June 2006
Best debt house 2006: League tables tell only half the story
Euromoney’s new poll shows that, according to the world’s largest issuers, Deutsche and Citigroup have the quality as well as the quantity of business to maintain their leading positions. But, as Alex Chambers reports, the results also throw up some interesting contradictions.
Full poll results
Methodology
Debt poll of polls: Customer votes reveal the new big three
Primary debt poll
| Quality versus quantity |
| League table Vs poll results |
| Bank |
Category |
League table |
Poll result |
Up/Down |
| JPMorgan |
USD international |
1 |
5 |
-4 |
| Goldman Sachs |
USD international |
9 |
4 |
+5 |
| Calyon |
ABS international |
8 |
3 |
+5 |
| UBS |
Euro international |
15 |
3 |
+12 |
| Citigroup |
Hybrid international |
13 |
4 |
+9 |
| SG |
Euro international |
6 |
8 |
-2 |
| Lehman |
All MTNs |
4 |
8 |
-4 |
| RBS |
ABS international |
3 |
11 |
-8 |
| Source: Dealogic, Euromoney |
MEASURING THE PERFORMANCE and competence of debt intermediaries is far from straightforward. What is to be gained from simply looking at which institution is conducting the largest deal volume? Those banks willing to buy market share by subsidizing bond transactions for opportunistic borrowers can easily manipulate the most obvious quantitative performance measures such as league tables. The intense competition for business in debt has meant that this type of activity is extremely common. And even if the league tables are taken at face value, many aspects of debt provision are not captured by such simple measures.
More information on primary debt poll
Access to this content is for level 2 subscribers. You do not currently have access to this content, to gain access subscribe or call our hotline on +44 (0)207 779 8999.
If you are a level 2 subscriber but have yet to sign in to the site, please log in now to view this content.
If you are a trialist or subscriber, please enter your username and password at the top right-hand side of euromoney.com
Subscribers to Euromoney benefit from:
Level 1:
- Online access to the past 12 months content
- Tailored RSS news feeds direct to your desktop
- News delivered directly to your mobile device or PC
- Personalised email newsfeed of 'Top stories' and 'Breaking news'
Level 2:
- Exclusive access to euromoney.com - Read the latest issue early online, search for specific developments by region or sector, interrogate the results of Euromoney's benchmark polls, and view the archive dating back to 2000
- 12 monthly issues of Euromoney magazine
- More than 30 specialist research guides free
- The results of Euromoney’s polls and surveys
- Tailored RSS news feeds direct to your desktop
- News delivered directly to your mobile device or PC
- Personalised email newsfeed of 'Top stories' and 'Breaking news'
Click here to subscribe