Structured credit winds up – in court

Issuers and underwriters are braced for more structured credit litigation.

Given the almost total destruction of the structured credit market since 2007, it was inevitable that a wave of litigation would follow. If the exhaustive media coverage afforded to Goldman Sachs’s problems with its Abacus 2007 CDO earlier this year showed anything it is that such cases had hardly been commonplace.

While the litigation spotlight was firmly shifted to the mortgage-backed market following the foreclosure scandal that recently broke in the US, lawyers are, however, sharpening their briefs across the spectrum of the market.

Following the Abacus furore last April, Credit Suisse analysts drew up a “CDO litigation risk” ranking of banks with underwriting exposure to CDOs with salient characteristics similar to the Goldman vehicle that landed the bank with a record $550 million fine from the SEC. Bank of America topped the list. However, ironically it was Credit Suisse itself that was slapped with a synthetic structured credit lawsuit at the end of November.

The bank, together with, among others, Standard & Poor’s, is being sued by Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank (ADCB) over the restructuring of a structured investment vehicle – Stanford Victoria. The Gulf bank invested in an emergency restructuring of the vehicle – dubbed Farmington – based on what it claims is false and misleading information. ADCB has form here: in August 2008 it filed a class action lawsuit for fraud, negligent misrepresentation and unjust enrichment over another SIV capital note investment – this one in Cheyne Finance. The suit was filed against Morgan Stanley, Bank of New York Mellon, Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s. In October 2009 the non-fraud claims against the rating agencies were dismissed by a US district judge but the fraud allegation was left to stand.

This case is the latest SIV investment to land up in the courts: pension fund Calpers filed a suit in mid-2009 against the three main rating agencies over its $1.3 billion investments in the same two SIVs – Cheyne and Stanfield Victoria – and also in Sigma Finance, the largest of these vehicles which imploded in October 2008. And IKB Deutsche Industriebank – which itself sued Goldman Sachs over its exposure to the Abacus 2007 CDO – is fighting numerous actions related to its failed Rhinebridge SIV. But the traffic is not all one way: UBS has filed a complaint against Highland Capital claiming that it was fraudulently induced to restructure one of the asset manager’s CDOs.

All this activity seems to indicate that litigation over failed structured financings could be set to accelerate. Goldman has been hit with a series of sub-prime CDO lawsuits since the Abacus case: in October it was sued by German bank LBBW over its $37 million loss in another such vehicle, Davis Square CDO.

According to NERA Economic Consulting, as of May this year total write-downs and losses stemming from the credit crisis had reached $1.8 trillion worldwide, with the total number of lawsuits related to the crisis exceeding 400. This was up from 130 in July 2008. The data show that filings peaked in the second quarter of 2008, with 170 filings in that year. There were 136 in 2009. But the nature of the defendants in the cases is changing: in 2007 mortgage lenders, home builders and real estate investment trusts dominated proceedings but by 2010 issuers and underwriters were named in 60% of cases up to May. The NERA analysis points out that even though the number of credit-crisis filings has declined and almost half of decisions to date have been dismissals, the types of allegations, products and defendants continue to shift and the cases against some – most notably the rating agencies – have survived several motions to dismiss and will proceed. So although they might have been some time in incubation, the structured-credit chickens could be coming home to roost.