Flight from the churning masses

The sales pitch for the EFG International IPO in October 2005 was that the bank would use the proceeds to continue to grow over the next three to five years at a comparable rate to the impressive expansion of the recent past.

The sales pitch for the EFG International IPO in October 2005 was that the bank would use the proceeds to continue to grow over the next three to five years at a comparable rate to the impressive expansion of the recent past.

Lonnie Howell, chief executive officer of EFG International, phrases this as modestly as he can. “We are trying to position ourselves as a consolidator over the next 10 years. Over the next three years we want to get ourselves out of the churning mass of banks in this business. From a size point, on a global basis, right now we’re in the middle of the middle and we’d like to get to the small end of the large.”

The plan is to grow from a bank with SFr26 billion of assets under management today to one with SFr76 billion ($58 billion) in three years. From there, the ambition is to press on and ultimately build AUM of SFr100 billion to SFr200 billion. As a point of comparison, at present UBS has wealth management AUM 30 times greater than EFG’s.

Private banking in Europe is an industry that appears steeped in history and tradition as ancient as its royal families. Howell doesn’t see it like this. He sees the opportunities of an immature market.

“It’s a unique and huge market that no one really identified as such until relatively recently – the last 10 to 15 years,” he says. “It has maybe SFr100 trillion in assets under management and SFr1 trillion in annual revenues, but it’s a business that’s still not widely recognized.

“It does not have a great mass of professionals within it that have run major private banking businesses. Many people still fall into private banking as a career by accident. And within this, we have a business model that makes sense and people who make sense.”

If EFG is disciplined about paying 2.5% for AUM, the proceeds from the IPO will enable it to treble in size by the end of 2008. That expected growth rate explains a P/E ratio far in excess of that for any group operating in the same business.

An expensive investment?

According to analysis by Joanna Lader at Lehman Brothers, EFG trades on 52.6 times estimated 2005 earnings, far ahead of the 12.6 average P/E ratio for large Swiss banks UBS and Credit Suisse, and the average of 17 for smaller private banks like Julius Baer, Vontobel and Sarasin. At the same time its expected compound annual growth rate for 2004 to 2007 earnings is also off the scale at 67%, compared with an 11.9% average Lehman attributes to the large and small Swiss banks.

Doubters in the stock market worry that successful execution of this plan is already largely priced into the stock. “EFG is a very expensive bank by any measure we employ,” notes Jacques-Henri Gaulard, research analyst at Merrill Lynch. Management’s determination to speed up EFG’s development and outgrow its peers, he reckons, dictated raising as much as possible from the initial offering and precluded leaving much value on the table for investors.

But existing investors have not cashed out a penny. They remain locked in to the stock, for up to five years for management and employees – with a staggered release of 20% per annum – and one year for the EFG Group, for which read the Latsis family.

Can EFG International grow to the next level without losing the special culture that has helped it thrive? Managing 250 CROs might permit an absence of bureaucracy and a sense of entrepreneurship; will that continue to be the case with 500, or 2,000?

“That’s the challenge,” says Antonio Villalon, co-head of European financial institutions group at Lehman Brothers, the investment banker who has been advising the company for the past five years in which the IPO went from a distant dream to reality. “But they have their feet on the ground. And personally, I think they’re going to outperform what they’ve promised.”

Villalon sees the IPO as a defining moment in establishing the bank. He is thinking of its current share of clients’ wallets – what they spend on private banking. Most ultra high net worth individuals are served by at least three banks. For now, EFG, still the newcomer, might get 10% to 15% of their business and other bigger banks up to 30% each. One way the bank might grow is by getting more from existing clients.

There was a time, not so long ago, when EFG was a mere curiosity. Villalon recalls: “We would arrange banking conferences where Cuoni and Howell would present and people would come up afterwards and say: ‘Wow, can we buy them?’” Now, EFG might be asking that question. It is much more than an odd little independent shop.

Accelerated organic growth

But the acquisition strategy remains crucial. The bank has quite a war chest – not just the IPO proceeds but also proceeds from earlier subordinated debt and preference capital issues. For now, those proceeds will be deployed in low-yielding, low-risk investments until being put to work. The longer that investment process takes, the poorer the short-term returns. “We need to invest over the next 18 to 36 months,” says Rudy van den Steen, chief financial officer, “but investors expect the bulk of this to be done by the end of 2007.”

The bank’s style has been to make numerous small acquisitions. It announced a couple in November – Bank von Ernst (Liechtenstein), with SFr1.6 billion AUM, was acquired from Coutts; the UK’s Chiltern Wealth Management, with SFr600 million, was acquired in the UK. Villalon, rather cheekily, describes these kinds of small purchases of key people as accelerated organic growth.

It’s a sure bet that EFG is taking calls every day from investment bankers with big deals to pitch. The temptation will arise to do a much larger transaction. But will the right opportunity present itself?