Europe: Banks need to bite funding bullet

Europe’s financial institutions must realize that the price of issuance is unlikely to improve any time soon.

While the stress tests have given investors greater clarity about European bank balance sheets, enabling them to tick that very important solvency box, the desire of Europe’s banks to come to the market with large benchmark debt issues still remains somewhat circumspect.

There’s a pure and simple reason for that. Funding costs in the bond markets remain high, relative to where they were in the first quarter, when a typical AA-rated bank could issue a benchmark five-year deal at 80 basis points over Libor. The sovereign crisis prompted that yield premium to almost double in some cases, and as a result many issuers have continued to sit on the sidelines.

They shouldn’t wait any longer. The harsh realization for European banks is that higher funding costs are here to stay, says Martin Egan, BNP Paribas’ global head of primary markets and origination. Indeed, now might be a good time to come to the market, given the recent rally in spreads on the back of successful sovereign issuance from some of the region’s peripheral sovereigns, such as Spain. That has led credit default swap spreads to rally on average 25bp to 30bp since the beginning of July. For instance, Crédit Agricole would have paid in the region of 160bp to issue a five-year bond in July, now it is likely to pay 130bp.

Egan points out that as the EU economy emerges from recession and the European Central Bank starts signalling the withdrawal of its liquidity provision there will be more pressure on banks to issue than not. The summer lull might therefore present an opportunity for banks to get some funding while the market is less crowded, and traditionally the US and UK debt markets typically remain open in the August period, when continental Europe goes to the beach.

Year to date, European banks have issued $387 billion, with 75% of that raised in the first four months of the year, according to Dealogic. In January, most analysts were forecasting annual issuance to be in the region of $650 billion. Hence there’s some need to pick up the run rate, and that’s not even without considering the extra funding requirements that are likely to come out of the new capital requirements from Basle III, which Credit Suisse forecasts could mean European banks have a €500 billion term-funding shortfall.

It could have been worse though. Under the original proposals Credit Suisse estimated that the term funding gap was about €1.3 trillion under the original proposals. The Basle committee decided to delay its planned “net stable funding ratio”, a first-of-its-kind liquidity rule, after banks lobbied furiously to have it modified, because of its potentially adverse impact on the real economy. The NSFR requires banks to match the duration of their liabilities and assets more closely. It will be placed in an “observation phase” until at least 2018 and might be modified substantially.

Deutsche Bank’s forthright credit strategist, Jim Reid, summed it up on the Monday after the stress test results. There was nothing from those results to make him change his view that the ECB would continue to have to be the required funder of last resort to the sector for many quarters to come; the funding problem remains an acute issue.