NASDAQ let down by its own technology
NYSE members differ over demutualization
Chicago’s fallen giants make progress of sorts
When you first visit Richard Kilsby at his office there is a surprise in store. He is the chief executive of Tradepoint, the London-based for-profit electronic exchange saved from extinction in May by a consortium led by agency broker Instinet and also including investment banks, an asset manager and a US electronic commission network (ECN) called Archipelago which itself has since applied to become an exchange in the US.
What provokes the surprise is preconceived ideas of what an exchange should look like: large buildings in the centre of financial districts proudly showing off their history. In the executive dining room of the New York Stock Exchange, for example, hang the portraits of past chairmen, and in the corner stands a magnificent Faberge egg donated to the exchange by Tsar Nicholas II at the start of the century.
That is not Tradepoint’s style. Its office is in London’s Soho, better known for opera, Chinese restaurants and more recently for being one of London’s gay meccas. It is only one of several businesses in the building, and the walls are adorned with posters of pop art by Ray Lichtenstein. While the NYSE ponders whether it should take advantage of the $600 million the City of New York has kindly provided it with to expand into more buildings in downtown Manhattan, Kilsby is looking at annual overheads of £10 million ($16 million)
Elsewhere, it’s a similar story. In Manhattan the area around Union Square is fast becoming the city’s silicon alley; home to new financial services companies. Wit Capital, the on-line retail investment bank run by former Salomon Smith Barney banker Bob Lessin and former Schwab vice-chairman Ron Readmond, is just south of the square on Broadway, based in cramped offices in a walk-up above one of the city’s most famous second hand bookshops, the Strand.
Just north of the square, off Fifth Avenue, is an even newer operation, Creditex, set up in early summer by two former Deutsche Bank credit derivatives traders, Sunil Hirani and John McEvoy. They are creating a virtual market place to trade, initially, default swaps. They have less than 20 employees, occupying just one office of several on their floor. It is still so new that they have yet to put a proper sign on the door, instead having a double photocopy of the firm’s name and photocopies of the main employees, stuck on with sellotape.
They are new, nimble, staffed with people who are experts in their field and lack all the organizational nightmares which are plaguing the incumbents. And, on the equities side at least, they would appear to have the backing of SEC chairman Arthur Levitt. His plan is to use the ECNs as a way to provide effective competition to the exchanges, and he has openly signalled that he is willing to end the regulatory bias in favour of the entrenched exchanges. “At one time or another, all of us have failed to act outside the scope of parochial interests – refusing to recognize the market as a marketplace, and not an institution,” he said in a speech at New York’s Columbia Law School at the end of September. “This is not the time to cling to the comforts of custom; it is time to demand value. We should be asking ourselves: what best serves the interests of investors? Anything that doesn’t should be part of our history – not our future.”
He has already proved willing to turn words into actions in the way he has dealt with the options exchanges. He made it clear that they needed to start to work with each other, even compete openly with each other by trading the others’ contracts. They failed to do so for themselves, so he imposed it upon them. Now it is a free-for-all, with customers searching out the best price on all three major exchanges for the first time.
A month later he was back in New York speaking in front of the Economic Club of New York, this time speaking in favour of a level playing field for all investors. But one of the questions at the end referred back to his earlier speech. In fact, it tried to refer to just about everything. Bill Donaldson, co-founder of Donaldson, Lufkin and Jenrette, and a former president of the NYSE, spent five minutes asking a question which included so much information he must have hoped it would make him look clever. His bottom line was that the SEC should put all developments on hold and set up a commission to investigate what would be best for the market.
Few outside the exchanges, and probably not too many inside them, would be all that keen. “We don’t want to see the regulators coming in to sort this out for us,” says Richard Korhammer, CEO of Lava Trading, a developer of trading systems that provides direct access to all sources of liquidity. “It should be left up to competitive forces. There are applications, such as ours, which can address Levitt’s desire to tap all pools of liquidity efficiently once regulations allow.”
Levitt appears to agree. After a stifled giggle at the preposterous length of Donaldson’s speech, and a short pause during which most of the audience must have feared that he would ask for Donaldson to repeat the question, Levitt answered. No, a commission would be counter-productive and waste too much time – a year, possibly longer. So the stock exchanges remain on the back foot, destined to be forced to prove their worth without the regulatory barriers to entry which have in the past kept them in almost unassailable positions.
Good news for the new firms, but no guarantee that they will as a result prosper, or even, where appropriate, replace, the incumbent institutions they compete with. E-commerce is a wonderful tag to be able to put on a business, but if the main focus is on the technology there could be trouble ahead. In other words, they need to use the ‘e’ to maximize the benefit of the ‘commerce’.
