Sovereign debt: ECB must keep liquidity pumping

Governor Trichet must play it safe as markets fret about sovereign debt.

We all know the saying “you made your bed, now you must lie in it”. That’s what faces the European Union as it seeks a solution to the potential financial meltdown being generated by Greece’s fiscal crisis, which threatens to envelope its EU’s neighbours.

The EU’s inability to police its profligate member states in a situation where budget deficits have made a joke of the 3% of GDP ceiling, while incentivizing the banking system to invest in government debt that is anything but risk free, has placed the EU and its central bank in an awkward position. The event risk pertaining to the access to bond markets for southern European sovereigns has the potential to damage the fragile recovery within the banking sector, by propagating a repricing of risk. European banks, particularly in the south, are facing sharply higher funding costs and significant markdowns on the asset portfolios all at a time when they need to increase term funding. This threatens a recovery in the institutional loan markets and could limit access to the capital markets for high-yield bond issuers barely a year after they reopened for business.

This is not a time for the European Central Bank to begin its withdrawal of special liquidity programmes, which it says it has already begun to do. It was only on January 27 that ECB council member Axel Weber said the bank would take further steps in the first half of the year to withdraw liquidity from the banking system, on the basis that the economy of Europe was gathering strength. This is unfortunate timing and the ECB must play safe rather than sure by keeping them in place for a longer period, because the risks of not doing so could destabilize bond markets and curb demand for government debt.

Banks and government debt markets are now virtually interdependent. For instance, lowering the ratings bar on eligible collateral is one mechanism that the ECB could impose as Greece faces further ratings cuts. As one investor says: “The ECB is caught between a rock and a hard place.”

In December the ECB said its third offer of 12-month loans to banks would be its last while also announcing it would discontinue six-month loans after March.

So if that is not desirable for Europe, then why is the US beginning to withdraw liquidity from its banking system? Last month the Fed closed at least three liquidity facilities, and raised the discount rate.

Credit-default swap markets suggest there is a decoupling occurring between the markets in Europe and the US as well. Will the sovereign crisis have no impact on US markets? Some suggest it is understating its impact. If Europe was complacent in the early days of the sub-prime crisis, then perhaps the US is being complacent now. That will depend on how well Europe contains the fires of southern Europe.