Disgrace at the heart of Europe

After nearly a decade of fanfare, the single European market for financial services is a ghost of what it should be. Turf battles, protectionism, and the inertia of Brussels decision-making conspire to frustrate cross-border financial business. There's still no Europe-wide bank account. But the euro and the pressure of electronic commerce have panicked EU mandarins. Things are moving - a decade too late. Behold the Financial Services Action Plan. David Shirreff reports.

Objectives of the financial services action plan

If God, Niccolò Machiavelli, or Isambard Kingdom Brunel had designed the single European market they would now be standing in the corner with a dunce’s cap on. Financial services, which should be at the heart of the single market and the engine of pan-European growth, are still stuck behind national barriers. It is as if the launch of the single market in 1992 and the introduction of a pan-European currency in 11 countries this January have added nothing to the quality of services that retail consumers or even the average company can enjoy.

The problems have been protectionism – a fear that once the floodgates are open the Anglo-Saxons will dominate financial services – turf wars within the European Commission, and turf wars between the 15 member states. The enemy has been the time it takes to draw up and refine European legislation, or a common code of conduct, and then enforce it.

It’s impossible to have a pan-European bank account. Retail bank charges for intra-euro business are still excessive – conversions between components of the euro average 5.5%, and cross-border transfers 8.4%, according to Christa Randzio-Plath, chair of the European parliament’s economic and monetary affairs committee. Fund managers in most countries are protected from foreign competition – by tax laws and conduct-of-business rules.

ABN Amro has been trying for years to establish a bank account usable across Europe. “Technically it’s possible, legally it’s an enormous problem,” says Jaap Kamp, head of ABN Amro’s EU (European Union) liaison office in Brussels. “Registering is difficult, there are different reporting requirements, there are different set-off and bankruptcy laws and solvency ratios.” This sort of thing wasn’t discussed when Europe went headlong into monetary union, Kamp says.

Precisely because of the euro, and the rapid development of electronic commerce, these national barriers have become a huge irritation. A pan-European company, for example, such as Shell or Unilever, has to run 15 separate pension funds for its employees, because of variations in tax laws between the EU states.

For years since 1992 countries anxious to preserve their retail savings base have pussyfooted around single-market measures, invoking special treatment for cultural reasons or the great fallback argument that such-and-such a measure would interfere on their home turf with “the general good”.

Wholesale markets were also trapped behind national barriers. But the advent of the euro largely eliminated the technical obstacles to a wholesale market spanning at least 11 if not 15 countries. Already there is one euro money and capital market whose common dynamic is credit and liquidity. Only legal obstacles remain before this business becomes freely cross-border, for example uncertainty about title to collateral, bankruptcy and set-off, variations in takeover codes, and a huge row about tax harmonization.

The European Commission in Brussels, divided into its 42 (now reduced to 36) directorates-general (DGs) and services, was late to recognize the need for urgent action to perfect the wholesale market, and to begin the work of creating a cross-border retail market. Mario Monti, until July commissioner for the internal market and taxation affairs, had been preoccupied by taxation until early 1998, a year from Emu. Yves Thibault de Silguy, commissioner for economic and financial affairs, and by many accounts a lightweight, showed a little more foresight on the macroeconomic side, harnessing the expertise of the private sector, represented by the Giovannini group, to ensure that at least the infrastructure of payments and settlements worked from day one of Emu.

In early 1998, with the UK assuming its six-month presidency of the European Council, the directorate-general for internal market and financial affairs (DG15 – although the commission has stopped using numbers and prefers to use names) began to draft what it called a “framework for action”. This was an attempt to draw together all the pieces of EU legislation and guidelines on financial affairs (57 financial affairs directives have been passed so far), all the work that was pending, and fit them into a coherent future plan, with a timetable, deadlines and priorities.

Knowledge from the coalface

DG15 set up its private-sector financial services review group, which included – horror of horrors – experts from US investment banks. Why should American bankers have a say in the creation of the European single market? Certainly that question was asked in Brussels. But the overloaded staff of DG15 insisted they needed knowledge from the coalface on such things as use of collateral, the function of wholesale markets, exchanges and clearing-houses, use of derivatives and other details of the fast-changing markets. They were right. The financial services action plan bears the hallmark of people who know what they are talking about.

But DG15 had to be cunning. The decision-making process in Brussels demands enormous stealth and diplomacy. DG15 covers only some aspects of financial services. There is an overlap with DG2 (economic and financial affairs), DG4 (competition), DG5 (employment and social affairs), DG21 (taxation) and DG24 (consumer affairs). So by drawing up a comprehensive action plan DG15 is already treading on toes. Officially, the existence of turf battles between DGs is hotly denied, but they exist. DGs, unless they are careful, tend to operate in silos, sometimes ignoring the impact on the DG next door. DG15, for example, is furious with DG2 for releasing papers on bank supervision that “contain factual errors”, according to one bank supervisor. DG15 itself was caught out some time back when it failed to spot the implications of an electronic data directive on the recording of dealing-room conversations: the European parliament had to scrabble together an amendment.

