AfE 2016 logo-196 135 Press release View full 2016 results
Regional Awards for Excellence 2016
Country Awards for Excellence
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Canada Best bank: TD Bank Best investment bank: RBC Capital Markets |
While North America may have fared better than many regions economically, it pays to be cautious if you want to remain the best bank in your country. That is the message from TD Bank’s chief executive Bharat Masrani, the best bank in Canada. Last year was Masrani’s first full year as CEO and he made no bones about being aggressive in repositioning the bank to be leaner and prepared for the challenges ahead. Those challenges are the levelling off of strong mortgage growth and home ownership and the pressure to innovate.
His decision to cut 1,600 jobs and incur $696 million in restructuring costs raised eyebrows, but Masrani has been clear that in spite of the focus on expenses, his attention is firmly on growth. The difficult energy markets that might be expected to negatively impact a Canadian bank have rather played to TD Bank’s strengths. Speaking at the first quarter earnings call, Masrani said: “While resource-rich provinces in Canada are struggling, cheaper energy prices and a falling currency are giving a lift to export-oriented manufacturers. This is boosting economic growth and employment in central Canada where TD has an outsized presence. We expect to continue generating good organic growth in these markets, leveraging the power of One TD to meet our customers’ banking, wealth management and insurance needs.”
It is hard to fathom how TD Bank can grow further in Canada, yet every year it seems to break records with its earnings. Last fiscal year was no exception. Its Canadian retail business delivered record adjusted earnings of C$5.9 billion ($4.6 billion). It had record long-term mutual fund sales, was number one in credit cards, drove record auto-loan originations in Canada while TD Insurance achieved a record C$3.9 billion in total premiums.
In retail banking TD Bank cannot be touched. Some 40% of Canadians have an account with TD Canada Trust. It leads in digital innovation: its retail banking business works with tech firms, students and employees to develop new technologies. The bank ranked first in Canadian mobile adoption and online unique visitors, according to Comscore, and last year it added a third innovation hub in Ontario.
During 2015 it also began testing the use of smart ATMs that allow customers to choose bills in different denominations and to deposit checks using image-enabled technology. It also became the first bank in the world to offer customers service through Facebook Messenger. When it comes to corporate social responsibility TD Bank is also hard to beat in Canada. In 2015 it invested in a programme to teach thousands of people about financial literacy – taught by TD employees. Last year it also introduced mobile tablets for aboriginal communities to help with banking in remote locations.
This year’s best investment bank in Canada is once again RBC Capital Markets. In every asset class RBC maintains an unrivalled market share. In Canadian equities and equity-linked issuance, the bank has been at the top of the league tables for the last seven years. The last 12 months were dominated by fewer but larger deals that play to RBC’s strengths, particularly as it boasts a large North American retail distribution platform.
Known for its ability to structure and execute large and complex deals, RBC is often selected as left lead bookrunner – as with TransCanada’s C$4.4 billion cross-border US follow-on offering in March this year, which was the largest equity offering in Canadian history. It was also the first time a dividend equivalent payment structure had been used on Canadian subscription receipts where funds were paid to the purchasers instead of the escrow. RBC was also joint bookrunner for Emera’s C$2.18 billion equity-linked offering, the largest of its kind in 2015.
In debt capital markets RBC has experience, size and international standing. As Rob Brown, managing director and co-head of DCM, says: “Our long-standing leadership position in the Canadian debt market is a function of RBC’s proven ability to deliver high-quality execution through market cycles, our uniquely global fixed income platform and the depth and breadth of our full-service funding solutions suite.”
According to Dealogic, RBC had a market share of 27.6% last year in corporate debt and 31.7% in the first quarter of this year. One of its landmark deals was for Choice Properties, the first ever 30-year real estate offering and the second lowest seven-year real estate investment trust coupon in the Canadian market. RBC was joint bookrunner. It was also the sole bookrunner on Kraft Heinz’s C$1 billion M&A driven financing in June 2015. RBC has also been prominent in liability management deals. For example, it was the sole deal manager on GE Capital’s C$3.5 billion tender.
