For as long as we are in a financial crisis, anti-bank sentiment looks unlikely to wane. In the Great Depression, it was JPMorgan that felt the wrath of the public. In the Great Recession it is Goldman Sachs.
Animosity towards the firm has reached phenomenal proportions. The public seems to want to trace any negative event back to the firm. IndyMac’s private equity buyers got a sweetheart deal? Clearly it has something to do with Goldman Sachs, intimates a video that caused such a stir on YouTube in February that the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation had to issue a rebuttal (US Banking: Private equity smells too strong for FDIC, Euromoney, March 2010). The fact that the only link seems to be that one of the buyers was once a Goldman Sachs employee matters little. The association itself is enough to further fuel the public’s ire and result in an audience of millions.
Yet despite the firm’s unpopularity among the public, Goldman’s shareholders must be delighted. A study by Boston Consulting Group shows that the firm has produced the greatest shareholder value of all the large-cap investment-banking franchises worldwide in 2009. Its total shareholder return for the year was 58.2%, which is 37.1% more than the US stock market as a whole. Indeed, the firm generated more alpha relative to local markets than any large-cap financial company in the world over the period.
It’s a quandary. An individual who lost his job at the end of 2008 might well have wanted to blame Goldman Sachs for causing the economic crisis but had he or she invested a redundancy package in Goldman Sachs stocks, they would have something to celebrate.
It’s a bitter pill to swallow, and perhaps the excuse the Federal Reserve grants itself for not slapping Goldman Sachs over the knuckles. Because one has to ask why, given public backing, the US government hasn’t taken Goldman Sachs to task yet? Recent revelations of how Goldman Sachs made AIG pay up for CDO losses, while forcing the losses itself, seem only to be furrowing brows at a Federal level. Is anyone going to be made to pay? Sources say the Volcker Rule is the punishment, but they admit that it will do little to stop the materialistic ambitions of Goldman Sachs. “The knives are out for Goldman Sachs, but are only half-hearted in their aim” seems to be the consensus.
One has to question therefore whether this is simply the order of the day from now on. Surely, there will have to be some recompense? Or is Goldman Sachs just the new unethical stock? One can moan all one likes, but it is perhaps wise to whack a few Goldman Sachs shares into your portfolio of tobacco, alcohol, gambling firms and weapons manufacturers.