The Facebook IPO no doubt cast a pall on the summer sunshine for senior Morgan Stanley executives. However, another bank that has had a torrid time recently is Credit Suisse. This is a little unexpected. The bank was a distinct winner from the 2008 crisis: it did not take government money and seemed to adapt quickly to the changing environment. However the share price performance in the past two years has been disastrous – it is down more than 60% since early August 2010 and now trades below its 2009 trough, close to a two-decade low. Other leading global banks have suffered, but not as much. Over the same period, JPMorgan’s share price is down by some 10% and HSBC shares are about 15% lower.
Credit Suisse’s earnings have been weak in the past two quarters, costs are too high, and now the bank is having problems with the Swiss authorities. In late June, the Swiss National Bank stated that Credit Suisse’s 5.9% core tier 1 ratio was inadequate to meet the more onerous Basle III standards. As if chief executive Brady Dougan didn’t have enough on his plate, Moody’s then downgraded the bank by three notches to A1.
In the world of the blind, the one-eyed man is blessed. Ironically, an A1 stable rating is not as bad as it sounds. For example, JPMorgan is rated only Aa3 by Moody’s. Commenting on the Moody’s downgrade, Credit Suisse CFO David Mathers said: “We are pleased that Moody’s continues to recognize Credit Suisse as one of the most highly rated banks in its peer group, citing our balanced business portfolio, strong liquidity position, improving capital position as well as our low exposure to the peripheral European economies.” I am confused. Mathers’ soothing words do not match the market’s negative view on the bank. I intend to delve deeper in my next column.
However, I did warn you many months ago that the outlook for Credit Suisse might darken. In my November 2010 column, when discussing the bank’s mediocre third-quarter 2010 results, I mused: “Is it bonfire night or bonfire of the vanities at Credit Suisse?” I then wrote: “They say no one rings a bell at the top. In April 2010, a Credit Suisse Performance Incentive Plan paid out huge amounts for the group’s most senior managers. I wondered at the time if it was wise for senior managers to accept such high pay-outs… shareholders might be unforgiving if the bank stumbled in future.” Even I, perspicacious as I am, could not have predicted how tough the following 18 months were going to be for Dougan and his senior colleagues.
And talking of David Mathers, the Credit Suisse CFO, I am reminded of an interesting observation from a senior investment banker. Senior Banker speculated that following the trading loss at JPMorgan, the days of the amateur banking CFO might be numbered. Senior Banker was referring to the fact that before his current role as JPMorgan’s CFO, Doug Braunstein used to be an investment banker. Such an appointment is not unusual in banking, where many executives are numerate, logical and familiar with risk management. Erin Callan, the penultimate CFO at Lehman Brothers, was perhaps the poster child for the promotion of a talented executive – she managed an investment banking group that advised hedge funds – to the corner office of the CFO. Also in the good old days, Sallie Krawcheck, a former bank analyst, rose to be the CFO of Citi. In future, however, a bank CFO will probably have a background in either accountancy or risk management. Although I am a believer in the generalist, I think Senior Banker might be correct. I will monitor the next few industry CFO appointments for confirmation of this new trend.