UAE banks Looking for a broader focus: Stronger but still exposed

Banks in the United Arab Emirates are better regulated than they used to be and have invested in new technology. But, as Nigel Dudley reports, the sector is still highly fragmented and vulnerable to outside shocks

A SUPPLEMENT TO EUROMONEY/MARCH 1998: UNITED ARAB EMIRATES

The leading financial institutions in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) positively bristle with the state-of-the-art technology that enables them to offer the latest products and services to their customers. Internet websites, telephone banking, point-of-sale operations, automatic teller machines and sophisticated back-office computers are all taken for granted. Management structures have been modernized as well, with credit assessment increasingly conducted at banks’ head offices and branches serving as retail showrooms.

These developments will help the banks to build their retail and investment services and look for business opportunities in the rest of the Middle East and beyond rather than focusing on the domestic market. Bankers believe these business areas will play an increasing role in the future as the banks diversify away from their core activities of trade and project finance.

The benefits of this approach have been seen over the past year as the banks have taken advantage of a vibrant UAE economy and produced sharply increased profits while investing significantly in technology. According to the central bank, preliminary figures show that the profits of local banks were up by 26.1% and those of foreign banks rose by 24.6%.

There is little evidence of a change in economic sentiment. The construction boom continues in both Abu Dhabi and Dubai (the two largest of the seven emirates that make up the UAE) where a steady flow of international companies continue to set up regional offices. Barely a month passes without the opening of a new hotel or office block.

“Business grew at 10% over the year,” says Anton Najjar, general manager of the Dubai Marriott. “But 1998 will be a testing year. It is the first year since 1994 when we have had a major increase in capacity, with more than 1,500 rooms coming on-stream.”

But there will be sighs of relief if hotel overcapacity is the most difficult challenge facing the UAE this year. Commenting on the banking sector’s results for last year, central bank governor sultan bin Nasser al-Suwaidi warned: “Despite these good results, the UAE economy is part of the world economy and will be influenced by the major world financial crises. Banks, other financial institutions, commercial companies and individuals should be prudent and refrain from expanding activity or investment prior to realistic justifications and feasibility studies.”

It is a salutary warning to a sector that is vulnerable to changes in the economic climate. The UAE banking system has, on several occasions in the past 15 years, faced crises, most notably from the combination of poor asset quality and falling oil prices. These were only resolved by the intervention of the governments of Abu Dhabi and Dubai.

The present outlook is far from rosy. Although Abu Dhabi has started to develop other sectors of its economy, oil and gas remain the major income earners, producing nearly half of the country’s GDP. If the crisis in Asia leads to a much lower oil price this year, a drop in revenue could feed into the economy through a reduction in government contracts and slower payments. This could hurt customers, particularly those on the margin, say bankers.

The main difference between the present situation and past economic problems which have damaged the banks is that central-bank regulation has improved considerably in the past five years to bring the UAE’s banking laws more into line with international practice. This has made the industry more responsible, transparent and accountable.

The central bank has taken a more active approach to introducing stricter reporting standards and regulations. Capital-adequacy ratios must be at least 10%, a controversial limit of 7% of capital funds has been imposed on exposures to a single non-state-sector borrower, tighter controls have been introduced to monitor loan portfolios and ensure that quality is maintained and banks have been instructed to seek central-bank approval before making senior management appointments. Governor al-Suweidi has been quick to warn institutions when he thinks they are focusing too much on one industrial or geographical area.

“The banks are now more sophisticated and better managed,” says one Dubai banker. “They have a better analytical capacity to assess risk. There are systems and controls that were simply not there 15 years ago. The central bank now has a strong presence which has helped the banks through the difficult times and ensured that managements have become more sophisticated.”

But al-Suwaidi faces a formidable task if he is to implement further measures to increase public disclosure and to develop capital markets. He has to balance the different, and sometimes competing, approaches of Dubai and Abu Dhabi and needs to win the support of banks that are reluctant to see more controls on their activities. As a result, regulations have been introduced more slowly than the central bank would have liked.

