European sovereign debt: Tot ziens België, adieu Belgique?

Belgium’s strained communal relations and ramshackle politics mean its financial problems could be fatal for the nation.

Never mind the break-up of the eurozone, Europe could witness the dissolution of a nation state before this financial crisis is done. Despite the best efforts of Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain the poster child of Europe’s sovereign debt crisis might well become Belgium.

At first glance Belgium’s plight does not seem too worrying. It has a current account surplus, low household debt and a high savings rate. Its budget deficit of 4.6% of GDP is much lower than France’s, never mind Portugal or Greece, and unlike Spain and Ireland it is not suffering from a real estate bust. Its national debt of €400 billion is less than half the loss racked up by AIG in 2007-08.

Yet Belgium’s future is gloomy; so unpromising that Bedlam Asset Management thinks the country is the surprise candidate for sovereign default by the end of 2012. Its debt-to-GDP ratio is nearly 100% and only Italy, Greece and Ireland have a higher ratio in the EU.

Belgium is a microcosm of the eurozone’s problems: a wealthy north subsidizing an impoverished south; distinct cultures with little in common co-existing uneasily; and, crucially, a country paralysed by a political vacuum.

Belgium is made up of three regions: Flemish (Dutch)-speaking Flanders in the north; French-speaking Wallonia in the south, and in the centre, Brussels, the bilingual unofficial capital of the EU. The economic and cultural differences between Flanders and Wallonia are huge. The income per head of Flanders is 118% of the EU average, according to Bedlam, while in Wallonia it is 85%. The Flemish make up 70% of the skilled labour force. Unemployment among French speakers is twice that of Flemish speakers. If Belgium’s national debt were divided proportionately between the two regions, Wallonia would need to service €260 billion of it. It cannot do so on its own. How long Flanders will continue to prop up Wallonia remains to be seen but last year Flemish leaders indicated that after 2012 the region would no longer help to lower the fiscal deficit, claiming it does more than enough to support the federal government.

Wallonia also depends on fiscal transfers from Brussels, which is one of the wealthiest regions in the eurozone. That wealth, though, has come almost entirely from EU capitals pouring money into the city. Given that austerity is now the biggest priority for European governments, that largesse will shrink, as will Wallonia’s cut.

What is spooking investors most is Belgium’s political crisis. The country has been without a government since June following the collapse of the coalition government because of strains between the Flemish and Walloons.

With no prospect of a new government, King Albert II was forced to intervene last month, urging the caretaker government to produce a more aggressive fiscal plan. His actions brought some calm to bond markets, which were pushing Belgian spreads on 10-year debt to their highest level in nearly 20 years. This breathing space will be temporary unless a lasting political solution is found.

Scepticism about Belgium is not new. Cultural and linguistic differences have plagued it ever since its inception in 1830. The euro was supposed to help narrow those divisions. Ironically, its crisis could be the trigger that finally pulls Belgium apart.