To keep its “framework for financial action” on track, DG15 in January 1998 set up a politically correct financial services policy group, chaired by Monti himself, sporting big names in finance ministries and supervisory bodies. The FSPG met four (and a half) times last year. Its members carried enough weight with their ministers to put financial services high on the agenda at twice-annual meetings of Ecofin (the council of EU finance ministers). Ecofin, according to DG15 officials, now “owns” the project, which means that EU finance ministers will exert peer pressure if any country appears to be dragging its feet on financial services legislation. The ultimate weapon is to put any unresolved grievance on the agenda of the IGC (inter-governmental conference) a meeting of EU ministers to discuss policy matters of the highest importance, such as EU enlargement.

If only that meant the financial services action plan would stick to its timetable. But the blessing of Ecofin, although encouraging, is not enough. DG15 must coordinate decision-making on the bits and pieces of its plan from the earliest drafts (green papers), through consultation, parliamentary committees, full parliament hearings, committees of the European Council, at the same time taking punches from professional lobbyists, pan-European financial services federations, and comments from individual countries. Whatever momentum is generated at avenue de Cortenberg 107, the rather shabby home of DG15, can be dissipated in a trice by one recalcitrant country, or a bunch of bleeding-heart MEPs (members of the European parliament) hung up on consumer rights.

Pressure from the euro

Nevertheless, this time there is finite pressure from the rapidly changing financial market itself. The advent of the euro and the stateless growth of the internet make a nonsense of many barriers to cross-border business. The EU drafted a directive on e-commerce last year. Unfortunately it was drawn up in such haste that it is likely to conflict with another directive on distance selling (selling cross-border by mail, telephone or internet). But the pressure to do cross-border business electronically will force a solution.

Similarly, DG15 is anticipating the use of electronic money, although there are few examples so far. It has drawn up draft legislation on the prudential supervision of e-money intermediaries.

In the wholesale market, there is pressure from financial institutions in five areas: to have certainty on use of collateral across borders; to have a clear definition of inter-professional, sophisticated counterparties and investors who can deal free of consumer-protection clauses; to have pan-European rules on market abuse; to establish rules on where a transaction between professionals is deemed to have taken place; and the standardizing of prospectuses.

DG15 launched its programme “Financial services: implementing the framework for financial markets: action plan”, on May 11. The next day Monti was in London, delivering a speech at the Mansion House that explicitly linked progress on market liberalization with a row on withholding tax. Germany wants member states to set a levy at source of 20% on interest earned on private savings. Most members agree that tax harmonization in this area would level the playing field, but not Luxembourg and the UK, which fear that agency business in Eurobonds will be driven offshore. There is a fierce debate between market practitioners and government officials on how much damage this would do to the Eurobond market, and to London and Luxembourg as financial centres, and how much revenue such a tax would ultimately raise.

Monti told his audience: “The simple fact is that further progress on creating a single financial market requires further progress on tax coordination.”

This raised the hackles of some EU watchers since it suggested that a single financial market is not an absolute goal but an object of horse trading. “Withholding tax can be applied tomorrow; the single market will take years to achieve, so what’s the connection?” asks Nick Collier, director of European policy at the International Swaps & Derivatives Association (Isda). Horse trading unfortunately is symptomatic of the way the European Commission is run, or at least was run until the forced resignation of its commissioners this March. Monti, who survived, and is now competition commissioner, showed that it’s difficult for a leopard to change his spots. Commission politics still rely on national quotas and bargaining chips of one sort or another. One bargaining chip is the post of director of financial affairs in DG15, which fell vacant in 1997 when Frenchman Jean-Pierre Fèvre retired, and is still vacant. Insiders suspect it was held empty as a bargaining chip, which couldn’t then be used in last year’s climate of scandal. Will incoming commissioner Frits Bolkestein, a Dutch liberal, now make an appointment?

Private sector forums

Bolkestein is not expected to veer from the main points of the financial services action plan. In July, John Mogg, director-general for financial affairs, invited 25 European finance industry federations to submit names of market practitioners to participate in five “forum groups” covering aspects of the plan: setting rules on market manipulation; upgrading the investment services directive (ISD); improving finality on cross-border use of collateral; standardizing consumer information for financial services; addressing obstacles raised in the name of the “general good”.

Mogg approached the federations to avoid the criticism last year that he had by-passed them and gone straight to practitioners – some of them American.

The forum groups should be selected by early October and will meet three or four times. As with last year’s practitioners’ group nothing will be published directly but their work will be distilled into DG15 proposals. The FSPG will continue to meet and report on progress to Ecofin twice a year.

