Hedge funds: No more secret stock stashes

UK Takeover Panel amends its rules on contracts for difference.

Hedge fund managers in the UK will find it harder to build up secret stakes in companies following amendments to takeover rules.

In November, the UK Takeover Panel altered Rule 8 of its Takeover Code to ensure that hedge funds in the UK will be forced to declare if they hold more than 1% of a company through derivatives during takeovers. Hedge fund managers have been able to use derivatives such as contracts for difference to gain exposure to companies’ shares.

“Two years ago, Shami Ahmed of Joe Bloggs Jeans was the first to use derivatives to build up a significant stake in Moss Bros through Cantor Fitzgerald. Then, last year, Philip Green used CFDs in his bid for Marks & Spencer. Hedge funds holding CFDs played an important role in that bid by trying to pressure the M&S board to allow Green to carry out due diligence,” says Rita Dattani, a senior lawyer in the corporate finance department at law firm Norton Rose.

Most recently, unbeknown to the market, London hedge fund Polygon managed to build up a 13.9% stake through CFDs in retail group Peacock, which was in the course of a management buy-out.

For hedge fund managers, the amendment to the ruling is a double-edged sword. Ed Murray is a partner at law firm Allen & Overy and acted as counsel to the Isda working group that responded to the two Takeover Panel consultation documents on the rule changes earlier this year. “They’ll be able to benefit from the greater amount of information in the market, but at the same time will find it harder to disguise their own strategies.”

Dattani and Murray say hedge fund managers have not been uniformly negative about the rule change, but some have grumbled about yet another operational burden. “We’ve had conversations with managers where they don’t regard the rule as a disaster, but certainly a pain,” says Murray. Dettani points out the three-month period that managers have to get the operations for disclosure in place is ample.

Although hedge fund managers are generally merely ruffled by the rule, the dealers that provide the CFDs are downright annoyed. They buy the CFDs’ underlying shares and can agree to vote them at the direction of hedge funds.

Murray says: “Dealers think that managers will be more reluctant to go into merger arbitrage strategies during an offer period. That will decrease activity, and they don’t believe there is reason to disclose purely synthetic positions.”

Dealers argue that far fewer of them vote on behalf of hedge fund managers than the Takeover Panel thinks. “Most dealers have a strict internal rule that they will not vote shares bought to hedge a CFD on behalf of the holder. But the Panel believes that they will do so in practice, notwithstanding such internal rule, as a matter of commercial pressure/reality,” says Murray.

One dealer adds: “In practice, there are many price players that would have no influence and would not vote. Disclosing these transactions is a waste of time.”

Murray adds that dealers think the ruling will lead to an information overload in the market. “The issue comes in the chains of CFDs. You can sell a CFD to a manager that could lay off the risk in a swap and so on, so that there is a chain. The ruling commands that each holder has to disclose its position, so you could end up with multiples of synthetic positions being disclosed – far more than are relevant.”

The UK Takeover Panel argues, however, that too much information is better than not enough, and that the market will work out how to deal with it. It says it will review the rule amendment in 18 months.