STP runs into the Red Queen effect

When markets were at dizzy heights and volumes were burgeoning the rapid implementation of straight-through processing looked to be a necessity. Now, though, developers and potential customers are taking a more sober view, not least because some markets don’t yet seem ready for T+1 settlement.

       

Not so long ago, straight-through processing (STP) was a hot topic in the financial services industry. The Global Straight-Through Processing Association (GSTPA), an industry-wide coalition of custodians, broker-dealers and investment managers, had succeeded in putting STP at the top of the agenda as the financial world moved into the 21st century. The pressure to move to a T+1 settlement cycle in the US securities markets, coupled with the explosion in trading volumes, forced the industry to look seriously at straight-through processing as a key element in coping with the workload.

With the election of Axion4gstp by the GSTPA and the establishment of Omgeo – a joint venture between the Depository Trust&Clearing Corporation (DTCC) and Thomson Financial ESG – to develop the global STP solution for worldwide markets including equities, fixed income, foreign exchange and future options markets, it seemed that it was all systems go for the move to fully automated trading and settlement.

The need for STP was clear and the will seemed to be there as well. But, a matter of months later, STP is no longer such a priority. Although Axion4 and Omgeo have continued to develop their protocols, achieving some notable successes, the pressure seems to have lessened, not least because of the economic slowdown and a consequent slackening in trading activity. There is now less conviction that STP will really bring the benefits that it is purported to confer on the industry. Consensus on the urgency of introducing STP is difficult to come by. Like the Red Queen encountered by Alice in Through the Looking-glass, the industry seems to be finding that it has to run hard just to keep in the same place.

Stanley Young, a partner at consultancy Accenture, agrees that there is an element of this in the latest developments, but reckons that it is difficult to get the pace of change right: “The industry has to move forward at a rate that all find acceptable. Too fast and you might disrupt the market. Too slow and companies could fall behind competitors.”

Concerns have also been raised about the solution providers themselves. Will the two proposed applications be interoperable and, if so, what is the potential for other organizations to enter the same market space, thus further confusing the issue? Some market participants, most notably in Europe, have still to be convinced that STP is the right way forward. Marco Strimer, global head of customer services and sales at SIS SegaInterSettle, the national central securities depository of the Swiss financial markets says: “It could be that a central counterparty for Europe might make the urgent need for STP redundant.”

According to Kevin Milne, executive managing director at Omgeo, the financial world varies greatly in its preparedness for straight-through processing. Milne cites same-day affirmation (SDA) rates in trading as an effective measure of how much STP is going on in various markets. As SDA can only be performed electronically, measuring its performance accurately reflects market efficiency. Such rates are radically different across the world. Times to trade affirmation for cross-border trade average around two hours in Japan, six hours in Australia and 10 to 15 hours in Hong Kong. As Milne says: “These data show that T+1 cannot be consistently achieved by all brokers, especially when you take into account the fact that T+1 doesn’t affect just US players, but anyone worldwide who trades in US securities.”

Milne points to Hong Kong where affirmation times are long thanks to the very nature of the business. With, traditionally, a high level of cross-border trades taking place in the market and the awkwardness of quick settlement across time zones, straight-through processing has been much more difficult to achieve. The move to an integrated global STP solution would dramatically improve this situation. Contrast this with a market that has had a tradition of much more straightforward trading and more efficient markets and the difference in SDA rates is marked. Getting the global market to a point where all but a few trades are affirmed within an hour or two is clearly going to be a long haul.

While Omgeo and Axion4gstp continue to develop their trade management and matching systems, the necessary investment from users also has to be made. Upgrading legacy systems to cope with the new requirements is not only time-consuming but could also be an expensive process for fund managers, broker-dealers and custodians. Bigger players, particularly the custodian banks that will perhaps benefit most from the efficiency gains that STP will bring, generally have the will and the resources to make the change. The costs are hard to quantify and for those yet to be convinced of the advantages, the investment is much more of a problem.

