Bizkaia is one of the three provinces that were united as Euskadi, the Basque Autonomous Region, under the 1978 constitution that decentralized Spain’s political administration after the death of the dictator Francisco Franco. It accounts for more than half of the Basque region’s GDP and although its economy is now mainly service-based, more than a third of output still comes from industry. However, Bizkaia’s GDP is forecast to grow by 4% this year compared with 3.7% for the rest of the Basque Country and Spain.
Over the past couple of years, Bizkaia’s star has been finally in the ascendant. Along with the collapse of its industrial lifeblood the Basque Country has had to bear the cross of political terrorism by ETA, the separatist group that since the late 1960s had been waging open warfare for Basque independence, fancifully defined as union with the province of Navarra as well as the three French Basque provinces.
The breakthrough came in September last year when the main Basque political parties and trade unions including ETA’s political wing, Herri Batasuna, issued a statement agreeing jointly to seek a solution to the issue of self-determination for the region. A few days later ETA, which by this time had lost most of its popular backing as well as its infrastructure, seized the opportunity to throw in the towel.
“The Basque people will decide their own future but we as a party are committed to abide by the decision of the majority,” says Eusebio Lasa, economic spokesman for Herri Batasuna, a party whose relationship with ETA is similar to that of Sinn Féin’s with the IRA. The party has not renounced its ambitious plans for an independent state, but Lasa concedes that this will be a “slow and gradual process and it will not happen overnight as we had previously demanded”. What it means is that even the most radical wing of Basque nationalism, which obtained 17% of the vote in this year’s regional election, agreed to take its seats in the Basque parliament and abide by the democratic process.
A setback came in late November when ETA, frustrated that the Spanish government was not meeting its demands, announced that it was reactivating military operations. For its part, the Spanish government says it will not talk to Eta unless it reinstates the ceasefire. It remains unclear whether the peace process can recover after these difficulties.
“Investment never came to a standstill because of ETA but there is no doubt that last year’s ceasefire brought a breath of fresh air,” says Javier Urizarbarrena, finance and treasury deputy of Bizkaia, one of the three provincial governments, along with Gipúzkoa and Álava, set up under the autonomy statute. Each has its own elected local government, and the regional authority for the Basque Country sits in Vitoria in Álava province.
Urizarbarrena says Bizkaia’s rejuvenation is most evident in Bilbao, the province’s capital city of 400,000, and this thanks largely to the “Guggenheim effect”. He says that “from a business standpoint it isn’t the least bit frivolous to talk about the impact of the Guggenheim Museum, which opened here in 1997. In the past two years the Guggenheim has attracted 2 million visitors, something we could never have achieved even if we had spent six times the museum’s £80 million construction cost on regional promotion. We did a presentation to investors in New York in 1997 and we had to pinpoint Bizkaia on a map for them. Last year we had another presentation in Chicago and by this time everyone had heard about Bilbao.”
The “Guggenheim effect” has turned into a unique promotional tool: half a dozen luxury hotels are under construction in Bilbao, a new airport is nearing completion, international banks such as Deutsche Bank, Barclays and ABN Amro have piled in and Chase Manhattan has even made the city its Spanish headquarters. James Bond has used the museum as a prop for his latest blockbuster, The World is Not Enough, and since Agent 007 wears an Omega watch in the film the manufacturer has opened its first Spanish outlet in Bilbao.
“We now have the resources to provide a first-rate infrastructure,” says a Bizkaia government official. “We could afford to hire architects like Sir Norman Foster, for instance, to design the city’s new metro system and Cesar Pelli to develop a multi-functional commercial centre along the riverbank.”
The Zamudio technology park outside Bilbao was Spain’s first and remains the largest. It has become the Spanish headquarters for such companies as Ericsson, as well as the European Software Institute. Zamudio and two other technology parks in the region account for half the research projects submitted each year to the European Union.
Partly to help neutralize business fears of political unrest, the Basque government introduced an aggressive tax regime that set the rate of corporate tax at 32.5%, compared with 35% for the rest of Spain. As one of the two “foral” regimes – the other is Navarra – the Basque Country enjoys a greater degree of fiscal autonomy than other regions. “The system dates back to the 14th century when special privileges called fueros were granted to the territory,” says Richard Morawetz, credit analyst at ABN Amro. “As a foral region, the Basque Country retains nearly all taxes collected within the region, and as such receives a very small share of revenues from the central government.” Morawetz says the Basque Country’s current Aa2/AA rating, the strongest of any region and on a par with Spain, reflects its per capita income being 20% above the national average, and also strong growth in the 1990s that has had a positive impact on fiscal indicators.
The special tax regime has set the Basque Country on a collision course with Madrid. The central government has for years been trying to force the Basques to harmonize their tax regime with the rest of Spain but its case has been consistently dismissed by the law courts. However, the latest in a round of judicial rulings came as something of a mixed victory for the Basque region. Not surprisingly, the Basque high court upheld a decision by the Spanish courts to allow the 32.5% corporate tax. But it also decreed the abolition of a system of tax holidays for companies setting up in the Basque Country, an incentive of crucial importance to Bizkaia where the bulk of the region’s industry is centred.
