Macquarie’s winning ways

Macquarie Bank is a rare type of investment bank. It has made returns on equity of over 20% for 10 years by constantly moving into new business areas such as property securitization. Steven Irvine meets its managing director Allen Moss - a man who eschews ostentation and wears pens in his pocket - and head of infrastructure and asset group Nicholas Moore.

Where Macquarie makes its money
Asset & infrastructure 35%
Treasury & commodities 26%
Corporate finance 11%
Banking and property 10%
Investment services 9%
Equities 9%
Direct investment 0%
Profit (half year to Sept 1998) A$80.5m (+25%)
Source: Macquarie

You said recently that commercial banks can’t do investment banking. Can you elaborate?

Allan Moss: Commercial banks find it very hard to maintain a commitment to investment banking. Historically you can see a number of cycles. In the 1970s and 1980s as well as in the 1990s commercial banks have moved into and out of investment banking. The reasons they’ve moved in is – superficially at least – because margins sometimes look attractive and they are responding to what they perceive to be a threat of competition from investment banks. The reason they move out is because there are major cultural differences, they often find risk management quite challenging, and find it too distracting from a management perspective and ultimately not worth the effort. This is especially true of commercial banks that are mainly retail banks, because it is such a different business to investment banking. It’s very challenging to integrate wholesale investment banking with broad-based consumer services because the sort of skills and approach which are needed to be successful are somewhat different.

Nicholas Moore: There is however a conventional wisdom that we are moving towards a world of maybe five global banks that will incorporate the whole range of financial services – investment banking and commercial banking included.

We have to remember that it was only 12 years ago that people thought that Japanese banks were going to dominate the world.

But surely if there is disintermediation of the commercial banks by bond markets they must enter investment banking?
Moss:
Commercial banks need to redefine their roles. The successful ones, such as Lloyds, are focusing on the consumer. They’re making most of their money out of providing services to consumers. That model seems to make a lot of sense. Margins are going to be very thin at the wholesale end. You can charge people at the consumer end because consumers are willing to pay for convenience and there are a lot of them. That’s why Lloyds is doing so well.

Moore: It’s a question of scale. A commercial bank is a basic production business. Commercial banking like making motor cars will be a question of who can get the unit cost down. That’s all commercial bankers talk about now: how much does it cost to process a mortgage, how much to process an account. And that’s all about scale. Someone like Virgin could take them on, but they’ve got to get the customers, get the systems, get the scale. Once you’re in the game you tend to be like Microsoft, you get bigger rather than smaller.

Moss: We’ve got a long way to go in terms of the consolidation of financial services. If you compare it to most other major international industries – oil, computers, cars – consolidation has barely begun.

But consolidation should exclude mergers of commercial banks and investment banks?

Moss: The successful consolidation will be mergers of commercial banks. It’s true of almost every industry in the world that the people who are doing well are becoming global products specialists, whether its chemicals or motor cars. The conglomerate model is widely accepted to be outdated.

What about the argument for conglomerates: the diversification of earnings streams?

Moore: If you’re a commercial bank and you’re not good at investment banking, you’re not going to make money there. It’s a binary sort of industry. You either make a lot of money, or you make nothing.

Moss: There’s no evidence that diversification of income streams in financial services reduces cost of capital. The diversification argument has been discredited and that’s why industrial conglomerates have been broken up around the world.

You spoke about new entrants lacking scale to compete. But you entered the Australian mortgage market through securitization and shook up the big four commercial banks. You took 5% of Australian mortgages almost overnight.

Moore: That’s true. We obtained the level of scale to survive. Just. There’s no doubt, however, that if Commonwealth Bank were running our portfolio we’d be making more money. They can process cheaper than us.

But you performed a useful economic function. You brought down cartelized rates.

Moore: We did. We halved mortgage margins in this country. It wasn’t necessarily that we were more efficient than the major trading banks. It was just that we were less greedy.

There will be niche areas where the mass providers of financial services get too greedy – there’s no question about that. People like us coming in and doing securitization will help to keep the major trading banks honest. But as a generalization, the successful commercial banks will focus globally on retail financial services.

You run a very dynamic institution. You currently have 47 business units.

Moore: If we have 47 businesses today we’re going to have more than 47 in the future. Some businesses we have today are dead. At the ground level and the executive level people are always looking for new opportunities. New businesses (less than five years old) contribute 30% to profits.

How fast has the number of business units grown?

Moss: In 1987 we had 25 units, so there has been a near doubling in 12 years. In the last five years we have added 10 units.

How do you decide a business is no longer viable?

Moss: It’s a matter of business judgement and understanding what is going on in the business. There’s no easy rule of thumb. One of the few businesses we shut down was our government bond desk. It was clear there that despite trying hard we were not going to achieve a sufficient market position to make the business worthwhile in terms of risk reward.

