Just what did the ratings agencies expect? That they would get off scot-free for giving solid ratings to mortgage-backed and asset-backed securities that ultimately blew up in the sub-prime crisis? The fact that Moody’s, Standard & Poor’s and Fitch are desperately arguing against pending legislation that classes them as “experts” and makes them liable for the ratings they give out seems to imply that they don’t trust their own ability to rate bonds accurately.
The ratings agencies have been criticized for too long for potential conflicts of interest. If they are being paid by the companies issuing securities to provide a rating, then it is in their financial interest to, first, agree to provide a rating and, second, provide a rating that is acceptable to the issuing company. The agencies have long disputed the notion that they are conflicted, claiming that any such bias would damage their reputation. Well, their reputation has been damaged enough. Now is the chance for ratings agencies to instil confidence in their services by getting in line with the proposed legislation.
There are many parts of the financial reform programme that can be argued against but the stance on ratings agencies is not one of them. Giving the SEC the right to deregister or fine agencies if they provide inappropriate ratings is crucial to getting the securitization market back on track. And the insistence that ratings analysts should pass qualifying examinations and continue with education is a sensible demand.
However, the six-month waiver that the SEC has granted the disputing agencies to prepare themselves for the legislation ahead is perhaps necessary. The legislation will increase ratings agencies’ costs and might have the unwanted effect of driving some out of the market. Long the domain of just two and, in latter years, three ratings agencies (after Fitch came on the scene), in the period leading up to the crisis there had been a welcome increase in competition from companies such as AM Best and Morningstar. The cost burden of legislation might drive those newer players out. Let’s hope it has the opposite effect. The proposed legislation for ratings agencies will actually make for a much more level playing field among providers. If raters are all acting within the same legislative environment, with the same strict guidelines, should it matter to a company whether they are rated by Moody’s or AM Best? The rating will, in theory, be of the same quality.