This is holding up implementation of STP across a range of markets and organizations. Strimer at SIS SegaInterSettle feels that the timetable for implementation is being pushed back. Strimer says that the industry is now looking at “a lead time of at least a couple of years. The Transaction Flow Manager that Axion4 is developing will help but what is most urgently required is investment by the users, which now means the investors as well.”

Three motivating factors

But will that investment be made? With fundamental change in any business, three motivating factors can usually be identified; fear, greed and regulation. All of these factors are playing a part in the move to STP and should encourage the market participants to find the necessary resources. While the US has seen regulation as a major driver, with T+1 becoming a statutory requirement, other markets are split between the fear and greed aspects. Many are greedy for the gains, in terms of lower operating costs and the value-added opportunities STP offers. Although the gains are difficult to quantify, Young estimates that a reduction in operating costs of 20% to 30% could be made through STP efficiencies. There are others whose primary fear is the possibility of losing out to competitors if they fail to adopt STP in time. “Some of these broker-dealers are running scared,” says one interested party. “They can see themselves being left behind if they don’t take the necessary steps to keep up. They may not want to spend the cash but they are going to have to.”

       
Charles Giessen

Milne believes that both fear and greed are of equal importance in the Asian markets, and that this will result in the Asian industry reaching the optimum STP point ahead of its counterparts in Europe and the US. “Europe doesn’t really share these drivers,” he states, though what is really motivating European organizations is not clear. But the need for STP is still apparent. At Brown Brothers Harriman, which offers foreign-exchange trading to custodian banks and some of Europe’s leading financial organizations, Henry Wilkes, senior vice-president and European head of sales and marketing, believes STP is still very much in everyone’s mind: “STP is definitely a big issue for our clients. The benefits in terms of greater efficiency and lower costs are obvious.”

Accenture’s Young is not convinced that Europe has a burning desire for STP. He points out the regulatory requirement for a move to T+1 in the US as something Europe has never had. “The US industry really wants to do this and there is no doubt that it will,” he explains. The European picture is complicated by the fragmentation of the market along national lines. Imposing a T+1 settlement cycle on such a disparate market is not a viable option, though the European Securities Forum is exploring the possibility.

Young’s main concern, though, surrounds the relationship between the industry’s two STP providers. Though the two have recently moved closer together, with both running SWIFT’s ISO 15022 data standard and XML messaging protocol, Young feels that this will not guarantee interoperability. The crux of the problem comes when a trade involves both systems, perhaps with a fund manager running Omgeo and a broker-dealer running Axion4. “When this happens,” asks Young, “whose engine is used to make the match? In short, who receives the payment?” He argues that this dilemma has been seen before, and it is not easily solved.

Milne at Omgeo has an answer: revenues would be split in such cases, with the investment manager’s provider managing the transaction flow, as determined in an agreement with the Securities Industry Association.

With organizations in competition with each other, where is the incentive to cooperate? It is up to the market to force the two to work together to solve this problem by insisting on full interoperability. Charles Giessen, CEO at Omiris Networks, an application service provider in the order management business, believes that the fund managers are beginning to press for this. “They want STP as soon as possible, so the pressure is there for the two to talk to each other,” he says.

So far, a resolution seems a long way off. Add to this the potential for further vendors to challenge the two existing providers and the problem could even be exacerbated. Young points to the concentrators, those who will provide access to the two trade management systems for users, as a likely source of competition. What is to stop a concentrator, or a consortium of them, deciding they are not content with acting as a glorified router for Omgeo or Axion4 and trying to take a bigger slice of the pie by developing their own trade-flow management systems? Although Young believes that ultimately the market can only support two providers at most, the process of achieving this could be difficult.

The problem is, to Young’s mind, one that is very much of the GSTPA’s own making. By not selecting the DTCC as a developer of the single industry solution that is the GSTPA’s stated aim, the GSTPA pushed the DTCC to seek another partner in Thomson Financial ESG. “In doing this,” he claims, “the GSTPA has contributed to the establishment of an organization which is both more powerful and more sustainable than Axion4.” Certainly, the two founders of the Omgeo platform score heavily over Axion4 in terms of industry experience. Omgeo makes much of its parent companies’ 30 years’ combined presence in the financial markets.

