Everyone’s a winner

Latin America is an unlikely safe haven. But as Asia melts down, the region's new foreign invaders are thankful that they spent their billions there. The acquisitions should be good for the local markets too. Jules Stewart reports.

“No-one is sure yet to what extent Latin America will be affected by the Asian crisis but so far it’s resisted surprisingly well,” says George Cardona, general manager, international, at Midland Bank. “Every time Asia takes a drop so do the Latin American markets, but the impact has not been as serious as in Asia. The majority of Latin American countries look set for GDP growth of about 5%. The governments in most countries are doing all the right things. They are privatizing, and this includes the sale of banks to the private sector. They are bringing government debt under control, reducing inflation and stabilizing their currencies.”

It’s an environment increasingly attractive to foreign banks and not just those that have been established there for decades. Foreign banks, notably Citibank, Chase and BankBoston, have been in Latin America since the early years of the century, but in the past three years an acquisition spree by Spain’s big banks and then other foreign institutions has changed the competitive landscape. Just last year HSBC Holdings, Midland’s parent company, spent nearly $2 billion in Latin America. It acquired 100% of Brazil’s Bamerindus and the Roberts Group in Argentina, as well as minority stakes in banks in Peru, Mexico and Chile.

A growing foreign presence

José García Cantera at Salomon Smith Barney in New York estimates that in the largest seven countries in the region, foreign banks now control about 15% of total loans and 16% of deposits, and that these figures have increased by nearly five percentage points in the last few years.

Spain’s big three banks – Banco Santander, Banco Bilbao Vizcaya (BBV) and Banco Central Hispano (BCH) – have been the most active acquirers. Santander, the country’s biggest banking group, is now the largest foreign bank in Latin America with total assets of $28.3 billion in nine countries.

Santander’s relationship with the region goes back more than 140 years. Its founding statutes laid down as one of its objectives the promotion of trade with Latin America. It had branches in Havana and Mexico before it opened in Barcelona, and today more than 40% of its assets are located in the region, as a result of acquisitions managed through what the bank describes as a “very disciplined framework”. This framework has to fulfil three main objectives: diversification, developing a regional universal banking franchise and achieving its profitability benchmarks.

“Our strategy so far has been to take majority holdings in banks in nine countries that together account for 98% of the region’s GDP,” says José Juan Ruiz, the bank’s strategic planning director. “We do not aspire to be a global bank hence Latin America does not represent a step towards this objective. We only want to be active in areas where we have a comparative advantage and Latin America is one of them.”

The group’s investment-banking arm Santander Investment began looking at Latin America again about 13 years ago when the region’s economies were being liberalized. “Santander Investment had already analyzed the potential for work in privatization and other areas,” says Ruiz. “The deregulation of Latin America’s economies makes them a natural ally for us. We can export our expertise to the region, as Spain went through the same experience about 10 years ago. We see Latin America on a regional scale, not as a series of isolated investments. We want to build one great franchise and help these countries to do business with Europe.”

Ruiz says the bank prefers majority control in order to be able to influence management decisions and maximize returns to shareholders. Santander applies its own risk-control methods to these banks. In Spain non-performing loans are 0.8% of its loan book compared with the Spanish average of 2%. “This gives us a comparative advantage in Latin America where the average ratio is 3%, while some of our competitors have twice that level,” says Ruiz. “The focus of our international expansion is to create shareholder value. We spent Pta325 billion ($2.1 billion) last year on restructuring these banks. The bulk of our Latin American expansion is concluded but we are open and flexible to opportunities, and we are diversifying into areas like fund management and pension funds. Last year these banks yielded $380 million in net attributable profit and we expect about $520 million this year. As for return on equity, we are in the midst of a restructuring programme and haven’t yet reached our cruising speed.”

By contrast, Santander’s chief rival and Spain’s largest bank, BBV, says its expansion programme is far from over. Indeed, it has $3.5 billion earmarked for the region on top of the $3 billion it has already spent on acquiring local banks. Last month it took control of Chile’s Banco BHIF. BBV’s deputy general manager José Ignacio Sánchez Asiaín defines the goal as becoming one of the three top banking groups in Latin America by the end of the century and in doing so, create value for shareholders through superior returns.

“Latin America is capable of growing faster than Spain and our ambition is to be a leader in each market in which we operate,” he says. “We provide a minimum of management for our Latin American banks, with rarely more than five or six staff per operation. We believe local people should run local businesses. What we really provide is our management style that is flexible but does not change our core way of doing business. We send in implementers, not caretakers.” Unlike Banco Santander, BBV tends to prefer minority holdings and wants to be perceived as a local player hand-in-hand with a high-profile partner in each of its markets.

No quick profits

Sánchez Asiaín says BBV is looking to achieve a 20% return on equity from its Latin American operations. However, foreign arrivals are finding that initial returns are lower than the continent’s rate of economic growth had led them to believe. Inefficiency and bad debts will depress profitability this year and next, while as Sánchez Asiaín points out, Latin America’s economies have underperformed expectations partly because of El Niño and partly because elections have upset economic programmes. However, he says: “In spite of this we are finding growth satisfactory and inflation is under control. Thanks to their orthodox economic policies they have held up well under the Asian crisis. I’m not sure Brazil would have survived this five or six years ago.”

