Rothchild: Overflowing with energy

Nathaniel Rothschild’s latest investment vehicle pits huge reward potential against substantial downside risk.

Equity markets might be jittery but it seems investors can’t get enough of cash shell funds backed by Nathaniel Rothschild and friends.

Last month Rothschild’s latest venture, an investment vehicle called Vallares, raised £1.35 billion ($2.16 billion) in London after placing 133 million ordinary shares at £10 each. Vallares’ four main partners, including former BP boss Tony Hayward, have also invested £100 million, the first £20 million of which will be forfeited if an acceptable investment is not made within two years. If the venture succeeds, however, the four men’s investment could more than quadruple in value. The vehicle’s remit is to invest in oil and gas companies in the emerging markets.

Vallares follows the successful listing 12 months ago of its sister company, Vallar, which raised just over £700 million. Rothschild founded Vallar with James Campbell, former head of Anglo American’s coal division, to invest in mining assets. Last month it announced a deal with Bumi, which is part of Indonesia’s Bakrie group.

Vallar is currently valued at about £2.5 billion, which, together with the amount raised by Vallares, serve as remarkable statements of faith from investors in these vehicles that have absolutely no track record.

Natural resources

The rationale is clear enough: emerging markets are in a growth cycle and natural resources are an obvious way to play that trend. That Rothschild and industry experts such as Hayward and Campbell back the funds only adds to their allure, as do the London listings.

But the downside risks are huge. Buying and controlling natural resource assets is arguably the toughest investment strategy there is because of the money and political sensitivities involved.

With pride and national prestige at stake, governments can make life very difficult for would-be investors. One only needs to consider the Vedanta Resources/Cairn India saga to see how much depends on government whim.

Vedanta’s intention to buy a controlling stake in the Indian oil interests of Cairn Energy has still to complete, nearly a year after the deal was announced, thanks to a dispute over royalty payments to a state-run oil company that has minority interests in some of Cairn’s oilfields and a misunderstanding over protocol.

Investment hurdles

Will Rothschild’s investment vehicles be able to circumnavigate the inevitable political and regulatory hurdles they will face?

Then there’s the complexity of its potential transactions. In its maiden deal Vallar plans to take a 40% to 50% stake in Bumi Resources, the largest coal mine in Indonesia, and 75% of Berau Coal Energy, the fifth-biggest producer, through a reverse takeover that will involve the owners of the Indonesian assets, primarily the Bakrie family, becoming majority shareholders in the new combined company to be renamed Bumi plc.

Separately, Vallar has agreed to buy a majority stake in Bumi Resources Minerals, a metals and mining business, via a $2 billion convertible bond. The bonds will be convertible into Bumi plc, which Vallar hopes will enter the FTSE 100, although that plan is already running behind schedule.

Although analysts believe the deal makes sense for Vallar and its shareholders, such are its intricacies it could yet unravel. Even if it goes ahead its long-term success will depend on the Vallar duo and the Bakrie family, which is not averse to controversy in its homeland, keeping their interests aligned.

With Vallar’s shares trading at a punchy 15 times 2012 earnings, investors are betting that Rothschild and his friends have a magician’s touch. But one-way bets have a habit of making their backers look foolish.