Mogg’s task is to keep all interested parties involved. He has to ensure that the creation of the FSPG and the close involvement of Ecofin doesn’t sideline the EU’s permanent committees: the banking advisory committee, the insurance committee and the high level securities supervisors committee. Then there is the relationship with parliamentary committees and European financial industry federations. Since the September 1997 Amsterdam Treaty, parliament has had greater powers to refine legislation, although it still can’t initiate new law, only amend it – some commentators believe it should become a legislative body.

Committee wrangles

The workings of the European parliament and its 17 committees are labyrinthine. The economic and monetary affairs committee (Emac) is supposed to examine all proposals on financial affairs, except those with a legal slant or with a broad internal market dimension, such as winding-up of banks and insurance companies, and electronic commerce, which are handled by the legal affairs committee. The legal affairs committee used to handle legislation on pensions and UCITS (undertakings for collective investments in transferable securities – or unit trusts) until a recent decison to hand them to Emac. A previous plan was to hand everything to Emac, but the legal affairs committee ignored it. It’s still uncertain which committee will handle legislation on financial infrastructure and it’s more likely to be decided by a fight than some Olympian decision. “Nobody reads those decisions,” says John Houston, a Brussels lobbyist. He worries that spreading financial proposals over three or more committees (the consumer affairs committee is also involved) leads to a dilution of rare MEP expertise in financial services. “A lot of MEPs don’t know the decision [to hand everything to Emac] was coming unravelled,” Houston says.

DG15 now unashamedly calls for input from European federations and experts from among their members. “The commission is far more open than most national bureaucracies,” says Malcolm Levitt, adviser on EU affairs at Barclays and a former UK treasury man. He sits on another bridge-building body, a sub-committee of private-sector advisers to the Financial Services Intergroup, comprised of MEPs, which last year helped to shape the action plan.

Levitt has floated his own proposal for a Europe-wide network of ombudsmen to whom consumers can appeal if they have a complaint about a cross-border financial service. This avoids the expense and language difficulties of litigation in the provider’s country and encourages consumers to buy cross-border, because of the comfort of redress if things go wrong.

Of the 25 or so financial services federations and the 120 or so financial lobbyists in federations or other bodies in Brussels “only about 6% lobby actively”, says Houston, perhaps the best known among financial lobbyists. Most federations are more concerned with keeping their members informed and arbitrating between the various national positions than putting their views across, and then they tend to do it in writing, says Houston. “Federations traditionally put out position papers and wait for the phone call,” he says.

The active lobbyists have a vast constituency to cover, from the Finnish government (which currently has the presidency of the European Council), to governments next in line for the presidency, Portugal, France and Sweden – each country likes to leave its stamp on the presidency and that interest can be exploited. Then there is Coreper, the council of permanent ambassadors to the EU, then the Commission itself, and MEPs, especially those on the relevant parliamentary committees. Each topic in committee is handled by a rapporteur, whose sympathy is keenly sought.

Most active at direct lobbying are the European Banking Federation, the European Federation of Investment Funds & Companies (Fefsi) and the European Federation for Retirement Provision (EFRP).

Then there are capital-markets bodies such as Isda, Ipma (International Primary Markets Association, Isma (International Securities Market Association) and the Futures & Options Association (FOA). Liba (the London Investment Banking Association) has difficulty passing itself off as a pan-European federation, although London is perhaps the only centre in Europe for investment banking. Rather than change its name, Liba approaches the commission officially through Isda, although there is nothing to stop it making informal visits to DG15. But with DG15’s selection process for the forum groups “this is the first time they wish to speak only to European federations”, says Liba director Peter Beales, concerned that Liba wasn’t asked directly to put up candidates.

Some banks spend time and money lobbying individually in Brussels, notably ABN Amro, Deutsche Bank, Barclays, Citibank (also Salomon Smith Barney), Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs. NatWest has a Brussels liaison office.

Individual firms can respond more quickly than their federations to a sudden challenge. For example when a distance-selling directive was issued in April and a quick response was needed to parliamentary comments, a group of big banks mobilized to lobby MEPs, frame the right words, and square them with their federations later.

Deutsche Bank is said to be split between London and Frankfurt on the withholding-tax question, but Deutsche’s Brussels representative, Rainer Boden, is firmly in the pro-tax camp: “We’re in favour of liberalization in principle,” says Boden, “on the other hand we support Monti’s initiative on the famous tax question. I think what will go offshore is limited, provided we have an understanding with Switzerland [and other non-EU neighbours].”