Foreign banks in Latin America, December 1997

Santander

Citibank

HSBC

BankBoston

BBV

Assets* ($ million)

28,344

22,833

21,081

16,532

12,996

Branches

1,339

457

2,097

174

1,086

Countries present

10

16

7

8

8

*weighted by % equity ownership
Source: Santander Investment

Despite its acquisition war-chest, BBV is moving ahead with caution. It has looked at 140 opportunities in the last three years. “We believe size is important,” says Sánchez Asiaín. “But there is no hurry. Profitability is a higher priority than size and we do not go into these countries simply to gain market share.” The third big Spanish presence in the region is Banco Central Hispano. It has spent less than Santander or BBV and prefers to move into major markets with local partners. In 1993 it struck a deal with Chile’s Luksic Group to merge BCH’s local branch network with Luksic’s Banco O’Higgins, setting up the country’s third-biggest bank and the OHCH holding that it uses as its vehicle for expansion in other Latin American countries.

BCH’s director general Antonio Escámez defines the bank’s strategy: “We have relationships with local partners where we acquire effectively full ownership, while in other banks we take minority holdings. The strategic objective is to achieve at least a 10% market share wherever we operate. This is a good time to invest and we would envisage spending $500 million to $700 million over the next year and a half.”

The Spanish offensive has forced established banks to respond. Guillermo Stanley, vice-president at Citibank in Buenos Aires, says the competition has changed dramatically in the past couple of years. “We recently looked at our strategy because the Spanish banks and other foreign players like HSBC are now in the market,” he says. “Also, banks like ABN Amro and ING Barings have made it clear that they want to be players in this region, while BankBoston has built up a significant presence. We decided to carry on with our policy of opening branches, although we are looking at the possibility of acquiring banks in different countries.” Stanley says the aim is to be among the top three or four players in consumer and corporate business.

Citibank – like those banks that have acquired local institutions – aims to present as domestic a front as possible to local customers. It employs local people almost exclusively, relying on their knowledge of the language and culture of each market. “Our advantage is that we have been here a long time and never pulled out of a market, not even during the Mexican revolution,” says Stanley. “The new foreign arrivals will have to face at least a couple of years’ work in restructuring these operations and putting together their different cultures.”

The difficulties faced by acquirers are illustrated by HSBC’s acquisition last year of a 19.9% stake in Mexico’s Serfin and the takeover of Bamerindus in Brazil. HSBC is satisfied with the progress so far but these operations, representing a total investment of nearly $1.2 billion, are not yet performing at group standards of profitability. Both were banks with serious problems and, in the case of Serfin, the Mexican government had to give HSBC a number of guarantees before it would buy the bank.

HSBC is in no hurry to expand its franchise outside the six countries where it has taken stakes in local banks. “This might be a good time for expansion for other people but not for us,” says Cardona. “We have to take a breather and concentrate on integrating what we’ve acquired.”

Cardona says Latin America is a natural area of business for HSBC given its emerging-market roots. “Unlike the Spanish and North American banks, our group started life in emerging markets,” he says. “We have the IT systems, the methods, credit rules and human-resources policies – all tested in ups and downs of cycles in emerging markets. In the long run that means we will prosper in Latin America.”

HSBC’s policy is to keep existing management in place wherever possible, but it also puts some of its own people in to help integrate the group. “There’s no point in owning something if you don’t do anything with it,” says Cardona. “If all we bring to a situation is capital we don’t do it. That means putting in management to extract the synergies and get business flows cross-referred. In all the minority banks we’ve got at least one executive seconded from the group to make business flows happen.”

BankBoston sees Latin America as one of the areas where it is looking to grow its business most. It is already present in 10 countries and operates a network of more than 150 branches. Ignacio Sosa, the bank’s managing director and head of emerging markets, says the region should eventually make a 30% contribution to group income.

BankBoston’s strategy has been to grow its own business in Latin America rather than go for joint ventures or acquisitions. BankBoston has a well-known franchise in the major economies of Brazil and Argentina but needs to raise its profile. “If this were the first time we were going into the market we would have to buy our way in,” says Sosa. “Bricks and mortar operations represent an initial cost, but we are now expanding our retail business in both countries.”

In the long term, the foreign bank offensive is good news for Latin America. It will lead to lower systemic risk because of the financial strength and diversification of the acquirers and it will increase the sophistication of the local banks and financial markets as the foreign institutions import their know-how and technology.

Salomon Smith Barney’s García Cantera believes that: “The acquired institutions will have easier and cheaper access to capital, as the rating agencies will most likely upgrade the banks, when possible, after the acquisition. They will also have access to new products and services, as well as to more advanced banking processes which will be used to meet the increased demand that we will see in the region.”