Leading European private-equity firm Doughty Hanson finally launched its long-delayed fourth buy-out fund at the end of October but will have to work hard to convince investors to hand over their money.
Doughty Hanson first planned to launch the fund last autumn but decided to postpone it due to the impact of the events of September 11. The New York tragedy certainly closed off a number of exit routes.
At that time, as well as hoping to raise new funds, Doughty Hanson was planning IPOs for several companies, such as LM Glasfiber, but found that it couldn’t get these off the ground. CDC also pulled out of a secondary buy-out of Doughty Hanson’s investment in Dunlop Aerospace and the firm then failed to list the company on Nasdaq.
A banker involved with private equity at an investment bank says in Doughty Hanson’s defence: “The LM Glasfiber IPO was pulled last year because they didn’t like the valuation.” Referring to Dunlop he adds: “Charterhouse was due to sign on 9/11. Then they tried to IPO last summer but there was no IPO market. Dick Hanson didn’t like the prices so he decided to hold it so they could get a higher multiple.”
Nonetheless, the lack of realizations from the firm’s third fund could make it difficult to raise a fourth. One banker says of the latest fund: “They’ll probably have a good first close because they have enough existing investors. But the question is whether they will reach their target [of around e3 billion]. I don’t see how unless they show realizations [on their third fund] between now and next year.”
Doughty Hanson does have a good track record for its first and second funds. According to figures disclosed on Calpers’ website as of December 2000 detailing its investment in Doughty Hanson’s second fund, the firm had an internal rate of return (IRR) of 45.1% on $39.53 million capital contributed with a total value multiple of 1.80 times.
The University of Texas Investment Management Company (Utimco) also disclosed figures as of August 31 2002 on its investment in Doughty Hanson’s second and third funds. The university’s $27.58 million investment in Doughty Hanson’s second fund, which closed in 1996, had an IRR of 50.21%.
Between a rock and a hard place But later figures look less impressive as Doughty Hanson, like all private-equity firms, found itself squeezed between high acquisition prices in the last years of the boom and poor exit opportunities since. Utimco’s $40 million investment in Doughty Hanson’s third fund, $33.69 million of which had been drawn as of August 31 2002, had a 5.74% IRR.
It is also important for investors to ensure that the same partners who worked on the successful funds are still contributing to the current one. Patrick Smulders, a general partner at Doughty Hanson, has been with the firm since 1994 but will not be working full-time on the firm’s fourth fund. A few years ago, Kevin Comolli also left the firm to return to the US to join a venture-capital firm. But, Stephen Marquardt, managing director at Doughty Hanson, says: “We still have the original core team of five founders which we’ve had since 1985.”
Doughty Hanson will have to convince investors that it can repeat its earlier performances and that the lack of return on its third fund can be attributed to the difficult market environment.