Relationship banking in a cynical world

This economic downturn is long past the point where banks might normally have started waxing lyrical about their commitment to relationship banking. Anticipating the end of past down cycles and sensing good opportunities ahead to lend, banks would already have tried to appeal to new customers by promising to stick with them through bad times such as those recently endured as well as the good.

Not this time, though. Relationship banking is not the favoured buzzword in any marketing campaigns. It is not the repeated trope of speeches and presentations from banks’ senior executives.

There are two possible explanations for this. One is that banks lack confidence in the economic recovery and don’t actually want to do any new business with new customers, being still preoccupied with the financial difficulties of their existing ones. The second is that the whole banking industry is now so utterly discredited that not even a moron in a hurry would be fooled by any of its guff about relationship banking.

Yet this is precisely the moment for banks and their customers to reconsider the benefits to both sides of establishing the economic basis for more stable and long-lasting partnerships than were in vogue in the years up to 2007.

At the start of January, in his first speech as chief executive of Bank of America, Brian Moynihan admitted the obvious: that the industry had over-lent, consumers and companies had over-borrowed, and we had all overleveraged. This had led to our recent economic crisis.

Too much bank credit was too freely available and transactional banking was the dominant pattern. Banks wanted to sell anything to their customers that would generate a profit for shareholders and a bonus. Many customers wanted to use cheap bank leverage to play much the same trick.

Right now, banks are being excoriated for failing to lend, for turning off the supply of credit, especially to small and medium-sized enterprises, or for offering it only on onerous terms. Banks deserve a lot of criticism.

Unfashionable though it might be, borrowers of all sizes might also want to think through their own share of responsibility for maintaining healthy relationship banking.

That has nothing to do with dinners, lunches or days at the tennis. Essentially it involves sharing out fees in a way that ensures that banks make an economic return on capital committed to lending to customers. This was very unfashionable in the years when CFOs and treasurers measured themselves by how many basis points they could shave off borrowing and transaction costs and gave little thought to how this might diminish banks’ willingness to maintain lines when the credit cycle turned.

Time Warner was one of the old-fashioned ones that tried to keep its share of the social contract with its banks. It had a big incentive in the years when the company was one of the largest users of bank credit, with $13 billion in undrawn revolvers and another $7 billion in bank lines. It was an early pioneer of multiple bookrunner roles for banks on its capital markets transactions as it sought to reward all of its core banks through the cycle. It also appointed multiple advisers on M&A deals.

Now, post the separation from AOL and with half that amount of dependence on revolving credits, Time Warner is still dealing with much the same group of relationship banks as it has for many years. Relationship banking might be unfashionable but it can benefit banks and customers if both sides choose to work at it.