When Ireland decided to guarantee the liabilities of a banking system twice the size of the country’s GDP, it didn’t take long for banks in neighbouring countries to complain about unfair state aid at the first sign of corporate deposits flowing west. European banks were already nervous about being put at a disadvantage by any US government guarantees for bad assets of big banks operating in the US and had begun lobbying hard for a similar European bail-out plan. Amid reports of disagreements among European finance ministries over this, it is easy to imagine a clash between European institutions and national interests exacerbating the uncertainties assailing European banks.
But at the moment of peril for particularly vulnerable banks, a sense of common purpose emerged. And this is a good thing.
Perhaps the most remarkable and encouraging aspect of the wave of bail-outs and nationalizations required to prop up the European banking sector at the end of September was the speed with which separate national governments coordinated efforts to prevent failure of large European-scale institutions with operations of systemic significance in several countries.
The salvation of Fortis, in particular, is a huge positive for the European banking market. It was a complicated rescue because Fortis is a complicated institution with a holding company in Belgium, banking subsidiaries in several countries, and insurance and asset management subsidiaries.
Over the summer, confidence had periodically wavered in the group’s efforts to raise the capital required to consolidate the Dutch banking assets of ABN Amro acquired in the disastrously timed consortium acquisition.
Suddenly, over September 25 and 26, this erupted into a frenzy of rumours of impending insolvency and bank runs – fomented, the bank’s management believes, by malicious speculators – and three Benelux governments stepped in. Over the weekend, they agreed to invest €11.2 billion of equity in the group. A few days later, the Dutch government nationalized the remainder of Fortis under its jurisdiction.
The group’s third CEO of the summer, Filip Dierckx, announced a strategic U-turn in the decision not to proceed with the consolidation of the ABN Amro banking business. This will be sold instead. This is widely believed to have been a stipulation of the Dutch government.
The group’s remaining public shareholders may ponder the implications for future earnings and stability at their leisure. Depositors and creditors can be thankful that the three governments stepped in so quickly. And this was not simply a case of national governments reasserting their budgetary and decision-making sovereignty and casting European institutions aside. Jean-Claude Trichet, president of the European Central Bank, played a prominent role in coordinating the rescue talks over the weekend.
It wasn’t the only deal. Just two days later, public authorities in Belgium and France, together with existing shareholders, subscribed to an equity capital increase of €6 billion for Dexia. In addition, the Luxembourg government stumped up €376 million for convertible bonds of Dexia Banque Internationale à Luxembourg.
European citizens and taxpayers – outside the UK, which has gone through a debt and housing boom of its own similar to that in the US – might well be dumbfounded at how their banks have been brought to the brink by the credit and funding crisis sparked in the US sub-prime mortgage market. Recriminations and disagreements aplenty on how to respond no doubt lie ahead. But they should be relieved that national and European institutions have stepped in quickly and decisively when disaster threatened.