Indian Finance Minister: On downgrades, reversals and press misquotations

"I must confess to you that at times the BJP [Bharatiya Janata Party] is misunderstood, misreported and statements are quoted out of context," says India's new finance minister Yashwant Sinha.

“I must confess to you that at times the BJP [Bharatiya Janata Party] is misunderstood, misreported and statements are quoted out of context,” says India’s new finance minister Yashwant Sinha.

This is Sinha’s comment on BJP president Kushabhau Thakre’s observation that India should leave the World Trade Organization. Sinha says it was a misquote on the part of the Indian press. “He contradicted that statement the next day.”

Sinha talked to Euromoney on his and his party’s 100th day of government. That’s considerably longer than the BJP’s last and only other period of office in 1996. That attempt by India’s Hindu nationalist party to govern lasted only 16 days.

For investment bankers it may seem like a 100 days too many. During this short time, the BJP has tested nuclear devices, received US sanctions and been downgraded from investment grade to junk. “India was supposed to be a safe haven in a troubled Asia,” commented one banker. “But it’s blown it.” Another Indian-born banker was even more pessimistic: “I worry the sanctions will set us back 10 years.”

If Sinha is worried, he doesn’t readily show it. He says the world will have to get used to a more assertive India, and he dismisses fears that sanctions will drag India into recession. “The US’s own estimation is that sanctions might end up doing about $2 billion of damage. One doesn’t know,” he says. “Their own statements show that they’re aware of the fact that sanctions don’t work. So hopefully sanctions will not hurt India in the long run.”

Investors are not so sure. Foreign investors dumped $370 million of Bombay shares within six weeks of the nuclear blasts. helping pull down the Bombay stock exchange 22%. A ban on short-selling made matters worse – just as it did in Malaysia, where prime minister Mahathir pioneered this disastrous policy last September.

The rupee has been hit too – a fact that has not helped Indian corporates which borrowed $4.5 billion of dollar-denominated bonds last year. Meanwhile opponents have been quick to exploit the BJP’s apparent confusion on economic policy. Former finance minister Manmohan Singh told the Times of India : “Even now, one day the finance minister says the Reserve Bank of India will not intervene to prop up the rupee, the next day he says it will.”

Sinha does not react well to the charge that he has mishandled statements about the currency. He is especially sensitive about a comment attributed to him on market forces determining the rupee’s value – a statement which led to the currency getting hammered. “I did not make that statement. I was misquoted,” he says. “All that I have been saying in parliament and outside is that we are interested in orderly conditions in the market.”

His first budget – delivered at the beginning of June – was almost as explosive as India’s activities in the Pokhran desert. US rating agency Moody’s reacted shortly after by downgrading India to one notch above Indonesia.

Suitably enough, Sinha began his budget speech by describing it as “a defining moment in history” and couched his delivery in nationalistic invective. But strong talk quickly turned to embarassment, as four taxes and subsidies were repealed or altered within days. The first to go was a rise in petrol excise tax. This led one member of the opposition to observe that never in post-independence India had a tax been presented to parliament and reversed within 24 hours. The Economic Times of India characterized the budget as marred by “avoidable goofups”.

The second measure to be repealed was even more politically sensitive. Withholding tax, aimed at those with foreign borrowings, was similarly axed when it was calculated that it could add up to 35% to corporate borrowing costs at a time when sanctions are already hitting big Indian companies hard.

However, the most serious backdown was over the so called swadeshi tax. This tax was initially announced to resounding acclaim from Indian industrialists.The BJP has never made a secret of its nationalistic approach to economics, but even still this took many moderates by surprise. The swadeshi tax was an 8% import duty, and was immediately characterized as protectionist.

But ideological budgets don’t fit well with global markets, as Sinha was quickly to discover. Within days of the budget it became clear that even India’s industrialists found the new levy irksome. With such a large component of their raw materials imported, local corporates protested that the tax rise would have the opposite effect to that desired – it would make them less competitive. Some economists argued that it would add 2.5% to inflation. The finance minister rolled back the swadeshi tax to 4%.

Sinha explains: “What I did was impose 8% and then rolled it back to 4% for the simple reason that there was a considerable depreciation of the rupee after the presentation of the budget. To our way of thinking an import duty is needed to create a level playing field since local industry bears the burden of local taxes. Imports don’t. This is a countervailing duty to eliminate a disadvantage from which Indian industry suffers.”

Sinha declares that his changes represents “the spirit of accommodation” that runs through the new administration. The opposition, on the other hand, pointed out in parliament that the budget had been virtually re-written.

The overall impact of these budget about-turns was that the fiscal deficit rose from 5.6% of GDP to 5.8%. However, former finance minister Singh does not discount the possibility that a supplementary budget might be necessary later this year.

The budget assumes corporate tax collections will go up by 24%, industrial growth by 10% and a 7% growth in GDP – against 5% last year. Net foreign aid, ignoring the impact of sanctions on finance from the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank, is slated to double from R1,201 crore to R2,337 crore ($282 million to $550 million).

