It is ironic that the latest regulatory consequence of the failure of the credit rating agencies to accurately assess the risk inherent in many structured finance products is that in future their opinions are to be treated as those of experts, whereas before they were not. This development is part of the final version of the Dodd-Frank legislation and goes to the root of the market’s misinterpretation – wilful or otherwise – of what ratings actually mean.
Under Rule 436(g) of The Securities Act (which Dodd-Frank will repeal) credit ratings are not considered part of a registration statement prepared or certified by an expert. This has been just fine with the rating agencies as it exempts them from expert liability if those ratings turn out to be wrong.
But all that will now change. Regulation AB has already stated that the inclusion of ratings in a prospectus is mandatory if the sale of securities is contingent on them achieving said rating. By treating credit ratings as expert opinions, Dodd-Frank will make sure that the rating agencies are potentially exposed to expert liability under section 11 of the Securities Act when those ratings are included.
In other words rating agencies can be sued if their opinions turn out to be wrong – something that is not fine with them at all. Indeed, all three agencies have already protested that they will prohibit the inclusion of ratings in prospectuses if this rule stands. While cynics might question whether or not this would necessarily be to the detriment of those prospectuses, the simple truth is that without those ratings the market cannot function.
Unsurprisingly, when the legislation was passed in July the US ABS market screeched to a halt (not that it was exactly thundering along at full pelt) and Ford Motor Credit was forced to postpone a $1.39 billion deal while it figured out what to do.
Structured finance ratings have been shown to be woefully inaccurate; but the nature of ratings has not changed – they were not verifiable facts before the financial crisis and they still aren’t now. Lazy investors who blindly rely on them still deserve to lose out.