European high-yield: Set to stay?

The European high-yield market may finally have come of age.

There have been many false dawns for the European high-yield bond market. This could be the year when it finally shows its true potential. After lying dormant for almost two years, the market has seen a flurry of activity, with a record €17.3 billion of issuance in 2009 to date. Almost half of that has occurred in the past two months. There are several factors at play here.

The mass of liquidity that central banks and governments have pumped into the financial system has helped underpin a rally in credit spreads that has seen European high-yield reap eye-watering returns in excess of 50%. That has had the knock-on effect of spurring a search for yield by investors as record low interest rates and a positive yield curve push investors further out along the curve and further down the ratings ladder. Of the 34 public deals this year, more than half have been upsized as a result of pent-up demand.

Historically, European leveraged finance, of which high-yield bonds were a small subset, has been predominantly a loan-driven market. Pre-crisis, that was dominated by the leveraged loan market that fuelled the LBO boom, and where much of the supply was soaked up by collateralized loan investor vehicles. That market has remained virtually shut this year as leveraged buyouts have been reduced to a trickle and the voracious appetite of CLO investors has been curtailed. As credit spreads widened in 2008, many funds were forced to unwind their so-called market-value structures and retrench from the market, while funding costs on total-return swaps, a key source of funding and leverage for such investors, have soared.

According to Barclays, 55% of issuance this year has been used to refinance loans, whereas only 12% has been used to refinance maturing bonds. A clear trend is developing here, but is it sustainable?

That will depend on whether CLO investors make a comeback, for without them there is limited capacity for banks to continue to lend, as higher regulatory capital charges being phased in over the coming years curb their enthusiasm for risky lending. The evidence that banks are pulling back from the market doesn’t bode well.

In the first nine months of this year €11.7 billion of so-called pro-rata loans, which are typically funded by banks, have been issued, compared with €36 billion for the same period in 2006. Fitch has estimated that about 20% of the 62 European CLO managers might disappear in the next couple of years.

The pipeline for more high-yield bond deals in early 2010 looks promising, though, provided the credit markets remain stable, and interest rates low, while anecdotally at least, many money market funds receive inflows marked for non-investment-grade. But this is still the straight path that leads to a wall of refinancing that kicks in in 2011 and 2012. That will be the true test of whether the European high-yield bond market has really come of age.