The weeklyFiX was sent a note this week saying that the Polish government was discussing a new regulation that would result in the cancellation of currency options transactions written by some of the country’s exporters. The news, first mooted back in December caused quite a sharp move in EUR/PLN. It also rekindled memories of the debacle in Russia in 1998, when a dodgy Micex fixing resulted in many Western banks having to wear losses when they thought they should be booking profits.
Commerzbank’s Ulrich Leuchtmann describes the plans as worrying: “Polish exporters in the past regularly hedged their future EUR incomes against a PLN appreciation. Now, most of these hedges are producing losses. Some of these transactions allegedly were done without informing the customers about potential risks. While it is certainly true that a bank that violated rules about the duty to inform should be punished. But such issues normally should be regulated by courts on a case-to-case basis. Putting all banks that offered such hedging strategies under general suspicion and cancelling trades without a case-by-case check would be an act that would undermine the confidence of foreign investors in the basic principles of contract certainty. In the last four quarters reported, Poland attracted €14.6 billion of foreign direct investment. Contract certainty is a condition sine qua non for foreign investment. While details of the government’s plan still must be awaited, the possibility of excessive measures is a risk for the PLN right now.”
According to one emerging market trader, the problem has arisen for reasons that also occurred in Mexico, Korea and Brazil. As exporters found that the cost of hedging was getting expensive, they sold puts on their own currency to reduce their expenditure. Unfortunately, many had what can only be described as a massive rush of blood to the head and over-leveraged, possibly by as much as 32 times.
They have now discovered that currencies do not always move in straight lines and to make things worse, the ensuing zloty weakness has occurred broadly at the same time as the demand for their exports started to subside. It will be interesting to see if the positions were put on because banks suggested they were a good idea or because a few treasurers thought they were cleverer than the market.