Urizarbarren says Bizkaia is hopeful of obtaining an upgrade with international rating agencies that, if it were to happen, would effectively set a precedent by breaking the sovereign ceiling. “The agencies know us well and we will soon obtain a rating from Fitch IBCA, along with the ones we have from Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s,” he says. “But looking at it realistically it’s unlikely they will rate us above the Kingdom of Spain, and with the euro it probably doesn’t make a great deal of sense for them to do so.”
Bizkaia’s borrowing requirements for the immediate future are likely to remain at most testimonial. “We haven’t a large enough stock of debt to warrant tapping the markets,” says Pedro María Azpiazu, Bizkaia’s director-general for financing and the budget. “If we did it would only be with a view to getting our name known in international investor circles, as our current borrowing needs are in the region of Pta5 billion [$30million] to Pta7 billion. Bizkaia’s current outstanding debt is Pta104 billion, the same as in 1994, and we plan to reduce this relative to our annual budget from 100% this year to 80% in 2003.” Bizkaia’s only international issue was a e150 billion, 15-year bond issued last year with ABN Amro and Chase Manhattan as foreign bookrunners, along with Spanish underwriters BBV, Argentaria, BSCH and Basque savings bank BBK.
Bizkaia this year expects to raise some Pta650 billion in tax revenue. Of this it is required to pay a Pta380 billion share to fund the Basque Country administration in Vitoria. It is also obliged to transfer Pta60 billion to the province’s local town administrations, and another Pta60 billion to Madrid to pay for general expenses such as defence, monetary policy and other powers not in the hands of the country’s autonomous regions. This leaves the province with Pta150 billion, presently estimated sufficient to cover local expenditures.
One factor that could encourage Bizkaia to tap the capital markets would be an increase in the scope of autonomous powers. The regional government is locked in a political wrangle with Madrid to take on social security and unemployment benefits, two areas contemplated under the economic pact signed with the central government, but which until now have not been transferred to the Basque Country.
“The economic pact covers about 40 areas which we should currently be administering on a regional basis, but the social security system and unemployment services are the two big ones,” says Urizarbarrena. “We should reach an agreement on this before long because we need to renegotiate the pact, which expires at the end of 2001. We have also set ourselves the objective to take on responsibility for setting the rates for a number of indirect taxes such as VAT.”
A bankers’ breeding ground
One of Bizkaia’s undisputed strong points is in the financial services sector, as the province was where most of Spain’s biggest banks were founded, as well as being home to the country’s second-largest stock exchange. Spain’s top bank, BBV, was the product of a merger between the Bilbao-based Banco de Vizcaya and Banco de Bilbao. In October it acquired the third-biggest bank, Argentaria, thus consolidating its national leadership in terms of assets and market share.
BBV’s top management, including its chairman, Emilio Ybarra, and chief executive, Pedro Luis Uriarte, are natives of Bilbao and the bank continues to have its headquarters in this city. Banco Hispano Americano, which merged with Banco Central as BCH and earlier this year with Banco Santander to create BSCH, was also founded in Bilbao, as was Banco del Comercio, another of the country’s top 10 banks. The banking industry flourished in Bilbao, where its primary role was financing trade with the Latin American colonies and in particular with the UK, whose navy was supplied with Basque iron and timber.
“The fact that the newly merged BBVA will continue to be headquartered in Bilbao is important, particularly for fiscal reasons,” says Alfonso Basagoiti, assistant to the chairman. “The combined entity will be paying more taxes to the local authorities. We are the region’s largest deposit taker and we also finance more industrial projects than any other bank. It enhances the region’s image to have the country’s biggest bank and decision-making centre in its main city. Our presence there definitely adds a lot to the region’s profile and should bode well for investment prospects.”
BBVA’s chief rival in Bizkaia is Bilbao Bizkaia Kutxa (BBK), one of Spain’s 50 regional cajas (savings banks), which account for half the country’s banking assets. BBK ranks as one of Spain’s best-capitalized banks (25% BIS capital adequacy ratio) and its 49% cost:income ratio makes it the country’s most efficient financial institution. Consolidated pre-tax profit last year grew by 34.3% to Pta38.8 billion, with total assets at Pta1.68 trillion.
The bank’s management takes a sanguine view of the risks of overcapitalization. “This is a problem many banks would happily like to deal with,” says Javier Egaña Gallastegui, BBK’s deputy director. “Given our 17.2% return on equity, we are comfortable with this level of capital.” Egaña hints that the bank’s excess capital might be put to use through a merger with two much smaller Basque savings banks in Álava and Gipuzkoa provinces.
Most foreign banks operating in the Spanish market have set up branch networks in Bilbao, concentrating on corporate and private banking. Chase Manhattan has taken its commitment to Bizkaia a step further by making the city its Spanish headquarters.