Government debt markets and the return of the bond vigilante

Banks are starting to assess the need to risk weight sovereign debt holdings.

This year is set to be a big one for government bond markets. Both in Europe and the US, governments are forecast to increase their net issuance of debt by as much as 40% in 2010 as they attempt to plug holes in their ballooning deficits. At the same time, in what could look like an attempt at brinkmanship, some of the world’s biggest bond managers say they’re cutting their exposure to US and UK government debt.

Bond funds such Pimco, the world’s largest, with almost a trillion dollars of assets under management, argue that record levels of issuance coinciding with the phasing out of central bank sponsored bond-buyback schemes will result in a rise in government bond yields. As a result they say they are cutting their exposure to UK and US debt. Other bond managers such as BlackRock, Barings Asset Management and Standard Life Investments publicly share a similar view. So does this mean a buyers’ strike and the return of the bond vigilantes?

The rise in government bond yields late last year would suggest so. Yields on 10-year Treasuries have spiked since the end of November from about 3.2% to 3.8% as Euromoney goes to print. That may be small change, according to some. Morgan Stanley reckons yields could rise as high as 5.5%, which would represent the sharpest rise in more than a decade. The UK has also seen 10-year government bond yields rise more than 50 basis points to 4% over the same period.

It’s a bad omen for a global economy looking for the light at the end of the recessionary tunnel. For investors to lose confidence in the fiscal and monetary authorities now would nip any recovery in the bud. For example, it would push 30-year mortgage rates in the US from 7.5% to 8%, says Morgan Stanley.

But there is a wider point here that goes well beyond mortgage rates in the US, and that’s the question of whether government bonds are risk-free. The debate has become more urgent following the recent downgrades of Greece and Iceland. That’s because banks, the very institutions governments have spent the last two years bailing out, have large holdings of government debt, for which they assign zero risk weightings. The developed western economy defaulting previously seemed preposterous; that is no longer the case.

With the economic and fiscal fundamentals for western governments having deteriorated sharply in the past two years, the risk-free rate may face some serious challenges as the unquestioned reference rate and cornerstone of the fixed income markets. Readers won’t need any reminding of what happened in financial markets when the Libor reference rate crumbled in 2008.

Anecdotal evidence suggests that large institutions are now in discussions about the need to make provisions for sovereign credit risk in the same way banks are required to set aside reserves to cover losses from corporate and emerging markets. Governments going to the bond market had better buckle up for what is sure to be a rough ride in 2010.