It was widely known that a significant barrier was in place at 9.1500, as Lehman advised its clients the day before. “There is a big barrier at 9.15 EUR/SEK that still is defended. Once broken we could head lower quickly and aim for 9.1180,” the bank wrote. The events that took place as the barrier was defended and possibly breached have resulted in some serious accusations flying around, which may apparently result in litigation.
According to well-placed sources, the option position was initiated by Drawbridge, part of the US-listed Fortress Investments Group. At the time of the trade, it is believed that Drawbridge’s prime broker was Dresdner Kleinwort, although at the time of expiry, it had switched to Deutsche. As is often the case with such options, a battle royal ensued between several market big hitters who were trying to trigger the barrier event and those who were defending it. According to one source, this is only a game for big boys. Apparently, Goldman Sachs was the main barrier defender, although two other banks are also known to have been bidding 9.1515 ahead of the 9.1500 trigger level. There were several sellers, with Dresdner said to have been the most prominent.
Talk is that Goldman bought so many euros that all of its credit lines got filled and even though it was still bidding above 9.1500, the market went 9.1495 offered on Reuters just before the option’s expiry. Ostensibly, that would seem to have been enough to have triggered the barrier event, which highlights the risk of leaving the order to defend it with only one bank, especially an investment bank with relatively poor bilateral credit.
However, as mentioned above, two other banks were also on the bid and one of them has told the Weekly FiX it never stopped paying 9.1515. “There was a big binary at 9.1500. A German bank had interest to trigger it, as did a big US one. The German tried to trigger 9.1500 just before the expiry time. 9.1495 was given but…………I was bidding 9.1515 and a Danish (bank) was bidding too. We were not given when 9.1495 was seen,” says a trader at one of the bidding banks, highlighting how odd for the market to be offered below the bid.” The trader concerned works at an extremely large commercial bank; he says that from the trades he booked, it is unlikely that his credit was exhausted.
“There was a real mess in the market and I think that the trigger was not filled as logical,” he adds. This is also apparently the view of Drawbridge. As is always the case in these situations, all the participants concerned have declined so far to comment, reinforcing the FX market’s code of omerta when things go wrong.
The event raises many issues, and several of them are extremely serious. If credit lines were cancelled purely to get a low print on Reuters, as some people are insinuating – it has happened before – the culprits will most certainly face disciplinary sanctions. And while I have repeatedly said credit is not an issue in FX, I may have to eat humble pie on this one, which will please those advocating the use of a central clearer. Among the questions I asked Goldman were if it was true its lines got filled and what impact that had on its prime broker business. Presumably if they were filled, Goldman’s PB clients would have seen a reduction in their potential counterparties. Goldman declined to comment.
Savvy hedge fund managers will be aware that credit is potentially an issue and will no doubt have taken steps to overcome it. “You have to have two prime brokers,” one hedge fund manager told the weeklyFiX as a result of this story. “And you’re a complete fool if both of those are investment banks,” he added. The saga also raises the issue of what actually constitutes a barrier event and who decides if it has occurred. There’s bound to be more to follow on this one.