New start-up exchanges, the ECNs in the US, Brokertec, Cantor Exchange, ChicagoFutures, all suffer from one or more hindrances: lack of name recognition and brand, lack of sufficient business and liquidity, or encumbering rules and regulations which grant the incumbents an advantage.
And then there is the matter of what the market players actually want. Several of the major investment banks refer to their investments in the ECNs as hedging their bets. Among these are the two largest investors, Goldman Sachs and Merrill Lynch, but also Salomon Smith Barney, Morgan Stanley Dean Witter, and others. Their investments in new exchanges may be a forcing function to get the incumbents to get their act together (for a complete list of major firms’ investments in new ventures see the table below).
| Who’s done what – investments in internet and electronic trading vehicles | |
| Bear Stearns | |
| Strike | ECN, set up by Bear Stearns |
| Barclays Capital | |
| Brokertec | Invited in as an equity partner in the inter-dealer broker by the intial consortium in December; 12 banks in total |
| EuroMTS | Inter-dealer broker for European market. 24 banks involved |
| Tradeweb | On-line trading platform for US treasuries. Barclays joined in early 1999 |
| Credit Suisse First Boston | |
| Tradeweb | electronic trading network in US treasury products, set up 1997; instigated by CSFB |
| Brokertec | Global inter-dealer broking system for bonds and futures. One of seven in initial consortium; 12 members now |
| EuroMTS | Inter-dealer broker for European market. 24 banks involved |
| Optimark | Alternative trading system, minority stake (undisclosed) |
| Tradepoint | European electronic stock exchange based in London, 9.74% of consortium, which owns 54% of the exchange |
| Reditrade | ECN, joint venture with Schwab, Fidelity, Spear Leeds Kellog and DLJdirect |
| Deutsche Bank | |
| Tradepoint | European electronic stock exchange based in London; 9.74% of consortium, which owns 54% of the exchange |
| Brokertec | one of the seven founders (12 banks now members) |
| EuroMTS | Inter-dealer broker for European market. 24 banks involved |
| DLJ/DLJdirect | |
| Strike | ECN, minority interest |
| Reditrade | ECN, joint venture with Schwab, Fidelity, Spear Leeds Kellog and CSFB |
| Dresdner Kleinwort Benson | |
| Brokertec | Invited in as an equity partner in the inter-dealer broker by the intial consortium in October |
| EuroMTS | Inter-dealer broker for the European bond market. 24 banks involved |
| Tradepoint | European electronic stock exchange based in London, 9.74% of consortium, which owns 54% of the exchange |
| Goldman Sachs | |
| Wit Capital | retail on-line investment bank, 20% stake |
| Archipelago | ECN, and would-be exchange, 12.5% stake |
| Optimark | ATS Minority stake (undisclosed) |
| Brut | ECN, 10% stake |
| Primex Trading | Joint venture with Merill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, Salomon Smith Barney and Madoff Securities |
| Strike | ECN – 5% stake through Hull Group (options trading firm bought by Goldman for $531 million in 1999) |
| Brokertec | Global inter-dealer broking system for bonds and futures; Goldman is the force |
| behind it, but holds an equal stake with 11 other investment banks | |
| EuroMTS | Inter-dealer broker for the European market |
| Tradeweb | electronic trading network in US treasury products |
| Easdaq | European Stock exchange, undisclosed stake |
| JP Morgan | |
| Archipelago | ECN and would-be exchange, 12.5% |
| Tradepoint | European electronic stock exchange based in London; 9.74% of consortium, which owns 54% of the exchange |
| Tradeweb | electronic trading network in US treasury products. Consortium of nine banks |
| EuroMTS | Inter-dealer broker for European market. 24 banks involved |
| Lehman Brothers | |
| Strike | ECN, minority stake |
| Brokertec | one of the seven founders (11 banks now members) |
| EuroMTS | Inter-dealer broker for European market. 24 banks involved |
| Tradeweb | electronic trading network in US treasury products |
| Merrill Lynch | |
| Brokertec | Global inter-dealer broking system for bonds and futures. One of seven in initial consortium; 11 now members |
| EuroMTS | Inter-dealer broker for European market. 24 banks involved |
| Primex | Joint venture with Morgan Stanley, Salomon Smith Barney and Madoff Securities |
| Strike/Brut | ECN, minority stake |
| Archipelago | ECN, 12.5% |
| Tradepoint | European electronic stock exchange based in London; 9.74% of consortium, which owns 54% of the exchange |
| Tradeweb | electronic trading network in US treasury products |
| Optimark | Alternative trading system; minority stake |
| Morgan Stanley Dean Witter | |
| Tradepoint | European electronic stock exchange based in London; 9.74% of consortium, which owns 54% of the exchange |
| Easdaq | 2.5% stake |
| Brut | ECN, minority interest |
| MarketXT | ECN pushing after hours trading, minority interest |
| Primex | Joint venture with Merill Lynch, Salomon Smith Barney and Madoff Securities |
| Salomon Smith Barney/Citigroup | |
| Strike | ECN, minority stake |
| Brokertec | Interdealer bond and futures broking system; one of seven founder members |
