Settlement: Settle down

Given the size of the daily flow in the FX market, it is no wonder that settlement remains a thorny issue.

Several of the market big cheeses who are quoted in this week’s Q&A session mention it specifically, which is timely given that the Bank for International Settlements has just released the findings of its Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems (CPSS). In it, the central bankers highlight what they say is the need for further action to reduce settlement risk (see https://www.bis.org/publ/cpss83.htm). The detailed report describes how more than 100 active banks and other institutions market manage their settlement risks and it contains recommendations for individual institutions, industry groups and central banks to reduce and control remaining exposures that may still present systemic risk.

“The financial services industry has made significant progress in dealing with foreign exchange settlement risk. However, more can and should be done to tackle remaining exposures and to guard against the risk of reversing the progress that has already been achieved,” says Timothy Geithner, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and CPSS chairman.

He adds: “Recent market conditions emphasise how important it is that the settlement infrastructure supporting financial markets is robust and reliable, so that markets have the confidence to function normally even in adverse circumstances.”

The survey reports that significant progress has been made, specifically with the success of CLS, which now process 55% of daily volume. “This is an important accomplishment, but more needs to be done,” says Geithner. Of the trades that are settled outside CLS, 45% use traditional mechanisms.

CLS says it welcomes the renewed focus on settlement risk reduction and that it supports the CPSS’ proposed recommendations. “Since the launch of the CLS initiative in 1997 and its subsequent go-live in September 2002, CLS Bank has been actively engaged with its members and with central banks in the aim of eliminating settlement risk. CLS Bank is pleased to be recognised as the dominant settlement method by the CPSS and for its contribution to the FX market. Prior to CLS Bank, the landscape was very different with 85% of settlement obligations settled by traditional correspondent banking and subject to settlement risk, compared to 32% in 2007,” says Rob Close, chief executive of CLS.

According to an old mucker, who knows far more about what goes on post-trade than I will ever do, while the central bankers’ wishes are admirable, there is a chance that they are inadvertently introducing significant operational risk. “So what’s new? The central bankers were saying exactly the same thing back in 1991 when BIS had just endorsed bilateral netting by novation and multilateral netting. Volumes are significantly higher than they were then and the advent of e-trading has put unprecedented pressure on payment systems. The difference is in the nature of perceived settlement risk. Originally the focus was on Herstatt, credit and systemic risk. CLS obviates the first and electronic platforms/prime brokerage largely obviate the second. But while today there is possibly more risk that a bank may fail than in the previous 20 years, there is a bigger operational risk through dependency on technology and systems, including CLS’ infrastructure. The issue is exacerbated surely since CLS settles gross, because that’s the only way its cost model works. So the irony is that while putting more through CLS reduces temporal/systemic settlement risk, it increases operational/infrastructural risk,” she says.