A large proportion of the market is already connected in some way to Omgeo or its parent organizations. Omgeo is able to offer existing clients the opportunity to upgrade their systems to incorporate the Central Trade Manager with much less aggravation and cost than changing to Axion4 would entail; this is a distinct competitive advantage. “In all this, the industry [through GSTPA] started out with the best intentions,” continues Young. Alienating the Omgeo founders has not helped their cause. “Now the GSTPA has gone too far down this route to turn back.” It is to be hoped that the market’s calls for true connectivity between Omgeo and Axion4 will persuade them to resolve this issue.

Value-added attractions

Omgeo’s position on value-added services is also important, not only from the point of view of the company’s competitiveness, but also as another incentive for users to move to STP. Transaction management alone is insufficient to convince users that STP is a must have. The true value comes from the offshoots of this process, such as making the auditing and reporting processes far easier. The more the providers can offer in terms of performance measurement, information provision and analysis, the more attractive the upgrade in systems will appear.

But who really benefits from STP? Some argue that the custodian banks and broker-dealers have most to gain from increased efficiency and shorter settlement cycles, but Giessen argues that fund managers are now waking up to the possibilities STP offers them. “I believe that the investment managers are now even more ambitious than the banks and brokers. They want the move to STP,” he says. Giessen feels that managers are looking forward to a much more compressed settlement time scale. “They will want T+0 settlement as soon as it is viable,” he argues. “For brokers and custodians, STP is about increasing efficiency internally. The fund managers are looking at external efficiency gains. They want good performance from the brokers and custodians and they want to minimize their exposure to risk.”

But Giessen is not sure that the buy side is prepared to pay: “There is little willingness to spend the money on these systems at the moment. Everyone is under enormous commercial pressure. It’s therefore tough to make long-term strategic decisions of this importance.” The world economic climate is markedly different now to its buoyant condition in 1999 when STP was coming to prominence. The global slowdown makes planning with confidence tricky. “It’s difficult to build to what you think may happen,” says Giessen. “But we are at an inflection point in the business.” Decisions made now will determine who does well in future.

But such far-reaching and expensive decisions are not for the faint-hearted. As one fund manager puts it: “Nobody is prepared to stand up and say that their company simply has to spend money on this. We automated as much of our system as we could, as quickly as we could, but most of our competitors are scared to make the investment.” He points out that around 75% of managers are still using the fax machine for much of their business “This is scandalous,” he says.

A choice of pace

Fortunately for the users, the pace at which they move to STP systems is up to them. All those involved are keen to stress that this is a gradual process – there will be no big bang of technological change here.

Omgeo offers its clients the ability to move to central matching as and when they feel comfortable with the step-up, by sticking with existing systems where possible and trading up only when ready. Keeping the impact of the move as small as possible will, hopefully, encourage more companies to make the change. The process will take years, rather than months.

There are those, however, who feel that STP may not be the only way to reduce risk. At least, not in Europe. Marco Strimer, while an advocate of the STP model – “I believe we need STP now,” he says – wonders whether any future European central counterparty might not make STP redundant: “A central counterparty could take a lot of the risk out of the market. If contractual settlement is assured, you might ask why would we need T+1?” Strimer believes that, for now, the industry would be well advised to follow both strategies. In the end, the market will determine which model is followed.

As for SIS and Axion4, Strimer is in no doubt that they have the capability to provide whatever users desire. “If our clients were to say: ‘We want T+1 and STP tomorrow,’ then we would do it tomorrow. We have the technology.” He points out that SIS has already offered STP to the Swiss equities market, but users were not ready to take it on. Many felt unprepared to make the necessary changes to their internal systems.

But that breathing space will not be particularly long. At the moment, the industry is implementing just enough change in this area to tread water. Large-scale investment of time, human resources and capital will soon be needed if STP and T+1 settlement is to become a reality. As the Red Queen advised Alice: “Here, you see, it takes all the running you can do to keep in the same place. If you want to get somewhere else, you must run at least twice as fast as that!”