| Cash Management poll 2004 | |||||||||||
|
|||||||||||
Citigroup wins this year’s Euromoney international cash management poll with big-money votes – within the highest ever 1,154 respondents to this year’s poll, 60% of corporations with annual gross sales figures of more than $25 billion use the bank. And when it comes to the really big clients – those with more than $100 billion in annual sales – that jumps to 90% of respondents who use Citigroup. The only scoring boost in the poll bigger than the one Citigroup gets from those big clients is the one HSBC gets from its small ones. It is a leading ICM provider for an astonishing 61% of clients with sales figures of less than $1 billion. That number accounts for HSBC’s run to near the top of the poll this year. If HSBC manages to keep up its small-client dominance and grab just a few of the big accounts in 2005, next year’s poll might even see it overtake Citigroup to leave all the other banks behind.
Just as the battle is closely fought at the top of the global rankings, so it is in the regional standings. JPMorgan’s lead over Citigroup in North America might be more tenuous than the overall scores show. Although it ends up on top by 257 points, there is no single category of voters among which it coasts to an easy victory. Among voters with sales of less than $1 billion, JPMorgan is only ahead by 23 points in North America. Among voters bigger than $100 billion, it’s actually 100 points behind Citigroup.
In fact, the only group of voters for which JPMorgan wins decisively is the medium-large group with sales of between $10 billion and $25 billion, which give the bank a 185-point lead. Take out that group and its margin of victory in North America is just 77 points, barely 1% of the total North American vote.
Chasing the same clients
As if that shouldn’t make JPMorgan nervous enough, the poll results tell us that Citigroup already has a foot in the door with a large number of JPMorgan’s clients. Because our respondents nominate their first, second, and third place ICM providers, we can see how many people who nominated JPMorgan also nominated Citigroup. In the North American category, 41% of voters who use JPMorgan also bank with Citigroup.
That means that to take market share from JPMorgan, Citigroup might not even have to find new accounts – it just needs to strengthen its relationship with existing clients. Considering that 77% of those shared clients say that centralizing their treasury environment is a high or very high priority, each of the leading banks in north America will have to fight to make sure it is not the one that gets pushed out.
ABN Amro has beaten Citigroup for the top spot in western Europe for the second year in a row. It’s especially strong among medium-size accounts – 70% of its western European score comes from firms with annual gross sales of between $1 billion and $25 billion.
Among those medium-size western European accounts, however, ABN Amro is rated dead last for customer satisfaction. Only 20% of the ratings from these clients give its services above-average marks (leader ING Group manages to score 61%). So why does ABN Amro do so well in the region if its clients are not that enthusiastic about its services?
For one thing, these clients don’t seem too interested in shopping around for other providers. Only 11% of them re-evaluate their ICM relationships every year by issuing an RFP; 37% let four years or more go by without doing so. For another, ABN Amro’s ratings are much higher with particular groups of accounts – especially those that are right in the middle of the size scale, with gross sales of between $5 billion and $10 billion.
ABN Amro seems to have two keys to European success: work hard to satisfy certain types of clients and do enough to maintain long-term relationships with other clients that are are willing to stick it out with it despite unimpressive service.