|
|
| Aldar/Sorouh $2.3 billion merger | |
| Advisers | Goldman Sachs, NBAD (steering committee); Credit Suisse (Aldar); Morgan Stanley (Sorouh) |
| return to the Deals of the Year 2013 index | |
Abu Dhabi has regained confidence since Aldar and Sorouh’s merger. Real estate and equity indices have risen. There has been a surge in new deals from state investment fund Mubadala, the biggest Aldar shareholder (a position that in part led Mubadala to a loss in 2010, because of fair-value write-downs).
Aldar and the less leveraged Sorouh used to be among Abu Dhabi’s largest developers. Meanwhile, real estate projects in Abu Dhabi leading up to the 2008 and 2009 UAE real estate crash were at times even more ambitious than those in the federation’s second biggest emirate, Dubai.
“A strong and stable real estate sector is crucial to the realization of Abu Dhabi’s vision,” says Greg Fewer, CFO of Aldar. “Now a national real estate champion can better utilize infrastructure and develop a single land bank with greater purpose and conviction than in a more fragmented sector.”
The $2.3 billion merger has further significance for the future of Gulf M&A, by improving the scope for local and regional sector consolidation, which has up to now been rare.
Indeed, this is the largest completed domestic M&A deal in the UAE since the 2008 crisis. There has been only one bigger domestic merger in the UAE in the past 10 years: the 2007 merger of Emirates Bank International and National Bank of Dubai.
Aldar and Sorouh announced terms in late January, after commencing talks in March 2012. The merger – the first in Abu Dhabi between two listed firms – became effective on June 27, following the publication of a resolution by the economy ministry.
Under the terms of the transaction, 1.288 shares in Aldar were issued in exchange for every Sorouh share. Sorouh was then dissolved and delisted. Sorouh’s managing director was to become chairman, with Sorouh and Aldar each nominating four of the remaining board members.
The lack of a takeover code in the UAE means there is no mechanism to squeeze out minorities in tender offers; this was used in the Emirates NBD merger (which also involved two listed companies). But a statutory merger meant Aldar and Sorouh could get around this problem.
It meant this transaction, unlike the Emirates NBD merger, could avoid the need to seek consent from the council of ministers to render pre-emption rights inapplicable in the share issuance (in UAE company law that is not possible by majority shareholder vote alone).
The method – although challenging and untested in the UAE – also helped to achieve synergies sooner. The Emirates NBD merger, for example, involved the creation of a new holding company and the continuation of two separate companies and two separate boards. Not so this time.
“Statutory mergers are now seen as a credible way forward for publicly listed companies in the UAE to consolidate,” says Mohammad Al Shukairy, partner at Clifford Chance, which advised Sorouh. Demonstrating the statutory framework has made domestic M&A more likely, according to other proponents of the deal.
Indeed, other domestic deals have gathered steam since the announcement of Aldar’s terms, including a potential merger of the Abu Dhabi and Dubai stock exchanges, and a $15 billion merger between Emirates Aluminium and Dubai Aluminium.
In Aldar’s case, a high-level joint steering committee, advised by Goldman Sachs and National Bank of Abu Dhabi, helped negotiations with government and regulators (in the UK, by comparison, courts give final sanction to schemes of arrangement, a similar route).
The creation of such committees has more precedents in the Gulf in M&A deals, and speaks partly to close-knit interests in relatively small nations, where state-related firms loom large. Aldar and Sorouh nevertheless had separate advisers: Credit Suisse and Morgan Stanley, respectively.
Government support helped solve a further difficulty: the legal need to allow creditors three months to oppose the deal, and scant definition in company law of who could count as a creditor in this case (a potential problem previously experienced in a deal in Oman in an objection from a fairly minor creditor).
One sign of success was Aldar’s return to the international capital markets for the first time since 2009, with a $750 million sukuk in November. “The bond anchored the capital structure of the combined company and validated the merger and its terms in the credit markets,” says Fewer.