Liability Management: Borrowers’ vote – Commodities

Liability Management: Borrowers' vote - Results Index Page

Liability Management: Borrowers’ vote – Results Index Page

Base metals
99 98 Score
1 – Barclays Capital 5
Precious metals
99 98 Score
1 4= J Aron 7
2= – JP Morgan 6
2= 3 Warburg Dillon Read 6
4 – Republic National Bank of New York 5
Reversing trades & fair value on instruments previously sold
99 98 Score
1 – JP Morgan 64
2 – Deutsche Bank 45
3 – Chase Manhattan Bank 43
4= – General Re 26
4= – Goldman Sachs 26
6 – Citibank/Salomon Smith Barney 23
7 – Warburg Dillon Read 22
8= – Dresdner Kleinwort Benson 15
8= – Merrill Lynch Derivative Products 15
10 – Credit Suisse Financial Products 14
11= – ABN Amro 12
11= – Morgan Stanley Dean Witter 12
11= – RBC Dominion Securities 12
14 – Bank of America 11
15 – AIG International 10
16 – Banque Nationale de Paris 9
17 – CIBC Wood Gundy 8
18= – Crédit Agricole Indosuez 6
18= – Fortis Bank 6
18= – HSBC 6
21= – Banque Paribas 5
21= – Barclays Capital 5
21= – Lehman Brothers 5
21= – Standard Chartered Bank 5
Complex risk management structures
99 98 Score
1 1 JP Morgan 107
2 5 Goldman Sachs 52
3 4 Chase Manhattan Bank 51
4 12 Citibank/Salomon Smith Barney 45
5 * Deutsche Bank 43
6 13 Morgan Stanley Dean Witter 37
7 7 ABN Amro 31
8 14 General Re 26
9 2 Warburg Dillon Read 23
10 11 Greenwich NatWest 15
11 9 Credit Suisse Financial Products 14
12= 8 Merrill Lynch Derivative Products 13
12= 27= RBC Dominion Securities 13
14 30= Banque Nationale de Paris 12
15 10 HSBC 11
16= 21= Barclays Capital 10
16= – DG Bank 10
18= 30= AIG International 8
18= – Banco Espirito Santo & Comercial de Lisboa 8
18= 30= Banque Paribas 8
18= 21= CIBC Wood Gundy 8
18= 30= Standard Chartered Bank 8
23= 16= Bank of America 6
23= – Tokai Bank 6
* Deutsche Bank ranked 6, BT Alex Brown 16=
** MeesPierson ranked 21=

Liability Management: Borrowers’ vote – Results Index Page