Sixteen months after the collapse of Lehman Brothers, and the near failure of the financial system, the world’s governments and financial regulators are still some way from agreeing the inevitable new set of rules that will shape the landscape of financial markets and, hopefully, prevent crises of such magnitude in the future.
Finding common ground will not be easy. European banks still complain about the failure of their US counterparts to institute Basle I. US banks counter that European banks are relatively over-leveraged. Each will seek to gain an advantage.
European banks are in no mood, however, to lay down to their US competitors. An off-the-record discussion with one of Europe’s senior bankers threw light on how the battleground might look.
The banker told Euromoney: “In Europe the banking system has passed through the crisis much better than our US competitors. Why? Probably because we have had better risk control and better risk management. My feeling is that large universal banks with big retail and commercial banking components have a better culture of risk management from the point of view both of credit intermediation and liquidity risk.”
He continues: “That is very different from classic investment banking in the US which has less of a culture of risk managing credit portfolios for the long term but instead considers that, at any moment, it is always possible to derive a market value for any financial asset. From there, it is very easy to make the assumption that it is always possible to liquidate them.”
He adds: “Given the assumption that the market would always provide liquidity, there was a habit especially in the US of regularly refinancing assets and increasingly of doing so through conduits that were kept off balance sheet, whereas in Europe much more of those assets were still included on balance sheet.”
In this banker’s view, that means European banks and regulators should shape the new framework. “The US and Europe are in competition in banking. This was mainly a crisis of the US banking industry itself and of regulation and there is no reason for Europe not to take advantage of this.”
In Europe, a lot of discussion has centred around potential conflicts between the continent and banks based in the City of London. To this banker’s mind, that would be counterproductive: “If we are to negotiate with the Americans, we Europeans must first negotiate among ourselves and develop one view and speak with one voice. We must be as united as possible in Europe in asking the US to agree with and implement the G20 regulations and the Basle II rules. We need one system of rules, applied in the same way to all banks and we need one system of accounting. If we have a level playing field,” he says, “I am convinced we can show that the European system is better and have more business come to Europe including to the City of London.”
Does this banker believe that US regulators will agree to a Europe-led framework?
“I fear they may not,” he says, “and that may be dangerous, when you look at what happened at Citi and at AIG and with the monolines, and the agencies as well as Bear Stearns and Lehman… this has not been a great success for US regulation.”
And what would be the outcome should they fail to do so?
“We might have to suggest that we could not consider the US banks as being well-regulated.”
The implications are left hanging in air.