Liability Management: Borrowers' vote - Commodities

Liability Management: Borrowers’ vote – Results Index Page

Base metals
99	98		*Score*
1	–	Barclays Capital	5
Precious metals
99	98		*Score*
1	4=	J Aron	7
2=	–	JP Morgan	6
2=	3	Warburg Dillon Read	6
4	–	Republic National Bank of New York	5
Reversing trades & fair value on instruments previously sold
99	98		*Score*
1	–	JP Morgan	64
2	–	Deutsche Bank	45
3	–	Chase Manhattan Bank	43
4=	–	General Re	26
4=	–	Goldman Sachs	26
6	–	Citibank/Salomon Smith Barney	23
7	–	Warburg Dillon Read	22
8=	–	Dresdner Kleinwort Benson	15
8=	–	Merrill Lynch Derivative Products	15
10	–	Credit Suisse Financial Products	14
11=	–	ABN Amro	12
11=	–	Morgan Stanley Dean Witter	12
11=	–	RBC Dominion Securities	12
14	–	Bank of America	11
15	–	AIG International	10
16	–	Banque Nationale de Paris	9
17	–	CIBC Wood Gundy	8
18=	–	Crédit Agricole Indosuez	6
18=	–	Fortis Bank	6
18=	–	HSBC	6
21=	–	Banque Paribas	5
21=	–	Barclays Capital	5
21=	–	Lehman Brothers	5
21=	–	Standard Chartered Bank	5
Complex risk management structures
99	98		*Score*
1	1	JP Morgan	107
2	5	Goldman Sachs	52
3	4	Chase Manhattan Bank	51
4	12	Citibank/Salomon Smith Barney	45
5	*	Deutsche Bank	43
6	13	Morgan Stanley Dean Witter	37
7	7	ABN Amro	31
8	14	General Re	26
9	2	Warburg Dillon Read	23
10	11	Greenwich NatWest	15
11	9	Credit Suisse Financial Products	14
12=	8	Merrill Lynch Derivative Products	13
12=	27=	RBC Dominion Securities	13
14	30=	Banque Nationale de Paris	12
15	10	HSBC	11
16=	21=	Barclays Capital	10
16=	–	DG Bank	10
18=	30=	AIG International	8
18=	–	Banco Espirito Santo & Comercial de Lisboa	8
18=	30=	Banque Paribas	8
18=	21=	CIBC Wood Gundy	8
18=	30=	Standard Chartered Bank	8
23=	16=	Bank of America	6
23=	–	Tokai Bank	6
* Deutsche Bank ranked 6, BT Alex Brown 16=
** MeesPierson ranked 21=