The clearest example of the problems facing governor al-Suwaidi is that new banking legislation, which most bankers in Dubai believe is necessary if the UAE is to establish itself as a regional banking centre, has been delayed for more than a year. This law would map out the enforcement mechanisms over banks, clarify ambiguities over foreign-exchange and option contracts (which have been held by some sharia courts to be illegal), make money-laundering illegal and clarify the central bank’s authority for liquidating banks. It would legislate for banks to meet international accounting standards on public disclosure, a measure which, say officials, the financial institutions express enthusiasm for but are reluctant to introduce.

The lack of disclosure, which makes it hard for independent analysts to assess the quality of assets, has accentuated the concern of some bankers about the rapid growth of retail lending. But, as a report by Moody’s Investors Service notes: “The sector has largely overcome the severe asset-quality difficulties of the 1980s.”

Another development, which bankers regard as important, is the establishment of a stock exchange to replace the present over-the-counter market and enable the UAE to offer investment opportunities similar to those offered by the expanding markets of Oman, Bahrain and Kuwait. But there is no sign yet that the government will authorize this step.

“They were looking at this as long ago as 1981,” says one local banker. “But the Soukh al-Manakh [Kuwait stock market] crash put the brakes on it. They were becoming more positive last year but the crisis in Asia has made them think again.”

Unless there is some rapid movement on establishing a local stock exchange, leading institutions such as Emirates Bank International and British Bank of the Middle East, which have established investment-banking operations, will become increasingly frustrated. They point out that there is plenty of investible money which at present goes into property or overseas. Both investors and companies would gain if there were opportunities for businesses to fund themselves through equity issues rather than by short-term financing.

“We need to create another avenue for financing,” says one local banker. “Now the only source is bank lending. The most successful banks have been financing sectors where there is a quick turnover. The UAE institutions are flush with funds but need to look to the medium or long term.”

The potential is demonstrated by the success of Emirates Bank International’s Emirates Equity Fund. “This is the first stock-market mutual fund, with Dh350 million ($95 million), and it invests in 34 stocks traded in the UAE,” says Suresh Kumar, general manager of Emirates Bank International’s investment-banking operation, Emirates Merchant Bank. “It gave the first opportunity to expatriates and non-UAE nationals to invest. The fund was well received, exceeding our expectations in terms of investor response.”

Another development being considered by the central bank is an end to the policy that has excluded new foreign entrants to the banking sector for nearly 16 years. Although there are plenty of banks – 46 in total, 27 of them foreign, serving a population of 2.4 million – the market is dominated by five institutions: National Bank of Abu Dhabi, National Bank of Dubai, Emirates Bank International, Mashreq Bank and Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank. Their main competition comes from foreign banks such as British Bank of the Middle East, Standard Chartered, ANZ Grindlays and Barclays rather than from other local banks, whose market shares are relatively small. Ten local banks have less than 1% of the market each.

“The banks always insist that there is tough competition,” says one banker. “But the level of profits suggests there is room for more banks. It would make sense for the central bank to end its moratorium.”

But local players contend that the sector is less overbanked than it appears. All the domestic banks except Mashreq Bank are focused on one emirate and have only one or two branches in other parts of the uae. At Emirates Bank International, managing director and chief executive Anis Al Jallaf is adamant that “competition is very tough. That is why we have to come up with innovative products. We were the first bank to introduce mutual funds. We had the first Islamic fund and we were involved in the first regional share flotation”.

Jallaf also argues that to survive banks have to look beyond the constraints of the local market. “We have taken a 10% stake in the Bank of Beirut in Lebanon. Financial institutions have to look regionally, whether setting up subsidiaries and branches or forming strategic alliances. We see the region as stretching from India to the Levant and the Bank of Beirut as a bank that can work with us in the Lebanese markets.”

There is also consensus that the smallest banks will eventually disappear. A report by Moody’s states: “Rising levels of competition and indications that the central bank may relax its licensing moratorium will increase pressure on some of the smaller and weaker banks to consider merging.”

Some bankers believe that will only be the start of the process. “Banks in this region must have the guts to follow the trends we see internationally,” says one Gulf banker. “There is no doubt that you become stronger by becoming bigger. I can see the time when there are just four regional Arab banks who could extend their activities from Indonesia to Morocco.”