Dogged by controversy ever since Rusal announced its intention to list on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange, its IPO on January 27 floundered after launch. Its shares plunged more than 10% after the first day of trading as investors gave a thumbs down to the Russian aluminium producer.
This was an IPO that was a disaster in the making. Two previous attempts to list were abandoned. The latest attempt was originally slated to launch before Christmas after Rusal signed off on a restructuring of its $14.9 billion of debt at the end of November. But the date was pushed back because Rusal had failed to fulfil several exchange conditions, including its profit requirement. The transaction was approved only after some hastily arranged compromises.
One of the issues that the HKSE was fretting about was a $4.5 billion loan from VEB, the Russian state bank, which is due in October. To appease the listing committee’s concerns Sberbank agreed to take on the loan and extend its maturity until 2013.
The IPO was then allowed to go through only if retail investors were shut out, as the company was deemed too risky. That move backfired: the shares, which were valued at a 15% premium to China’s Chalco and a 50% premium to the US’s Alcoa, tumbled within minutes of trading. Without the presence of key anchor investors, such as VEB, which have agreed to six-month lock-ins, the performance might have been even worse.
The deal’s poor performance is a big blow to the HKSE’s ambitions to diversify its issuer base away from mainland China. Despite putting Rusal through the wringer – the prospectus weighs 2.5kg and is 1,141 pages long – the manner in which it bent over backwards to accommodate the IPO sits uneasily.
The lead managers, BNP Paribas and Credit Suisse, found themselves trying to get off the ground a deal that investors were not especially keen on, but needing to get the funding to secure the position of a company of which both banks are creditors.
Both have bagged their fees, and one competitor said he was impressed that they had managed to get the deal away. But the aftermarket performance suggests they were not able to secure a realistic price from a client in need.
As for Rusal, even allowing for tough market conditions the deal shows that it still has a long way to go to convince investors that it is on top of its huge debt burden. Admittedly the company had little choice but to sell shares. It needs to raise money to pay down that debt – $5 billion of which has to be repaid by 2013, with the rest on a pay-as-you-can basis. But its troubles continue to mount.
In the run-up to the IPO the government of Guinea demanded $860 million of the proceeds for what it says it is owed in damages by Rusal. The company says it has disclosed all relevant details regarding Guinea.
In addition, Oleg Deripaska, the oligarch who controls Rusal, faces the prospect of a court hearing in London following claims made by Michael Cherney, a former business associate, that Deripaska reneged on a previous agreement between the two. Cherney alleges that in 2001 Deripaska agreed to hold assets on trust for him, including a 20% stake in Rusal, and is now seeking the proceeds. Deripaska denies entering into such an agreement. The claim is valued at $4 billion.
There’s a chance that Rusal’s shares will bounce back and that they will recover to the issue price. Even so, it is hardly the best company to showcase Russia’s return to the international equity markets.