BIS report: Who says today’s markets are volatile?

The BIS report’s timing is nice, coming just after the volatility seen in August, much of which has stemmed from the unwinding of carry trades. My attention was drawn to one comment made by Patrick Bartle, global head of foreign exchange trading at ABN Amro in an article that appeared on Dow Jones Newswires.

“I have been in the market close to 20 years, and I have seen this kind of thing maybe five times,” he responded to questions about the market’s choppiness.

Do what? I immediately thought, sending out an e-mail to my muckers. “There’s a strange quote from ABN Amro’s Patrick Bartle in the Dow Jones story below. Did Patrick really say that? If so, where did he work 20-years ago, Thomas Cook?” I asked.

“I think I must be losing it. For some reason, I seem to remember that the market moved more in the afternoon, especially after a ‘lunch’ of bangers & mash washed down with some pink poo and especially after a Pimms Royale (aka rocket fuel) frenzy, than it does most months now.

“I can only conclude the following possibilities, because I remember a couple of ERM devaluations, big interventions and the odd accord since 1987.

•    I was rubbish

•    I worked for rubbish institutions

•    My brokers were rubbish

•    My memory is shot.”

I got many responses telling me my conclusions were wrong. And as the chart below of the monthly range of cable over the past 20-years shows, the market unquestionably used to move a lot more than it does now. 

fix-graphic1.gif

Still, the rules of this column are clear: I always give people the right to respond. So I got in touch with Patrick and he had the grace to accept my Mickey taking in good humour; he also clarified the remarks, which even in the article look slightly out of context.

“The reference was to the rapid/dramatic change of liquidity conditions over a very short period of time, the extreme spikes in short dated vol as well as the skews in risk reversals and other anomalies in the markets such as the basis between base rates, t-bills, money markets and LIBOR,” he says.

“I agree that there was a great deal of daily volatility 10 to 20-years ago focused on around the events mentioned, which created perhaps bigger moves in the underlying. But the volumes and liquidity in the markets then were no where near where they are today,” he adds. “The point that I was making was that the change in the overall liquidity in the market during this brief period of time was dramatic as were the impacts on spreads and vol,” he concludes.

And he’s right of course. The other thing is that liquidity itself may be harder to access, despite the surge in volumes. In the old days, it was easy to call up multiple banks direct and get spot prices in large amounts; banks can’t do that now. Also, the market was far less transparent, so prices could be shaded. A few of my contacts did express the view that things used to be better; however, I’m sure that overall they probably weren’t.