| Tradeweb | electronic trading network in US treasury products; Salomon one of four banks |
| in initial consortium (now stands at nine) | |
| Primex | Joint venture with Merill Lynch, Morgan Stanley and Madoff Securities |
| EuroMTS | Inter-dealer broker for European market. 24 banks involved |
| MarketXT | Joint venture with Merill Lynch, Salomon Smith Barney and Madoff Securities |
| Warburg Dillon Read | |
| Tradepoint | European electronic stock exchange based in London; 9.74% of consortium, which owns 54% of the exchange |
| EuroMTS | Inter-dealer broker for European market. 24 banks involved |
| Brokertec | Invited into the consortium as equity partner in December 1999 |
| Note | The ECNs Strike and Brut recently announced their intention to merge |
That’s fine as the strategic view but what about tactics? As a community, the large investment banks speak more or less with one voice about the stock exchanges. The top 10 banks between them bring 55% to 60% of the order flow to the NYSE, which makes for a powerful voice. To oversimplify somewhat, it’s the big guys against the other members – the small or independent floor brokers at the NYSE, or the specialists. The big firms all repeat the same line: they know NYSE chairman Richard Grasso understands what they say and agrees with them on most counts, but it is the other members who hinder the process of change. “A lot of the smaller guys say such things as ‘just give me another two years at this’,” says one investment banker. “As if in two years they will have made enough, with no ill effects for the exchange. But it’ll be too late by then.”
Take the big guys away from the arcane distractions of exchange politics, though, and it can be a different matter. The banks themselves are also worried: what if the ECNs succeed in winning flow from a wide range of equities trading rather than just the narrower field of technology and growth stocks on Nasdaq? It would wreck much of their business, so rather than be cannibalized it’s better to get involved in the cannibalization themselves. When decent systems come along, such as Archipelago, for example (one of the main ECNs and the first to register its intent to become an exchange), several banks jump in as investors and board members, and feel compelled to act together in the better interests of the market.
But it won’t be long before old rivalries and conflicting ideas between the firms resurface on the boards of the start-ups. The banks have bought into these operations partly to force the market, partly to benefit financially from investing, but also because they want greater control over what happens.
So this then threatens to turn the nimble new guys into parodies of the old models. One of the investors in Archipelago is worried that this is already happening. “We and our competitors may check our guns in at the door to start with, but it increasingly looks like the NYSE,” he says with just enough annoyance to imply that it’s not just a joke. “Getting us all to work together is not easy for one thing. For another, we’re sitting there creating more mechanisms and structures.” In other words, what is happening at the new entities is that the seeds for future discord are already being sewn.
First, there is the question of which firms to allow on board. In the case of Tradepoint, there are now 10 institutions in the consortium; Doug Atkin, CEO of Instinet and the man credited with forming the consortium, says that there are about 75 others who want to join. That is clearly untenable, as it would make the decision-making process as torturous as at the old exchanges. In any case, bickering and fighting on the boards of these start-ups is inevitable as each tries to reconcile the lofty longer-term aims for the market as a whole with the shorter-term desire, inbred since starting on Wall Street, to put oneself and one’s own firm first. Investment banks thrive on competition, traditionally have managers who focus on product, and are not renowned for being adept at managing multiple channels; to expect them to be able completely to put that aside is too unrealistic.
Another problem could well be an increase in conflicts of interest for those such as Merrill and Goldman which have invested in a plethora of systems and start-ups. Will they be prevented from taking one course with one of them because it conflicts with the aims of another? This has already caused some friction at the Chicago Board of Trade, where those banks involved in Brokertec, the Goldman Sachs-led consortium of nine banks to set up an electronic inter-dealer fixed-income broking concern, have felt compelled to refrain from voting on any Brokertec-related matters brought before the CBOT. If that were applied to the ECNs and cash exchanges, nothing would ever get done.
The founder of another start-up, on-line investment bank Wit Capital, predicted in an off-the-cuff remark that it would be 10 years or more before his firm began to suffer from the organizational nightmares which plague incumbents today. But for many the challenges have already started. It could be time to brush up on those game theory skills.