed stock exchange is also important to the new breed of strategic investors which is playing an increasingly important role in developing the economy in Dubai.
Dubai Investments, for example, has identified specific sectors, including food and beverages, light manufacturing and pharmaceuticals, where it believes local production can replace imports. “We have put money into different ventures. While we are long-term strategic investors, we would like to divest at some stage and the best way to do this is through the stock exchange,” says Kalban.
The determination of the UAE to become a financial centre is also shown by its plans to develop the Saadiyat free zone. In July the Abu Dhabi Free Zone Authority gave the Emirates Global Capital Corporation (EGCC) a 50-year concession to develop a futures and options exchange, a commodities exchange and a clearing house as well as a depository for commodities and raw materials.
Of EGCC’s initial paid-up capital of $3.3 billion, some $400 million is coming from the Abu Dhabi government and $165 million each from two local and two international financial institutions. A total of $1.65 billion will be raised through a domestic and international IPO. Nomura International is responsible for the international tranche and the National Bank of Abu Dhabi for the local side. The remaining $590 million will come from other founder shareholders.
The benefits of establishing these markets should spread through the whole economy. As well as attracting money back to the region, bankers believe it would change the savings culture in a country where the main tendency is to spend money on consumption or property development.
A well-regulated capital market would also provide a source of long-term funds for companies. There should also be benefits for banks and for insurance companies, which want to pick up long-term assets and liabilities.
At present, many banks are flush with funds with the result that there are mismatches. That problem would be eased if investors put their money directly into a capital market. According to one banker: “Liabilities are between three and six months while assets are from five to 10 years. There is a potential recipe for disaster with high levels of lending at cheap rates.”
The risks inherent in these mismatches have worried the central bank, which in recent years has shown a greater readiness to intervene to stop potential threats to the stability of the banking system.
Bankers say it has done so without suffocating the market through oppressive regulations. Last year, for example, al-Suwaidi acted quickly to ensure that the volatility of the over-the-counter market did not get out of control.
To moderate such lending and ensure that customers rather than the banks took the bulk of the risk, the central bank raised the margin requirements for share purchases. This was hiked from 20% to 50% for initial public offerings for companies that have been trading for less than five years and to 30% for companies that have been trading for longer than five years.
Al-Suwaidi, who has been central bank governor for eight years, has established a strong reputation in the region for the way he has brought order to what was once a fragile banking system. He has enforced much-needed federal standards on a country where individual emirates jealously guard their own powers.
“The central bank has played a critical role in monitoring, advising and regulating banks. The governor has also improved the quality of the staff work at the bank,” says al-Ghurair. The governor now believes that there is the right balance of commercial freedom and regulatory control to ensure that any problems facing individual financial institutions will not destabilize the system. He has also been quick to use his authority to dampen rumours that might have damaged otherwise stable banks.
The latest measure, introduced last year, makes it compulsory for all banks to use international accounting standards. That followed the introduction of 10% capital ratios, 2% higher than Bank for International Settlements (BIS) levels, a decision taken because the local market is not as deep as, say, those in western Europe.
Other regulations included stricter reporting standards and closer monitoring of loans as well as requirements related to lending and fees and stricter vetting of those taking senior bank positions.
The benefits of this strategy have been seen during the past 18 months. The banking system has come through relatively unscathed from the pressures caused by the financial crises in Asia and Russia and the collapse in oil prices, which was responsible for a 26.2% drop in oil GDP in the UAE last year.
In the past, these challenges would have caused serious problems to traders and their bankers. Dubai in particular would have been vulnerable to the fall in Russian business, which has shown little sign of recovery. For example, in 1998 Russia accounted for only 5% of textile business compared with 30% a year previously and the electrical goods market has slumped by 10% to 15% a year over the past two years.
Dubai has in part been protected from the worst effects of this slump because it has found new trading partners in recent years. Leading businessmen, such as Sultan bin Sulayem, chairman of the Jebel Ali Free Zone and managing director of the Dubai Ports Authority, believe that the re-exports to newer markets such as Iran, India and Africa will compensate in part for the fall in Russian trade.
Most important, the banking system itself has not suffered from the country’s economic problems. This is seen in the UAE as evidence of the central bank’s success in rating corporate borrowers effectively and not allowing banks to become overexposed to individuals. Foreign banks based in the UAE were worst affected by a case of alleged fraud in which one business customer disappeared, accused of taking Dh1 billion from several banks across the country.
Despite the commercial pressures, which have been accentuated by a year in which growth is expected to be flat following a 5.6% fall in real GDP last year, bankers are expecting another successful year.
“People were pessimistic at the start of the year but fears have evaporated and we expect to do at least as well as last year,” says al-Ghurair. This confidence is reflected in the banks’ performances. The instance of delays in payments on loans and bad loans are at standard international levels of 6% and 1% respectively while the 1998 profits of the 27 foreign and 20 local financial institutions rose to Dh4.3 billion, a 12% rise on the previous year’s figure.
Some local bankers say there are too many banks. But there is little pressure for mergers while they are all making money. Mergers in the UAE tend to happen when banks run into financial difficulties and are bailed out by the individual emirate governments which act as de facto lenders of last resort.
Five large banks, the National Bank of Abu Dhabi (NBAD), the National Bank of Dubai (NBD), Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank (ADCB), Mashreq Bank and Emirates Bank International (EBI) dominate the market, holding more than half total bank assets and 70% of local bank assets. At least 10 of the remaining 15 local institutions have a less than 1% market share.
