Europe scores surprisingly well on leveraged loan recoveries

Recoveries in Europe for distressed junior lenders compare well with the US despite the lack of a single bankruptcy framework.

In July rating agency Moody’s published its first detailed analysis of recoveries in European private equity-backed leveraged loans. The research sheds some light on what has traditionally been a fairly opaque topic.

The fact that so many of these loans are collateral for rated CLOs has enabled the agency to derive sufficient data for the study – which before this downturn would have been limited to simply analysing the trading prices of individual defaulted debt instruments. So the figures could provide ammunition for the debate as to whether some form of Chapter 11-style regime is needed in the region.

At first glance the answer would seem to be no. Despite the lack of a single bankruptcy jurisdiction in Europe (and the perceived lower emphasis on the rights of creditors together with glacial legal processes that erode enterprise value) the results were surprisingly good: average recovery of 71% in Europe compared with 75% in the US.

However, a closer look reveals that those perceptions are clearly strongly held, as only two companies out of the 53 in the study resorted to the local bankruptcy courts – both French. Unlike in the US, the vast majority of European restructurings are settled out of court.

The Moody’s analysis also shows that despite the lack of a Chapter 11 framework the ranking priority of debt instruments still holds firm, with 80% recoveries on first-lien debt (85% in the US), but with slightly higher recoveries for US junior debt. For example, recoveries on junior debt with an additional debt cushion beneath it were 61% in the US but only 46% in Europe. This feeds the argument that junior, particularly mezzanine, debt has a tough time in European restructurings, with the senior lenders traditionally wiping out the juniors to ensure their own recovery.

However, junior lenders in Europe do have one advantage over their US peers: the ability to exploit poor documentation. In the US, Chapter 11 provides strong protection for the company against junior lenders trying to establish a ransom position.

However, in Europe poorly drafted inter-creditor agreements can afford opportunities for the juniors to do just this – as was the case in the European Directories dispute last year when the juniors managed to block a €1.5 billion debt-equity swap because of weak documentation.

As so many of the LBOs that characterized the boom years might be prone to just such sloppy paperwork, this could turn out to be the junior creditors’ best line of defence in the predicted surge of disputes to come.