Goldman, Lehman and the chase for retail flow

Without giving too much away, I can say that this year’s Euromoney FX Poll is...

Without giving too much away, I can say that this year’s Euromoney FX Poll is the biggest ever in terms of the numbers of voters and the volumes reported. What was even more noticeable this year is just how big the so-called retail sector has become. The banks have long realized this and a few have tried to work out ways they can benefit. The retail aggregators now also recognize the value of their business, which is a dramatic change from a few years back when they had to go begging for liquidity.

Players in the retail sector have become an extremely reliable source of information, especially about the banks’ technology and the quality of their pricing. Consistent feedback says that, not surprisingly, the banks have at times widened their spreads over the past nine months or so. Frequently, they claim, this is because of credit issues, which is patently nonsense. At one time, a systematic widening of spreads would have caused consternation among the retail aggregators but the competition for their flow means it is not such an issue, as they invariably soon come in again. Most buy-side particpants require consistency but for those that operate in the market on a 24-hour basis it is absolutely paramount.

The retail aggregators will have welcomed the emergence of two ‘new’ liquidity providers over the past year, which has helped ensure that competition for their flow remains high. The first is Lehman Brothers, which is streaming extremely tight prices, at least in European hours, on a consistent basis. The second is Goldman Sachs, which rolled out a new API earlier this year and has has also poached a number of e-commerce staff from Barclays; it is now aggressively touting for business and its euro-dollar spread is said to be as tight as a duck’s backside at 50 fathoms.

I’ve long wondered whether it was more profitable for a bank to do a thousand trades in $1 million than a single trade in a yard and I suspect the answer is that it is – provided its electronic offering is robust enough. The FX arms race is clearly not over and for those that get it right the reward is increased flow and potential profitability. It will be interesting to see next year the impact that Goldman’s and Lehman’s push will have on their 2009 rankings.