For some time now, I have questioned the rationale for the existence of the multibank platforms, arguing that the level of service provided by the banks’ proprietary systems make them superfluous to requirements. Many of the buy-side participants I have spoken to over the years simply hate paying commissions – they would seemingly, or so I thought, rather ‘deal for free’ with one of their banks directly.
“Have you seen the latest Greenwich Associates report?” my multibank chum asked. “Don’t be daft,” I replied. “I write for Euromoney.”
“Well, there’s a very interesting slide you might want to take a look at,” he responded. “It basically suggests that the argument you have been puttingforward for the past couple of years is wrong,” he gently goaded.
And, it would seem he is correct and that I now have a little bit of egg on my mooey, as we say in London when we get things wrong. Greenwich’s Foreign Exchange Services – E-Commerce Report 2008 found that 74% of the buy side used multibank or third-party systems in 2007 compared with 73% in 2006, while the percentage using single-bank platforms declined to 47% from 55%. Greenwich also found that the percentage using both fell from 28% to 20%.
Even though the sample size was bigger in 2007, the suggestion is that there has been an absolute drop in the number of users of single-bank platforms. I would like to know why. A possible reason is that the buy side is increasingly looking for consistency of pricing and services and there were clearly times in 2007 – which have continued through into 2008 – when some single-bank platforms made swift changes to what they were providing, such as widening spreads and halting streaming prices. It might be that because of the competitiveness of a multibank platform, such service disruption was less frequent. I have yet to be totally convinced, and would love to hear any views readers have.