The NBAD, bankers to the Abu Dhabi government, which owns a 72% stake in the institution, is the UAE’s largest bank with $9.6 billion total assets and is highly respected by international rating agencies. According to Cyprus-based Capital Intelligence, the bank’s sovereign rating reflects its “ownership by the Abu Dhabi government, its large branch network, good management and overall sound financial position.
“NBAD’s considerable reach within the country has helped it to build an important customer-driven business base. Its large international operations also make a useful contribution to the bottom line. The bank’s asset quality is sound. It is adequately capitalized and its liquidity is supported by substantial deposits placed by public-sector institutions.”
A switch to value-added
Competition for the lending market will remain intense but is likely to change in character as the emphasis switches to services and investment banking. “At present, there is intense competition and spreads are reducing. The future is in offering value-added services. The charges may be higher but the services will be better,” says al-Ghurair.
One area that the banks are keen to extend is investment banking. Emirates Bank and the Abu Dhabi Investment Company, for example, are among the banks to set up equity funds. There are also opportunities for such innovative institutions as the Dubai-based Cupola, which is attracting investors into capital markets across the region and taking stakes directly in consumer and industrial projects.
Emirates Bank has set up a Dh183.5 million joint-venture investment company with Bank Austria, which will invest in medium-size Austrian firms trading or doing business in the Middle East. The fund, in which Emirates Bank holds 75%, is targeted at institutional and high-net-worth individual investors and will focus on companies involved in solar energy, information technology, irrigation, oil separation, remote telemetry and engineering.
“We will invest at the initial stage and then divest after five years,” says Suresh Kumar, general manager of Emirates Financial Services, the merchant banking arm of Emirates Bank. “The AAA-rated fund has been guaranteed by the Austrian government and we are looking at internal rates of return of 25% a year. The fund is of the nature of venture capital and can grow later.”
The continued stability of the banking sector will be crucial as the UAE continues to diversify from its dependence on oil. Abu Dhabi does not want to be totally reliant on a commodity whose price is extremely volatile, and in Dubai diversification is needed as its oil reserves run out early in the next century.
Abu Dhabi and particularly Dubai are reaping the rewards from the massive capital investment programmes of recent years. Their sophisticated ports and competitively priced and marketed free zones are enabling the UAE to develop as a manufacturing and re-export centre.
Manufacturing expansion
Manufacturing alone now contributes more than 12% to GDP compared with less than 1% in 1975. More than 1,400 companies are based in the Jebel Ali Free Zone. There is also a zone for light-industrial and high-technology companies at Dubai airport, which has been successful in attracting international blue-chip companies such as Rolls-Royce, IBM, Porsche and Boeing. In 2001, the Jebel Ali and Dubai Airport zones will be joined by the Gulf’s first tax-free commodities storage zone in Saadiyat island in Abu Dhabi.
Much infrastructure development is still a government responsibility. Early next year, the $540 million modernization of Dubai’s international airport will be completed. Abu Dhabi is investing $630 million in airports in the capital and second city Al Ain. Other projects under way, or being considered, include a new container terminal at Mina Zayed, a $120 million expansion of the Abu Dhabi shipbuilding yard and a $117 million pediatrics hospital in Abu Dhabi.
But this activity does not disguise a shift away from publicly funded projects. Dubai’s government is sponsoring private-sector companies that will play a more important role in undertaking projects which previously would have been a state-sector preserve.
Dubai Investments, whose shareholders include the government of Dubai and many of the emirate’s leading businessmen, is de-veloping the first privately owned business park in the Middle East. It is committing a total of $150 million towards building an infrastructure that will include executive and staff accommodation and an 18-hole golf course. The park will be located in the most rapidly expanding part of the emirate on the road between Dubai and Abu Dhabi.
Also in the area are two major projects developed by Emaar. Emirates Hills is a 400-home property development that includes restaurants, shopping and leisure facilities and two first-class golf courses. Over the next decade, the Westside Marina development will become a full residential and commercial city with a yachting marina at its heart.
The emphasis on quality accommodation and leisure facilities reflects Dubai’s determination to provide the facilities that will attract international businesses. They can set up distribution centres and headquarters which are responsible not just for the region but have easy access to south Asia and Africa.
The quality and quantity of the golf courses and other sporting attractions, such as the world’s most valuable horse race, also show the way Dubai has diversified its economy into tourism, which now earns $550 million a year from 1.8 million visitors.
In the past 12 months more than 1,100 top-class rooms have come on the market, bringing the total in the emirate to more than 4,900. That means Dubai now can host some of the biggest international conferences and exhibitions.
Dubai is also trying to build its industrial base, with Dubai Aluminium (Dubal) set to become one of the largest smelters in the world when production rises to 536,000 tonnes next month. Last year Dubal exported $670 million-worth of aluminium.
Abu Dhabi remains the major industrial emirate. Following a management restructuring at the Abu Dhabi National Oil Company, it is now focusing on value-added downstream oil and gas projects such as refined oil and petrochemicals. While the oil sector remains the preserve of the state, the government is ready to involve the private sector on a build-operate-transfer basis in all other aspects of industrial development.
All new power-generation plants will be joint ventures between a foreign partner, holding 40%, and the Abu Dhabi Water and Electricity Authority, whose initial 60% holding will be reduced as shares are sold on the stock exchange to UAE nationals.
Eventually the whole generation and distribution side of these industries will be privatized. The first step was taken with the appointment of CMS Energy of the US as part owner/operator of the Taweelah A2 water and power project. CMS and the other five prequalified bidders have been invited to bid for the Taweelah A1 project.