When I was growing up in a very small village in Berkshire County, Massachusetts, it was usually impossible to assemble more than two, three or four children to play baseball or football after school. Most of the kids were from farm families, where those older than five had chores that took up their time before and after school. Sometimes we had to play two-man baseball or football, or once in a while a game called cat’s cradle.
This involves two people wrapping string around their hands to make different shapes by alternately taking the string while still wrapped around the other’s hands without tangling it. The cat’s cradle record, according to the Guinness Book of World Records, is held by a couple in California who created more than 21,000 cat’s cradles over a 21-hour period in the 1970s. (As California’s bondholders know to their cost, this is a state in which “nothing exceeds like excess”, to quote Oscar Wilde.)
Cat’s Cradle is also the title of a novel by Kurt Vonnegut that I read shortly after it was published in 1963. Here, the cat’s cradle was something very complicated that suddenly and irreversibly ended.
The thing I have always remembered from the novel, which deals with the indifference of scientists to the effects of their discoveries, such as the atomic bomb, was that the protagonist created a crystal that would make water freeze at normal temperatures. This substance contaminates the ocean, ending all life on earth in a matter of minutes. The scientist said nonchalantly as he observed the ocean congealing: “I didn’t think it would happen this fast.” The wunderkinds who invented CDOs and their like on Wall Street and in the City of London will doubtless share this sentiment.
|
This game will end suddenly and unpleasantly. That is why the Greek problem is important to everyone |
This brings me to the Greek euro crisis, which I was lucky enough to predict at an investment conference on risk management in Hong Kong in February. There was general scepticism, and even some good-natured derision among the economists and risk managers present, which offended my vanity a little. A prophet is never loved. One of my points was that perceptions of reality can change with astonishing rapidity, as in Vonnegut’s novel. This is one reason for the simile with the cat’s cradle, both the game and the novel. The second is that investors are now realizing that Greece will not be able to repay its debt, and it does not matter what sort of financial support the IMF or the European Union provides it.
Greece will eventually default and this will trigger other sovereign defaults. The historical fact is that the normal behaviour of sovereign borrowers is to default when convenient and then to execute the lenders. The Fugger bank of Augsburg, then the largest in the world, collapsed in the late 1500s when Spain rather arbitrarily decided that it was not in its interest to repay its loans. Almost two centuries before, Philippe le Bel of France arrested, executed or expelled the Jews so he could renege on loans and steal their assets, following the example of Edward I of England.
Today, the debt maturities of sovereign borrowers are far too short and present substantial refinancing risk. The US government, for example, has an average debt maturity of about four years. The typical sovereign borrower has to refinance 30% of its debt each year, not accounting for new issues. According to the Financial Times, the UK is an outlier, with refinancings at about 15% over the next year.
In the good old pre-euro days, the Deutsche Bundesbank would not allow the German government to issue debt with maturities of less than 10 years, but that policy was abandoned to create a yield curve for the soon-to-be-launched euro. This interested me a lot at the time, as Germany was the only important country to manage its debt in a manner that took into account refinancing risk. Today, alas, Germany’s debt profile is no better than other countries’. The cost of sovereign refinancing will rise inexorably because the financial costs of so many social policies are unsustainable. When the refinancing cost becomes too great, sovereigns will stop paying.
We are in a complicated cat’s cradle of developed country debt. First, the parties involved must keep passing things off among themselves and everything fails if they do not. This game will end suddenly and unpleasantly. That is why the Greek problem is important to everyone. The investment implications of the cat’s cradle we are now in are that many sovereigns that borrow in foreign currencies will default. Those that borrow in their own currencies, such as the US and the UK, will devalue their debts through inflation.
The US has a long and ignoble tradition of devaluing debt through interest rate controls. The markets will realize this in the next few months and will become fearful, causing borrowing costs to rise everywhere. The only sensible conclusion is that risky assets will suffer very poor outcomes over the next year. Physical assets should be preferred over financial ones. The game of cat’s cradle is about to end. Untangle your string now.
Lincoln Rathnam, PhD, CFA, is an investment professional based in Singapore and Boston. In a career spanning almost 30 years he has managed equity, debt and venture capital portfolios and was a pioneer investor in emerging markets in the late 1980s