Maximum and minimum

Kamp at ABN Amro is chairman of the intergroup sub-committee. ABN Amro and a handful of big banks support what is called “maximum harmonization” of EU rules, so that one institution can sell services Europe-wide under home regulation – it doesn’t have to bother about local regulatory nuances. The opposite, “minimum harmonization”, requires less work on common rule-making, but means that sellers of services must take account of local differences. That can be got around by an agreement on “mutual recognition” of the seller’s home state’s conduct-of-business rules. If this sounds complicated it is all designed to avoid an even greater complication, which is framing new EU legislation.

The new financial action plan will be pushed through as much as possible without reopening statutes or drafting new ones, to save time. Sometimes legislation can be tweaked with a new “interpretative document” from the European Commission. But sometimes parliament or the European Council rejects that route because it’s a fudge – trying to make the law say what wasn’t intended. If legislation is unavoidable then there is a fast track called Slim (simpler legislation for the internal market), which was introduced in 1997. Slim is already being applied to company law.

Despite these highly inventive mechanisms and measures it will be surprising if there is no slippage in the action-plan timetable. In fact there is some already. A large amount of work has been farmed out to Fesco (the Federation of European Securities Commissioners) in Paris. Fesco is looking at upgrading a directive on prospectuses, a directive on reporting requirements and a definition of the “sophisticated” investor. Because of foot-dragging at the national level it is already slipping on the prospectus timetable, say commission sources. Fesco, the brainchild of Tommaso Padoa-Schioppa, former chairman of Italian regulator Consob, took five years to set up because some national securities regulators were afraid it would be given statutory powers. Now there is talk of it becoming a pan-European securities and exchange commission. “If we had a single securities supervisor, many of today’s problems would go away,” says Steffen Matthias, secretary-general of Fefsi (the European Federation of Investment Funds & Companies). “Today the problem is mostly one of interpretation,” he adds.

Interpretation of existing law is the best expedient to avoid long and tortuous European legislation. But even if interpretation will work in one country, often another country needs a new law to achieve the same effect. An EU directive is the cleanest, but longest solution to harmonization. Experienced Brussels watchers aren’t holding their breath. “Everybody’s waiting for something to happen,” says Collier at Isda. “But there’s every likelihood there will be no legislation [to assist wholesale markets] within a decade of the euro.”

Bundled together

He’s also a little cynical about the packaging of the action plan. “Of the 42 or 43 elements of the action plan only two are new – collateral and market manipulation.” It’s as though DG15 has bundled everything together that needs doing and called it a plan.

At DG15, Mogg rejects suggestions that the plan is “piecemeal”. He runs through the plan’s four objectives: “First, wholesale markets; second, to catalyse the debate on how supervisory issues relate to the regulatory framework, with special reference to conglomerates; third, conduct of business, especially the retail end, and e-commerce; fourth, establishing a more effective, fast-track process for getting legislation through the commission, parliament and the European Council.” The framework tried to provide a coherent whole, says Mogg: “Within that framework, the answers are necessarily individual or ‘piecemeal’.”

Houston, the lobbyist, sees the plan as a step in the right direction: “It’s as far from piecemeal as we have been so far, although maybe it does adjust too far to the stuff that’s already on track.” For example the Commission has been discussing the upgrading of the investment services directive for years. But the important thing, says Chris Verhaegen at EFRP, “is that they had their plan agreed by the Council. It’s otherwise not always clear that the Commission will take any action”.

Basel calls the shots

External pressures are the best goad to action. For example the Commission is racing to respond to the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision’s proposed new supervisory framework. It intends to produce a green paper in November and member states and industry federations will be asked to respond by February or March. Delays will mean that once again the Basel committee will be calling the shots and its framework will have to be adapted retrospectively to cover investment firms. But to implement something close to the Basel framework, the Commission may have to reopen its 1989 solvency ratio directive (already amended once in 1996) and reinterpret its own funds directive (OFD). Other aspects may be achieved by supervisors issuing their own rules, or even by pieces of self-regulation. But the whole process, which will probably need new EU legislation, could take four years, predicts a UK treasury official.

Here, as in other aspects of the action plan, the Commission has to play down the suspicion of an Anglo-Saxon takeover. Yet so much of international financial services is driven by rules and practices flagged as American or Anglo-Saxon. One example is a takeover code: the UK believes its thresholds and best practice are the best regime. As the EU develops its rulebook, either it creates its own paradigm, or it adopts proven models from outside. It must avoid a “fortress Europe” mentality.

Electronic commerce and electronic money are two areas where EU law may lead rather than lag. US regulators have shied away from introducing e-commerce legislation. DG15 has drafted an e-commerce directive that is now before parliament. In the case of electronic money DG15 has a draft proposal that actually designs an e-money institution. It stipulates that an e-cash provider cannot give credit, and must keep its assets in the form of cash or government securities – not unlike the century-old concept of the “narrow bank”. The European Commission as law-maker and creator of a new kind of financial institution. Will it fly?