The resolution of an acrimonious restructuring dispute in September has again raised the issue of the rights of junior lenders in the workout process.
Mezzanine lenders to German specialist alumina producer Almatis eventually succeeded in persuading management against a senior lender-backed restructuring (that would have seen them wiped out) by convincing them that the company was worth more than the senior lenders claimed. The result is in stark contrast to the outcome of the IMO CarWash dispute in Europe last year where senior lenders saw off a challenge from mezzanine funds, which – together with sponsor Carlyle Group – lost their money.
The IMO CarWash decision seemed to demonstrate the likely extremely weak position of junior lenders in this downturn as companies are simply so overlevered that value will never break in the mezz tranches. Success or failure in restructuring disputes largely hangs on convincing the judge of where value breaks in the capital stack: senior lenders want value to break in the senior debt, thereby dismissing any claims of junior parties, and subordinated lenders need to prove that value breaks within their tranches to give them a claim. The valuations produced by opposing sides unsurprisingly vary substantially given the motivations of the parties that commission them.
The Almatis situation is unusual in that the mezzanine lenders joined forces with the equity sponsor to counter a Chapter 11 process that senior lenders intended to use to take control of the business. Almatis filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in April this year, burdened with more than $1 billion in debt on which it had defaulted in June 2009. Distressed debt investor Oaktree, which together with other investors ended up controlling 50% of Almatis’s outstanding debt, was instrumental in convincing management that the business was unsustainable and put forward a restructuring proposal under which both mezzanine and equity (the firm had been bought by Dubai International Corp in 2007) would be flushed.
After a year-long battle for control of the firm, however, DIC and the mezz steering committee (Alcentra, Babson Capital, Permira and Northwestern Mutual Capital) persuaded management to approve their plan, which involves the injection of $100 million of fresh equity into Almatis and a debt-for-equity swap for mezzanine lenders to give them a 40% stake. Senior creditors will be repaid at par via $550 million of new debt financing from GSO Capital Partners, Sankaty Credit Opportunities, GoldenTree Asset Management, Bank of America Merrill Lynch and JPMorgan.
This unlikely outcome might embolden mezzanine creditors and give senior lenders pursuing loan-to-own strategies pause for thought. But it also highlights the shocking disparity in valuations that are produced in such disputes. In the IMO CarWash deal the senior lenders commissioned Rothschild and PwC to produce their valuation, which came between €225 million and €250 million while the mezz used LEK Consultants (€385 million to €398 million). But in Almatis the senior valuation, which was prepared by Moelis, valued the firm at roughly €400 million while the mezz valuation from Capstone was closer to €800 million.
Despite the confrontational nature of these valuation mandates, it seems quite baffling that the numbers can vary to this extent. But given the unstable state of many corporate balance sheets and the difficulty in forecasting cashflows in an uncertain economic climate they are likely to continue to do so. This will embolden junior lenders to try their luck and far more of these cases might end up in court than would otherwise have been the case.