So much activity in financial markets is collateralized now that, for banks, the once obscure process of managing stores of security of varying quality – from cash to treasuries to corporate bonds and even equities – and posting it where it achieves the best value is becoming ever more important and ever more strained.
In its yearly margin survey, the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (Isda) found that amid the pandemic-related volatility in 2020, variation margin collected by the biggest so-called phase one firms for non-cleared derivatives increased by 29.8% to $1.2 trillion at year-end 2020, compared with $897.3 billion collected at year-end 2019.
Regulators want more derivatives trading to be cleared to take credit risk out of the system. That makes central clearing counterparties (CCPs) – each with their own rules on what is eligible for initial margin and at what haircuts – increasingly critical.
What is clear is that as volatility rises, not only does required margin climb but so too does the frequency of margin increases
Bimal Kadikar, Transcend
The value of initial margin required under global margin rules for the biggest dealers also increased last year by 22.8%.
“There’s a dance going on here, with derivatives dealers complaining that CCPs demand too much initial margin and the CCPs trying to please them but also manage the risk and meet the regulatory expectations,” says Bimal Kadikar, chief executive of Transcend, a fintech building technology for real-time, firm-wide management of inventory, funding and liquidity.
He tells Euromoney: “It is a complex ecosystem. But what is clear is that as volatility rises, not only does required margin climb but so too does the frequency of margin increases, including intra-day margin calls.
“Over the years, banks have built their own technology to keep up, but this space has always been underfunded and underserved. It never got the cutting-edge technology that the traders got.
“That was a big driver to found Transcend and change that, because stresses are now growing on fragile operating systems.”
Big impact
Kadikar started his career in repo at Salomon Brothers and eventually ran all FICC technology globally at Citi.
In grappling with the technology side of the bank’s liquidity challenges after the financial crisis, one area he took great interest in was management of collateral, margin and liquidity that he saw was split and handled separately across different businesses – repos, prime finance, agency lending, Treasury, over-the-counter derivates, cleared derivatives and operations.
Even modest investments to improve the bank’s systems had a big impact.
“This started to go up to the board. It had very high visibility,” Kadikar recalls.
He set up his own firm with a number of ex-Citi colleagues to provide banks with a holistic view across businesses of their whole collateral and margin requirements.
These processes still tend to be largely manual, with lots of checks and verification that eligible margin has been posted and acknowledged by counterparties.
They are also siloed. Individual businesses within banks may not realize that they have a surplus of cash or securities, perhaps sitting idle on account at one counterparty – a surplus that another business could take advantage of.
“We are throwing sunlight into this space,” says Kadikar.
Transcend has just launched CCP Central, the first platform to connect and automate margin and collateral management activities across a global network of CCPs.
It provides pre-built connections to CCPs, along with comprehensive analysis of a bank’s margin calls and balances, collateral schedules, positions and transactions, and required values to satisfy margin requirements.
Its algorithms then suggest the smartest collateral movements and automatically execute them within the bank’s systems.
“If firms have an excess of collateral with a counterparty, because they are not then required to do anything, they often just leave it,” says Kadikar, “even though they may have a deficit in another business.”
And, he observes, “because of operational challenges, many firms post cash as initial margin with CCPs.”
That is the highest-quality collateral.
“By saving better-quality collateral and maximizing haircut and funding value from specific securities, there are major liquidity benefits for banks,” Kadikar points out.
Operational efficiency
Intraday liquidity is becoming a focus for large banks and smaller broker-dealers alike who need to get a better handle on their positions and improve ability to forecast margin and funding needs.
Robinhood’s experience with GameStop may have been an outlier, but it was also a perfect example of the stresses that can suddenly hit intermediaries. The Archegos Capital Management scandal also showed the importance of establishing accurate valuations in fast-moving markets on the collateral that banks hold and lend against.
Operational efficiency links together with better risk management and improved financials. The analysis for a couple of banks just on their tri-party repo books shows this.
We are throwing sunlight into this space
Bimal Kadikar
Kadikar reports: “The banks calculated what they did with collateral and what Transcend would have done; on an annual basis, the improvement was $3 million for one and $9 million for the other for only a portion of their book.”
Kadikar mentions customers including large US based global banks, broker-dealers, big Canadian, European and Japanese banks.
He says: “We’re also getting incoming queries from some smaller broker-dealers looking for more sophisticated automation and controls.”
The firm is also talking to investors.
The next phase of uncleared margin rules later this year will also require the buyside to post collateral. They will need systems to handle this efficiently.
Competition
Transcend will have plenty of competition. In June, SmartStream Technologies, the financial transaction lifecycle management solutions provider, revealed that KeyBank had gone live with its cloud-based collateral management solution – offering coverage for cleared and non-cleared, OTC derivatives, repo and securities lending margining.
Paula Janofsky, swap operations director at KeyBank, states: “Moving to the cloud enabled us to further improve and automate our operational and credit risk strategies, and reduce our internal infrastructure and support costs”.