The brave new dawn of bank capital was ushered in at the end of January with Rabobank’s $2 billion non-call 5.5-year perpetual deal, underwritten by Bank of America Merrill Lynch, Credit Suisse, Morgan Stanley and Rabobank. The hybrid deal was the first to incorporate a permanent write-down feature and is the future of hybrid issuance under Basle III. The deal has jumped the gun somewhat, taking place before regulatory certainty that it will be Capital Requirements Directive 4 compliant. But the Dutch bank forged ahead anyway, cognizant that market conditions could deteriorate before that clarity emerges.
The deal is a clear sign of the priority that banks are placing on coming up with funding options that will meet the tougher capital requirements under Basle III. That the $2 billion deal attracted $7 billion of orders cannot be hailed as evidence of healthy appetite for the new hybrid structures – this is triple-A rated Rabobank after all. Second-tier institutions will find it much tougher to attract buyers for instruments such as this with bail-in type features.
If the banks do not consider meeting their tier 1 capital ratios a sufficient challenge, rating agency Standard & Poor’s recently published research claiming that 75 of the largest global banks could need an additional €577 billion to meet the final 7% minimum common tier 1 ratio. The rating agency calculated risk-adjusted capital (RAC) ratios for the banks and found a sharp disparity between this and their regulatory tier 1 ratios – sometimes shockingly so. It claims that RAC is a more meaningful comparison between the banks because of the lengthy transitional arrangements and lack of clarity on some technical details of Basle III.
Under S&P’s calculations, Credit Suisse had an estimated RAC at June 2010 of just 5.8% – well below its Basle tier 1 ratio at the same date of a healthy 16.3%. Credit Suisse has, not surprisingly, reacted angrily to the report, stating that “S&P’s methodology is not in line with the demands of stringent new international banking rules” and says that it “does not fully include the phase-in and other transitional changes planned under the new regime”.
Credit Suisse came out particularly poorly in the S&P analysis because of its high level of hybrid instruments and because the agency did not take into account future tax benefits (S&P admitted that its RAC ratio would be more than 200 basis points higher without the deduction of tax loss carried forward).
Other banks that struggled under the S&P methodology were Deutsche Bank (RAC 6.5%, tier 1 ratio 11.3%) and Morgan Stanley (RAC 8.1%, tier 1 ratio 16.5%). Bank of China topped the ranking with an RAC of 13.4% and Commerzbank brought up the rear with an RAC of just 3.6%. Some banks may rail at S&P’s approach but the figures serve to highlight just how much of a priority meeting the new bank capital ratios has now become.