Platform propaganda

Someone is putting about the suggestion that a new market paradigm has emerged.

According to the whisperer, the main loser is Icap’s EBS spot platform. This surprises me, but if it was true it shows just how quickly the FX market is evolving. It only seems like yesterday that I argued that EBS, which at the time was still predominantly owned by its user banks, had the potential to be the de facto FX market.

However, while EBS remains the biggest single pool of spot liquidity, things have clearly changed substantially since it was set up to prevent Reuters from achieving hegemony in FX. Where it once had an effective monopoly on the bulk of trade in currency pairs such as USD/JPY and EUR/USD, it has been facing competition from other platforms as well as – more significantly – from its former owners, the banks.

There is no doubt that EBS did lose market share before it was sold off to Icap, primarily because it was slow to react to change while it was run as mutual. Similar events took place on various exchanges, which had to demutualize too to survive.

Icap insists that EBS is not losing market share; a claim that will be verified either after the next set of central bank data on market turnover is published or after the next BIS triennial survey comes out and we can see how the others are performing. Not all of them have published the most transparent sets of figures.  

EBS’ apparent decline in volume has to be put into context. According to Barclays, the amount of liquidity available on platforms, including EBS, is now around 30% of what it was in January 2008. So it is not surprising that EBS’ volumes may have also dropped off. In January 2008, its average daily turnover was $238 billion. In May, this had declined to $134 billion. In other words, it is only doing now 56% of the volume it was doing 18 months ago. Yet this appears to be a stronger performance than many of its competitors.

I have often wondered why many end-users traded on anything other than their own bank’s platforms. Of course, convincing arguments can be made about how the ability to price-make can save the implicit cost of trading, and many on the buy side do not want to restrict their choice of counterparty.

Yet it is clear that many banks have become expert at internalising their order flow. Several are achieving rates higher than 75%, and this has a knock on effect on all the external multibank portals for two main reasons. The banks are transacting less externally and the success of their platforms mean that they are no longer reliant on EBS or Reuters or anyone else to make a market because they can price off their own inventory. And it means that they have the ability to quote rates that are tighter and in bigger amounts than those found on non-bank platforms.

For the moment at least though, the banks still need external outlets for the flow they can’t internalise. There have long been suggestions of linking the banks’ liquidity pools but nothing has ever materialised; so it is too early to report the demise of the external venues.

For the moment, Reuters and EBS remain the two major venues at the market’s hub, with CME pushing them hard. All three have competitors that sometimes seem to operate with a different set of flexible rules, which certainly can attract flow. However, although liquidity is by definition fluid, it is also very sticky. The likelihood is that EBS will remain the market’s predominant platform.