Asked about the above, Sinha replies: “I have worked out the figures on the basis of averages over the past five years, and the average of last year and this year. So I don’t think my budget estimates are unrealistic unless something very unusual happens over which nobody has any control.”

The budget does not take into account the possible negative impact of sanctions. Sinha told parliament in his budget speech that this is because he believes they “will not have any significant impact on our economic development”.

He told Euromoney that it was a budget for growth: “The growth rate we have factored in is between 6.5% and 7%, and I tell you I already see signs of revival.”

If these optimistic assumptions go awry, former finance minister Palianappan Chidambaram may use against Sinha the very words Sinha used to describe Chidambaram’s budget last year – “Alas, like magic, all this is untrue, just sleight of hand.”

Moody’s announced that its downgrade to Ba2 reflected its concerns “about India’s weakening macroeconomic balances”, and “in particular, the policy framework which appears to lack the necessary coherence to quickly address the deterioration in the external trade accounts and the public sector finances”.

It added that that sanctions are “likely to hamper efforts to overcome severe infrastructure constraints”. This will probably be the most damaging outcome of the government’s nuclear tests.

The BJP’s slogan may be “an India built by Indians” but given India’s need for $200 billion of investment in roads, power stations and telecoms in the next six and a half years it is difficult to see how this is achievable without foreign capital.

The swadeshi tax sent out a negative signal to foreigners, but the BJP claims not to be anti-foreign investment. It has put in place special legislation to fast track foreign investment, for example. Approvals will be instant for certain amounts.

Sinha also sent out a positive signal on privatization. In his budget he declared the government would take its stake in Indian Airlines below 50%, and that he would sell portions of VSNL, GAIL and IOC during the year to earn a budgeted R5000 crore.

However, the BJP does take an innovative approach to economics, and what is quickly becoming evident is that sometimes the ideas are better on paper than in practice. Take its initiative to boost exports. It was declared that all “incremental” exports could be financed at an interest rate of 6.5% – rather than the normal export credit rate of 11%.

No bank has yet made a loan at this rate. Bank of Baroda chairman R Kannan has said that while he and other bank chiefs were keen on providing credit to exporters under this new rate there were no set guidelines on determining what were incremental exports.

Exporters agree that it is not an easy thing to prove. It will take at least another six to seven months before any exporter can prove that his export level is increasing and thus claim the reduced rate.

Meanwhile interest rates are rising. The Reserve Bank of India has hiked yields on its issue of 10-year government securities to 12.10% from 12.00% and on six-year paper to 12.75% from 12.50%.

Sinha says India merits an investment-grade rating. “For one thing we are a large country and we have a very diversified economy. The whole thing does not collapse if something goes wrong over here, or over there,” he says. “The second thing is we have large reserves at the moment and so are capable of taking care of any emergency. The third thing is that while we had a slowdown last year, all the indications are that the slowdown was very temporary, very cyclical and the economy will pick up again. The fourth is that the budget will revive growth. I have analyzed the reasons for the cyclical slowdown as due to lack of government expenditure, and I have increased government expenditure in this budget. The fifth is we are keeping inflation under control. It might increase temporarily but that is due to seasonal factors.”

He is therefore rather sore on the subject of the Moody’s downgrade. “I can’t understand it. When they came here and met me, I explained the position to them and I thought they would take all this into account, but obviously they didn’t agree with our assessment. I have to say that I don’t agree with their assessment either.”

Moody’s decision to downgrade India beneath even Thailand and Korea pushed the Sensex stock index to a one year low, while spreads on Indian international debt widened over 150 basis points.

“We are a country which has never ever reneged on any international debt,” says Sinha. “This is a 50-year track record of which we are very proud. We have gone through the severest difficulties and periods of extreme crisis, but India has never allowed either the government or the public or private sector to default on any international debt. I was the finance minister in 1991 when we faced an extreme balance-of-payments crisis and I mortgaged the country’s gold so as to be able to meet our international commitments.”

He believes India is being victimized for mistakes the agencies made elsewhere: “It is well known they did not anticipate the east Asian meltdown. If they are so good in their job then they should have known. They have failed there and that’s why they are erring on the side of too much caution now. If you can’t find fault with me, I’ll downgrade you by two notches and then I’m safe. But they’re increasingly doing damage to their own credibility.”

After 100 days in power, the BJP’s biggest problem will be keeping its coalition together – or as Moody’s termed it “the fractious political environment”. The Samata Party is also beginning to get rather impatient with the BJP since there seems to be no sign of the government imposing central rule in the state of Bihar. Says Nitish Kumar, Samata Party leader and railway minister: “Even the Patna high court has observed that there is no government worth the name and jungle raj is prevailing in that state.”

More worrying still are the antics of the AIADMK, which wants the Karunanidhi government in Tamil Nadu declared unconstitutional and overthrown – something even the BJP is reluctant to do. The leader of AIADMK is a real threat to the survival of the government and has even gone on the record as saying the government’s home minister has “scant regard for the nation’s security”.

Sinha – finance minister briefly in 1991 – dismisses this: “There are issues where [our coalition partners] might have a difference of opinion. We are not agreed on all issues. But this is all part of the democratic process.” Steven Irvine