The recent rally in real estate prices – particularly in the UK – has disguised the fact that these assets still present a big problem for many bank balance sheets. According to CBRE, UK commercial capital values jumped more than 10% in the final quarter of 2009, and in January JPMorgan had a capital growth estimate of 15% for the 12 months to June 2010 and a first-quarter estimate of 5% growth.
But because of the savage mark-to-market losses that many real estate portfolios have sustained, many banks have moved their real estate loans from the trading book to the banking book and have thus been unable to take advantage of the recent rally without tainting the tax treatment of the loans in the bank book. This has led to a bifurcated market, with the equity side (Reits in particular) seeming to actively manage assets more successfully through the rally while the bank side remaining sluggish to react.
This does little to assuage the fears of those mindful of the volume of outstanding real estate loans that need to be financed in Europe. Commercial real estate and SME loans are perhaps the most worrisome of all bank exposures – particularly because the fiscal protections that have so far buffered these portfolios from losses are now set to be withdrawn.
This will expose the true performance of many of these facilities, which in some cases could be pretty dire. Half of all European CMBS loans that have passed their maturity dates and are still outstanding are now in standstill or going through a workout process, with the other half having had their maturity dates extended. And recent research has shown the shocking statistic that one in five secondary shopping centres in the UK are now at risk of defaulting on their loans.
But if the regulators get their way banks could face a double whammy in the treatment of their troublesome portfolios. Not only will fiscal support now be gradually withdrawn but regulatory capital requirements are likely to rise – in some cases by a substantial amount.
Assets that have been held on the trading book could now be required to have regulatory capital held against them in the same manner as if they were held on the banking book.
So for those with troublesome real estate exposure there is a choice between the devil and the deep blue sea: move the assets to the banking book where you will be unable to take advantage of capital price rises to sell and reduce your exposure, or keep them on the trading book in order to be able to sell them if the opportunity arises – but now be required to hold regulatory capital against assets that you might have already written down severely.
It is not a choice that those with exposure to secondary assets in weak sectors such as retail are likely to relish in this market.