This is particularly worrying, as in the minds of some investors it is linked with proposals over the past 12 months for new mining codes in Guinea, Democratic Republic of Congo and Zimbabwe, and new mining taxes in Côte d’Ivoire, Ghana and Zambia.
Magnus Ericsson at Raw Materials group, a consultancy, says places such as Finland, Canada and Australia have seen moves like this recently too. Governments might simply have taken until now to catch up with the commodities super-cycle, according to Ericsson.
“Resource nationalism is global, so won’t determine flows of capital on a regional level, only country by country,” he says. Indeed, some reckon (perhaps optimistically) that the increased perceived political risks in South Africa might make such countries as DRC look marginally more attractive.
In recent years, even the IMF has advised countries such as Ghana and Zambia to increase taxes on the mining sector, which it deemed too low. At an Indaba panel discussion, Sheila Khama, a mining expert at ACET, a multilateral-sponsored think-tank, says government equity participation in joint ventures can sometimes help states understand what drives investment.
![]() |
| Peter Sullivan, head of Africa at Citi’s public sector group |
“Minority state ownership in mines means governments are becoming more commercially savvy and seeking to get more value out of partnerships, including those with Chinese companies,” agrees Peter Sullivan, head of Africa at Citi’s public sector group. Sullivan cites new or revived state-owned holding companies or funds in Gabon (Société Equatoriale des Mines) and Zambia (ZCCM Investments, which is also publicly listed) as examples where this might ring true. From Guinea, to Gabon, to Mauritania, governments in Africa are increasingly willing to pay for advice from international investment banks on how best to bring value to their mineral treasures, according to another banker advising such governments on mining. Mining codes in some countries are revised out of necessity, he says, as the rules were previously so ill defined.
Undeniably, there have been improvements in Africa in investment frameworks around mining. Take Sierra Leone, synonymous with warlords and blood diamonds in the 1990s. The country is now host to an iron-ore project that propelled African Minerals to the highest market capitalization on AIM last year. That is partly thanks to a more respectable and investor-friendly government: the country’s president is a former insurance broker.
But another new mining code in DRC or elsewhere, probably resulting in new rises in minimum proportions of state ownership of mines, often termed free carry as there is no payment, will hardly be a comfort for investors, now struggling with the even greater problem of slowing demand in China.