What return on capital was that business making?

Moore: Actually we were losing money.

Moss: We’ll support infant businesses for a long time. We’ve got an excellent metals trading business now, dealing copper, zinc, aluminium and gold. When we moved into that it took us five years to make any kind of decent money. But we felt we were on the right track so we persisted with it.

Moore: If the people in the businesses themselves aren’t making money they’ll tend to move out of it. Maybe that’s the investment-banking culture.

Which business has the highest return on capital?

Moss: There are a number of businesses which use very little capital. The asset and infrastructure group, the M&A business, the funds management business.

When you’re in a board meeting do you have a list of the businesses with numbers beside them stating the return on capital? This is 33%, this is 12%.

Moss: No we don’t have anything like that although we do think about it.

Moore: Our capital is the people. Our business is about people power. Our shareholder funds are A$600 million. Our market cap is A$2.8 billion. So the real capital is what you have in the room here.

Moss: Return on equity has consistently been over 20% after tax even though we approach the return on capital issue very informally.

In Australia you are regarded as being one step ahead of the curve. How have you managed to foster innovation in your ranks?

Moss: The big thing is to create a sense of ownership. Almost everybody has the capacity for innovation in some degree. It’s just important to tap into that capacity by giving them a sense of ownership. Our loose-tight management structure gives business leaders a lot of freedom within appropriate risk management controls. We don’t move people around – almost never unless they want to move. And we reward people on the basis of performance.

People understand that if they do well and expand their business, they’ll be a beneficiary of it.

Moore: In the UK three years ago we started infrastructure advisory work. I was there two weeks ago and was reliably informed we have the best group in the marketplace. We’ve gone in three years from nowhere. Why are we the best group? Not because of me, not because of Allan Moss – well, of course, because of Allan Moss – but because we’ve got a guy called Stephen Allen and Steve wanted to be a hero and said he wanted to go to London and set up an aircraft-financing business so we said fine. Off you go. Go forth and multiply. As Allan Moss once put it – let a thousand flowers bloom.

You have a high retention rate?

Moss: It would be true to say that everyone on the executive committee has been at Macquarie Bank for more than 10 years.

How does your remuneration system work?

Moss: For the top 60 executive directors bonuses vest over 10 years. Share options run over five years and as far as the executive directors are concerned there are extra conditions. The options are exercisable only if return on equity targets are met for the bank as a whole. These target ROEs are based on a rolling three-year average.

So people are very heavily tied in?

Moss: Yes.

Who do you think you look like in the investment-banking world?

Moss: We think we’re quite like Goldman Sachs or like Morgan Stanley before its merger with Dean Witter – obviously leaving aside issue of scale.

You’ve diversified into some very non-investment banking businesses like car leasing

Moore : And golf courses.

Moss: We have a joint venture with Greg Norman. It’s really to develop residential properties around the edges of golf courses, but to do that you have to have a golf course so you develop the golf course as well. This is part of our property investment banking business. But 95% of our business is traditional investment banking. A few of our businesses are at the margin.

Do you make acquisitions?

Moss: We made a couple of small acquisitions. One is a leading Brisbane retail broker and a retail broker in Western Australia. At the moment there are no major acquisition opportunities that are of any interest to us.

Would you be loath to acquire internationally?

Moss: We had a look around Asia 12 months ago. The businesses that were available and cheap we didn’t want, and the ones that were attractive were too expensive in our view.

What stops your very successful business heads going off and setting up on their own?

Moss: The bank has to give value to its employees. In order to keep the team together people like me have to give value to the employees. There’s a sense in which people report to me, but there’s also a sense in which management provides a service. Management has to give value. Nicholas has to help people get deals done. I provide risk management, which most people would say is a value-adding service. By providing good risk management I help to preserve the bank’s reputation which gives entry to clients. Also my job is make sure support services are effective and that there is a fair deal between the shareholders and the staff.

What are the Australian characteristics that differentiate you from an American investment bank

Moss: We’re probably softer. On Wall Street the market tanks and they’ll fire 5% of the staff. We have never done that and don’t think we ever would. It’s not part of our culture to undertake wholesale sackings. People tend to be more loyal and longer-serving as a result.

In an energetic go-getting organization like this there must be a lot of scope for infighting?

Moss: There is still a lot of territory in the world which from Macquarie Bank’s point of view doesn’t have anybody’s flag on it within the organization. So energetic managers who want to create a new business have plenty of unoccupied places to go. That means energies are directed outwards.

Are you looking to be acquired?

Moss: It would be inappropriate for any publicly listed company to pre-empt a decision by shareholders on the question of ownership. But there is a consensus between the board and the management that independence brings with it a lot of value. I don’t think anyone would buy us unless the team was on side and the present view of the team is that independence is very valuable.