Brazil: Avoiding the commodity curse

Is the Brazilian real overvalued? Is there a credit bubble? Is Brazil headed for a correction?

The view on Brazil’s near- and mid-term prospects will, to a large extent, be determined by the answer to the currency question. And there are many valuation theories: going by Brazil’s real effective exchange rate the currency is significantly overvalued compared with its 10-year average.

One banker talking to Euromoney repeatedly used the Big Mac Index to argue that the currency is about 40% overvalued. A Nomura Securities graph is more compelling. It shows the dollar-real inverted exchange rate compared with the CRB Metal Index. The strong correlation is evident and provokes two thoughts. First, if the real’s valuation is linked to the CRB Metal Index – and as the world’s largest iron ore exporter the relationship makes sense – then the real is close to fair value, and therefore concerns about corrections are eased. The second thought feeds into growing doubts about Brazil’s commodity-driven boom: is the country in danger of (another) bout of Dutch disease?

A recent World Bank report Natural Resources in Latin America and the Caribbean: Beyond Booms and Busts? addresses these growing concerns about the region’s increasingly commodity-reliant growth.

The demand is coming from China. The speed of the growth of volumes and concentration of Brazilian exports is stark. China is now Brazil’s largest customer for minerals ($14 billion-worth a year with a year-on-year growth of 70.5%), oil and soya beans.

Commodity exports to China as a percentage of manufacturing exports to South America have grown from less than 10% in 2000 to 75% a decade later.

But some Brazilian economists are concerned that the demand from China is not so open-ended. The theory goes that Chinese demand is being created by a singular moment in its history – the mass urbanization of its population. Once the population has urbanized – a process that could take as little as 10 to 15 years), the slackening pace of all the infrastructure and construction projects that are driving Chinese urbanization becomes a problem for Brazil. India and some African countries might then offer hope of new export markets but would be unlikely to constitute a full substitute for present levels of Chinese hunger.

One Brazilian public policy consultant with close links to the Brazilian government says that the new president, Dilma Rousseff, understands this. He expects new policies to emerge that will aim to broaden the base of the Brazilian economy but he warns that it will be hard and take time.

Recent attempts to lower the real rate through increases in the IOF tax and the purchase of dollars are so short-term in effect as to be at most a footnote when viewed in the course of economic history. Instead, he says, we should expect the government to make substantial public saving cuts to create the conditions to lower interest rates and therefore the exchange rate to help other export sectors.

Expect new taxes levied on the commodity export sector to fund tax breaks for manufacturing industries – especially those using technology. Expect the government to encourage savings and increase investment in areas that can generate widespread, long-term economic improvements – education and infrastructure – and wean the country off a credit-fuelled growth that could easily spiral out of control. And expect the Rousseff government to pursue more plural global economic and political strategies that foster better relationships with the US and Europe.

The World Bank report cautiously concludes that it is possible to achieve stable, balanced and long-term economic growth despite a dependence on commodities. Possible, yes, but not easy.