?Have your cake and eat it?
Clients may describe a chunk of capital as ?excess?, but you can always guarantee that an eagle eye will be kept on the bottom line. Unless we are formally instructed to manage assets relative to a pure equity benchmark, therefore, we would advise giving at least equal importance to absolute and relative return issues when agreeing the mandate.
Private investors have always wanted to ?have their cake and eat it?, and why shouldn?t they? It is a perfectly natural reaction to the unnerving opportunities for making or losing capital to equal degrees in the same investment assets, but at different points of the cycle. The challenge for managers is to develop an investment process and products, which come close to meeting our clients? utopian aspirations.
Dynamic asset allocation
At the top of the process, you need an asset allocation model, directed by a good lateral thinker, always one step ahead of the market. There is no doubt that allocating with conviction between cash, bonds, equities and alternative strategies can add significantly more value to a portfolio?s long-term performance and risk adjusted return profile than any other investment discipline ? stock-picking, for example. Find a good macro strategist with a sixth sense, backed by a disciplined investment process and you have won 90% of the battle.
During the years 1997 ? 2002 the equity allocation of the CAPS Pooled Pension Median Fund in the UK ranged between 77% and 82%*. In 3 consecutive years of bull markets, followed by 3 years of the worst equity markets in living memory, managers in this group barely shifted equity allocation around their neutral axis. Serious value could have been added.
Portfolio profile
How would our portfolio look and what type of product would we include? For this mandate, we recommend that the majority of the portfolio be invested in ?long only? assets, but retaining the ability to use alternative strategies on a focused basis at different points in the cycle.
Alternative strategies
Alternative strategies will include hedge funds, which for us will be ?best of breed?, long/short equity managers covering the world?s major investment regions ? a strategy which complements our own global equity process. A brief word of caution, however, is needed about the hedge fund universe. In order to achieve their aim of consistent returns in all market conditions, many hedge fund managers rely on short-term trading opportunities, new issues, or pricing imperfections in the market. As the hedge fund industry grows rapidly so too does the competition to take advantage of these opportunities and it is our view that managers will have to take on increasing levels of risk to achieve their performance objectives ? if we are right, investment processes could become less transparent once again, volatility of returns will increase and upsets will happen. Beware!
Structured products
We also bracket structured products into the alternative asset class and here there is a genuine opportunity for investors to have their cake and eat it. Again, beware the small print of these highly complex structures, because the headline promises can be misleading. However, structures do exist with 100% capital guarantees (always check the guarantor?s credit rating), an ongoing income stream, and potential exposure to all of the upside of the underlying investment or index. Where those features can be combined in one product, perhaps investors can get closer than ever before to fulfilling their investment dream.
Summary
Our portfolio for the $20m investor, prepared to take limited capital risk in return for growth potential over a 5 year cycle would have the following features:
? Active asset allocation between cash, bonds, equities and alternatives
? Neutral allocation: 5% cash, 30% fixed interest, 40% equities, 25% alternative strategies (long/short hedge funds and structured products)
? +/- 50% in each asset class
? Five year return objective: cash, plus RPI (or CPI), plus 3%
Jamie Black
Director
Sarasin Investment Management Limited
*Source: Russell/Mellon CAPS Pooled pension Median Fund Dec 02
Compliance Warnings: All opinions and estimates contained in this article constitute the Company?s judgement and view of the date of the article and are subject to change without notice. The information contained is published for the assistance of recipients, but is not to be relied upon as authoritative or taken in substitution for the exercise of judgement by the recipient. If you are a private investor, you should not act or rely on this article but should contact your professional advisor.