In M&A, RBC also leads the league tables. Although last year saw a decline in M&A activity among resources firms, there were many more Canadian outbound deals that played to RBC’s strengths as not just a Canadian firm but a global bank.
|
USA Best bank: JPMorgan Chase Best investment bank: Bank of America Merrill Lynch |
Retail banking has been one of the few bright spots for financial institutions in North America where economic recovery has been faster to take hold than elsewhere in the world. And there is one bank that does more business for more customers in the US than any other, JPMorgan Chase, the winner of this year’s award for best bank in the US.
JPMorgan Chase is the largest bank in the US and its chief executive Jamie Dimon has been vocal of late on why size matters. In his annual letter to shareholders Dimon said that big banks perform “mission-critical services that regional and community banks cannot do” and warned that banks from other nations would step into the shoes of the US’s largest banks were they to be hindered from growing.
JPMorgan Chase is still growing. Its deposit growth drove net revenues of $4.6 billion for the first quarter this year – up 4% on the same period last year. Its loans are also increasing. In the first quarter alone it provided $6 billion in credit for small businesses and $59 billion of credit to consumers in the US.
That size has impact is evident in the financing that the bank is able to provide to communities in need. Last May it launched the JPMorgan Institute that will use data and expert insights to address and resolve global economic challenges. Closer to home, the bank has been a supporter of Detroit – committing $100 million in a five-year plan to spur economic opportunity in challenged Detroit neighbourhoods. It also announced in April a $125 million commitment to help revitalize disadvantaged neighbourhoods across the US, as well as a pledge to hire more than 1,000 veterans into technology positions over the next five years.
Technology is at the forefront of JPMorgan’s investment plans and it competes with many smaller and more nimble banking competitors. Its mobile banking app consistently ranks first in industry surveys. At the end of 2015 the bank upgraded that app so that customers can now view statements from their investing, auto loans, home equity lines and loans. And banking and commercial customers can see analysis statements for their checking accounts. As of the end of September last year, the bank had 22 million active mobile users. It also opened its doors in December to a new digital office for 800 professionals in New York City designed to attract millennials. It has similar offices in Brooklyn, Columbus and San Francisco.
Bank of America Merrill Lynch (BAML) has been the go-to investment bank in the tough times of the last 12 months and that is reflected in its earnings. The bank’s 2015 profits of almost $16 billion were the best since 2006. This year BAML takes the award for best investment bank in the US.
In debt capital markets, BAML leads the league tables in investment-grade issuance, green bonds, FIG and jumbo deals. It was left lead on the $46 billion bond offering by Anheuser Busch InBev, was sole bookrunner on the $9 billion bridge facility for Abbott Laboratories, as well as lead left on Anthem’s $26.5 billion bridge facility. “We’re prepared to be responsibly aggressive with our balance sheet,” says Brendan Hanley, co-head of Americas investment grade capital at BAML.
After the volatility of the first six weeks of the year, the bank had a 30% market share in high yield in the first quarter. “Our closest competitor had just 16%,” says Sarang Gadkari, the firm’s co-head of global leveraged finance. In loans the firm had a 27% market share in the first quarter.
In the US equity markets BAML goes head to head with Goldman Sachs in IPOs and secondary offerings. It has been a challenging market with issuers spooked by volatility. That means the banks that have been selected to lead deals have been the ones with the most experience, investor dialogue and distribution, says JD Moriarty, head of Americas equity capital markets. BAML was the only bank to bookrun all the IPOs that re-opened the IPO window in the US market in the early second quarter of 2016. The bank was also lead left on the largest exploration and production block trade ever for Pioneer Natural Resources in January, at a point when energy companies were most challenged. Real estate, one of only a few sectors financing in the first quarter, has also been strong for BAML.
While M&A volumes are down, BAML has gained market share, emphasizing its ability to do well when markets are under pressure. It served as exclusive financial adviser to Towers Watson on its $18.2 billion merger-of-equals transaction with Willis Group Holdings.